Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Climate Confident is for business leaders, climate professionals and policymakers who need to understand what is actually cutting emissions—and what it takes to make those solutions work at scale.
Each Wednesday, technology and sustainability analyst, keynote speaker and former SAP Global VP Tom Raftery speaks with the executives, engineers, scientists, founders and policymakers turning climate ambition into measurable progress. Together, they examine the technologies, business models, policies and implementation strategies reshaping energy, transport, industry, supply chains, food and finance.
These are not conversations about distant targets, vague pledges or greenwash. They are candid discussions about what is working, what is failing, where the real bottlenecks lie, and how leaders can make better decisions about decarbonisation, resilience, investment and risk.
You will hear:
- Proven approaches to reducing emissions
- Hard-earned lessons from real-world implementation
- Analysis of the markets, technologies and policies driving the transition
- Honest examination of costs, trade-offs, setbacks and unintended consequences
- Practical ideas for turning climate commitments into action
New episodes are published every Wednesday at 7am CET. Subscribers also receive bonus episodes featuring highlights, analysis and emerging themes from across the series.
Follow Climate Confident for practical climate solutions, informed debate and the insights you need to turn ambition into measurable progress.
Guest suggestions and feedback are welcome at Tom@tomraftery.com.
Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Supercharge Me - How To Get To Net Zero - A Chat With Corinne Sawers And Eric Lonergan
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Get in touch - leave me a message
There is a new book on climate which has been recently released which I think is worth paying attention to. It is called Supercharge Me.
Why do I think it is worth paying attention to? Because it takes a different tack to most other books. It proposes a manifesto of actions which if followed, should deliver net zero. what kind of actions? The ones that actually matter - policy and regulatory tweaks which can serve to change the incentives to act.
I invited the authors of this book Corinne Sawers and Eric Lonergan to come on the podcast to tell me more.
We had a fascinating conversation covering why they decided to write the book, the kinds of policy and regulatory tweaks that can make the biggest differences, and how to ensure these policy hacks are actually rolled out in the world.
This was an excellent episode of the podcast and I learned loads as always, and I hope you do too.
If you have any comments/suggestions or questions for the podcast - feel free to leave me a voice message over on my SpeakPipe page, head on over to the Climate 21 Podcast Forum, or just send it to me as a direct message on Twitter/LinkedIn. Audio messages will get played (unless you specifically ask me not to).
And if you want to know more about any of SAP's Sustainability solutions, head on over to www.sap.com/sustainability, and if you liked this show, please don't forget to rate and/or review it. It makes a big difference to help new people discover the show. Thanks.
And remember, stay healthy, stay safe, stay sane!
Music credit - Intro and Outro music for this podcast was composed, played, and produced by my daughter Luna Juniper
Sign up to Climate Confident+ for deep dive analysis of the major climate and energy stories of the day.
Podcast subscribers
I'd like to sincerely thank this podcast's amazing subscribers:
- Anita Krajnc
- Cecilia Skarupa
- Ben Gross
- Jerry Sweeney
- Andreas Werner
- Stephen Carroll
- Roger Arnold
And remember you too can Subscribe to the Podcast - it is really easy and hugely important as it will enable me to continue to create more excellent Climate Confident episodes like this one, as well as give you access to the entire back catalog of Climate Confident episodes.
🎤 Looking for a keynote speaker on climate, energy, AI, or sustainability?
I help executive audiences understand the technologies, trends, and decisions shaping the low-carbon transition.
Download my Speaker Pack: https://tinyurl.com/spkrpck
And a quick note before you go: I’ve started a new Reddit community for serious, evidence-led discussion on climate solutions, clean energy, decarbonisation, policy, technology, and what actually works in practice.
If you’d like to suggest future guests, challenge ideas from the show, or share climate reports and solutions worth discussing, join us at r/ClimateConfident
To why doesn't Denmark borrow its low to 3% Pass that capital over to India. She's going to invest it in a whole lot of green infrastructure, which Denmark then owns part of. And that's, that's an income generating asset. Denmark's making money, and India has access to a lower cost of capital. So then the number of projects that can finance goes from a small share, which makes sense on that 10% cost of capital to a much bigger share, which makes sense on a 3% cost of capital.
Tom Raftery:Good morning, good afternoon, or good evening wherever you are in the world. This is the climate 21 podcast, the number one podcast showcasing best practices in climate emissions reductions. And I'm your host, global vice president for SAP. Tom Raftery. Climate 21 is the name of an initiative by SAP to allow our customers calculate, report and reduce their greenhouse gas emissions. In this climate 21 podcast, I will showcase best practices and thought leadership by SAP, by our customers by our partners on by our competitors if their game in climate emissions reductions. Don't forget to subscribe to this podcast in your podcast app of choice to be sure you don't miss any episodes. Play everyone, welcome to the climate 21 podcast. My name is Tom Raftery with SAP and with me on the podcast today I have my two special guests, Corinne and Eric. Folks, would you like to introduce yourselves? Maybe Corrine go first?
Corinne Sawers:Sure. So I have been working in climate consulting, essentially, with businesses and governments, the last 1213 years my whole career essentially. So have had a kind of inside out view of how businesses have been thinking about this topic. Obviously, there's been a massive evolution in that time. And I have co authored supercharged me with Eric, which is what we're here to talk about today.
Tom Raftery:Super, and Eric. Yeah,
Eric Lonergan:I'm the I'm the nerdy economist in the team. So I've been my my day job is as a macro investor. So I run a an institutional investment fund, which I've been working in financial markets and in policy economics. Well, for about 25 years now. And I've my main passion and interest is in is really in policy and applying the ideas of economics to policy. And so it was kind of I guess, those are the two voices, corn with expertise and sustainability and me coming more from the sort of policy and economic side of things.
Tom Raftery:And so you decided to write this book supercharged me. What was the thinking behind that?
Corinne Sawers:Yeah, perhaps I'll start and Eric can jump in. First of all, we were living and breathing, the changes going on in in the business and finance sector in our day jobs. You know, the last couple of years, there's been a huge transformation. You know, sustainability and climate has gone from being in the corporate world, quite a niche sized topic to a board level priority. And we're suddenly seeing this, there's a there's a moment in time where the corporate world and business world are taking this seriously. But we felt as many people feel this transition is not happening fast enough. And there isn't a clear manifesto for action. You know, people will say we need to end our reliance on fossil fuels. But But how? And you ask the man on the street, he can't tell you how. And we have various ideas about how to fill that gap. But we need to we need to write the manifesto.
Eric Lonergan:Yeah, I think for me, personally, I had there were two things that that really galvanized me and made me want to write the book with Corinne. One is I had a meeting maybe four or five years ago now with Adair Turner. I don't know if you're familiar with Adair Turner, but uh, definitely, you know, has been a big, sort of intellectual leader of the the kind of sustainability movement in the United Kingdom has chaired a lot of government commissions. And I was working on some policy for government in the UK. And I sat them down and just said, like, if there were three things you could do to really make a difference on emissions, what would they be? And he put it, he pretty much said like, if you if we make the grid sustainable, and if we get everything that we can onto the grid, will reduce emissions by something like 70% We don't know precisely but something like that. So priority number one has to be to make the the electricity generation in our society sustainable. And this really resonated with me because I professionally I'd been looking at at wind farm investments. And what amazed me was how quickly they could be done. Right? So I suddenly thought to myself, there's a confluence of factors here that are really interesting to me. When I look at this as a policy economist, which is the big way to have an impact quick Pleased to electrify is to make the electricity sustainable. The the lead times to make electricity generation are really short. And then the final piece of the puzzle for me is that, and this is my day job is the government's cost of capital is incredibly low. Now people might go, Well, you know, what's the government's cost capital? What is this jargon? What does that mean? that effectively means that our governments in the developed world can borrow today at the lowest levels of interest rates in human history. And that's how you finance investments in electricity. So I'm thinking, this problem is a lot more tractors a lot analytically clear. And I feel suddenly quite passionate that this, people should know this. And we should be doing it. And then as Karen said, we were working in home during COVID. And I think we suddenly these ideas just starting to come together. And also working with somebody where I could just go to current and say, you know, biodiversity, just get to the heart of this and explain it to me. And then we just felt, you know, the ideas were kind of coming thick and fast. But this sort of core belief that we had a framework for making the problem clear, and then really coming up with concrete policy ideas that could have a dramatic impact was really a really big motivation. And I guess just what the final thing there is that, you know, I've read so many books on climate change, and particularly on climate change policy. And both of us felt there's no manifesto, which says, This is how you do it. Okay. Right. So so there's some great books that make you absolutely terrified. There are some great books like donut economics, by Kiera with that help you to rethink economics. There's great science, there's great clarity of expression, if I look at something like like Bill Gates's book, but I always go to the section on so what are we going to do? And I just felt like, either rely on technology and capitalism, or you know, stop flying and become vegan. None of that was satisfactory to me. And that was what we felt we really needed to write that book.
Tom Raftery:Okay, I mean, I totally get that. It's those those steps that you talked about, you know, going vegan, stopping flying, or like and stuff. Those are very individual things that we can do as individuals, but it's not up to us as individuals, that's been kind of the great victory that the fossil fuel companies have had, it's they've managed to distract people by saying, it's the fault of the people who are using our products, not us for actually making the product, there has to be a systemic level change, I think, which means that if we do choose to fly, or if we do choose to eat meat, it doesn't have the current carbon costs that it has today. And is that what you mean, when you talk about the framework and how we change?
Corinne Sawers:Yeah, you perhaps we'll talk a bit about our kind of framework and how we think about it. First of all, you know, bang on what, one thing we were relentlessly tough on ourselves on is realism and pragmatism. You know, and like we said, there's folks calling for, you know, us holding the global economy, we just don't think that's realistic. You know, both of us are students of behavioral economics in different ways. And psychology, human behavior changes unbelievably hard. You know, so we, we really came down in every domain bit corporate world, the financial world, you know, household spending, to first principles about how these different agents really changed behavior. And that frames everything. So you know, we have this, this sort of saying, humans change behavior, if the alternative is cheaper, better, or their friends are doing it. Companies change behavior if they can make more money. And governments have to get elected, and that guides their behavior. Right. So this, and some people don't, don't like this. And this isn't to say that we don't think it's great that people are going vegan and, and flying less, but betting on the whole global population doing that is not a realistic bet. So we have 10 years to harbor missions, as you're well known to, to stay kind of close to 1.5 degrees, time is incredibly short. We have to pick strategies and bets which have a very high likelihood of working. So that that frames it. And part of our framework is also as Eric alluded to, this is essentially the greatest reallocation of capital, kind of is certainly in living memory. Yeah, potentially in human history, we are rebuilding the vast majority of the economy to be a low carbon version. And we kind of get it that we frame that in the book by breaking down the types of problems in climate change two to three categories, which helps us think about how we address them. The first category is where there is a technology, and it's relatively affordable. So that's kind of most types of clean energy generation and transmission. We call this simple maps, because all you need to do there is really make the numbers work to allocate the capital. Sure, we have a second type of problem where technology isn't quite there. So that might be green cement, or green aviation fuel, these technologies are not quite there, we call that mini masks, we need more mini masks to try and solve those problems quickly, and get the technologies where they need to be. And then the third type of problem is what we call herding sheep. And this is mass behavioural change. This might be where diets come in, you know, less meat and dairy consumption. And our tomorrow analysis based on energy transitions Commission's and many of the leading respected bodies out there thinking about this suggests that 70% of the problem 70% of emissions falls into that first category of simple maths. And that is really good news, because that is the easiest one to solve. We'd be in trouble if 70% of it was in herding sheep, as humans are really, really hard. So So that's, that's our frame. Thank goodness, this is basically a capital reallocation problem. We need to work out how to solve that simple. It's not that we don't have to solve that other 30% We absolutely do. But given the timeframes, we've also got to do the easy stuff, ASAP. Because we can't solve aviation fuel just yet. We need to make sure we're doing everything else we can whilst that technology is evolving. Okay.
Tom Raftery:How do we do it? How do we how do we make? I mean, I know it's simple maths. But it has been simple maths for a couple of years now. And yeah, yeah, it's happening in some places, but not in others. Yeah, yeah.
Corinne Sawers:I'll introduce our concept of epics. And I'm sure we'll pick it up and run with it. So epics is one of the core concepts of our solutions. It stands for extreme positive incentives for change. And we got onto this idea of epics because we were looking at the success stories, you know, it's the first place to start is what has actually worked, where has there been a rapid transformation in a part of the economy. And this theme of extreme positive incentives came up, it came up in the rapid collapse in cost of solar, which was driven by huge subsidies by the Japanese, Chinese and the Germans. Essentially, it was behind the the Scandinavians, particularly the Norwegians getting EVs to be 90% share of new car sales, behind the success in offshore wind in the UK. So so we thought I could have something in this in practice. And it makes sense intuitively, it makes sense that people respond, people and institutions, companies respond better to a positive incentive to getting a cheaper mortgage, if they insulate their home versus being faced with a tax, if they don't, they risk they get on board with it, they don't try and block it. Or if their company, they don't go into sort of lobbying, you know, or corporate capture to try and block it. So there's a basic psychological point about the power of positive incentives and getting folks on board. And then the importance of extreme is, as we said, we're wholesale reorganizing the economy here. So we have to get the majority of whether it's people changing what they eat, or households shifting how they heat themselves, or, or construction companies changing what steel they use, we have to get the majority to change. So we have to the incentive as extreme enough to get the majority to change. And as well as that there's fairly strong evidence to suggest that the effect of incentives is nonlinear. So there will be a threshold point where it will affect it, there's a disproportionate impact, essentially. So so those are epics. I'll maybe hand over to Eric and talk a bit more about them and how we think about applying them in different contexts.
Eric Lonergan:Yeah, so So the epic and extreme positive incentive for change. It sounds complicated. It's really, really simple. If you look at what the Norwegians have done with electric vehicles. They've said we're actually going to make the list price of the electric vehicle. So when you go into a car dealership, the electric vehicle is going to be the cheaper alternative. And not only that they have like a 50% rule, which is big. That everything that you do with your car, whether it's parking, whether it's taxation, whether it's tolls will be 50% cheaper, right? Now, you sort of rather obviously go, Well, why wouldn't and also by the way, they have got a charging infrastructure. So you would immediately say, Well, why won't everybody buy an electric vehicle because human beings don't really care whether they've got an electric vehicle or petrol vehicle? And lo and behold, 95% of car sales, I think in December last year, are electric vehicles. Now in in Norway, in fact, it's kind of odd as you try and kind of what are the other 5% doing? And our observation is, well, why aren't we applying that, by the way, it's not just there. But you see exactly the same thing. If you look at the Chinese cities that have been most successful in this regard, they've effectively adopted almost an identical policy. And so you're getting extremely rapid behavioral change, based on an extreme positive incentive. So what we really say is, there's two dimensions really, to the to the to the problem, the first one is, we need to make make electricity generation sustainable, which we'll come back to one second. And then the second one is we need to get everything we need to incentivize effectively everybody else to to electrify to all intents and purposes, and what we're saying is, why don't we just go sector by sector, create an extreme positive incentive. So I'd say take two examples, which are on the face of it very, very difficult. If you look at plant based meats, you know, I start doing this now I go into McDonald's, I go into Burger King, I'm just deeply frustrated, why isn't the plant based burger The Impossible Burger 30% cheaper? Effectively, then the carbon intensive alternative? It's really as simple as that. And I want to do that at every sector. When I look at steel, the steel industry, I just say, Okay, what's the job of policy, the job of policy here is to make green steel more profitable for the companies to produce, and cheaper for the consumer of steel. I mean, again, the consumer steel doesn't care, they're indifferent between them. I mean, they may care ethically, but in a sense, it's just steel. And so there's no difference. If one is 30%, cheaper, I will definitely buy the 30% cheaper, and the evidence says that you can just get, we will get very, very rapid change, people will change the behavior rapidly. If if you follow that, that that line of attack. Now, the one has to be a bit softer. And so the first point that we're really advocating is, is look, this is the evidence of what works. It makes intuitive sense. It's empirically supported, let's literally do IT sector by sector, and target very rapid change. But at the core of it, we then go, what are we going to do about electricity generation? And this again, is really, really interesting, because in most countries, electricity, the industry is a regulated industry. And it's, that is because it's a natural monopoly, what economists call a natural monopoly. What does that mean is because if somebody had the infrastructure, like the National Grid, all of those transmission lines and distribution cables, it's not it's not something you can open to competition, you can't have hundreds of providers. It's like a railway line, or the road network and actually tends towards monopolies. So we regulate them. And they and the way regulation really works is is actually quite simple, which is the regulator sits down with the the the owners of electricity generation and distribution and transmission, and says, Okay, you have to make a return on capital, the system needs a certain amount of investment spending, how do we price the electricity? And what's your cost of capital? And as Karen said to us, that that's a simple maths problem, right? Because it doesn't take decades to build wind farms to build storage to build solar. These are actually things if you look at offshore wind in the UK, it's quite extraordinary from start to finish. It's been done in five to seven years, and we've been able to create huge amounts of capacity. So this is a very tractable problem. But we have to be extreme and clever. And so what we're really saying is we want to effectively the way you do this is you de risk it. So if you want companies to reduce their cost, their hurdle rates, their investment requirements, you make the investment, much lower risk. And one way to do that, for example is that the government provides effectively guarantees electricity prices. So we think it is absolutely possible that the government could engineer lower rates of like lower levels of electricity prices, really, really reduce the cost of capital through guarantees and other mechanisms to the companies. And we just rapidly accelerate the rate of investment in our utilities. So the bottom line for us is we want people when they're thinking, What can I do about this? You know, get on the phone to your local MP Member of Parliament, Congressman and say, why aren't we building sustainable electricity? Why aren't we building storage? You know, we've got the, we got the lowest interest rates in history, this is capital investment. This is very doable. Okay.
Corinne Sawers:Yeah, and I just wanted to quickly pick up on that point, cuz I think it's very important context that, that many people who aren't living and breeding interest rates every day, may not, may not be on to fundamentally, our thesis is very optimistic, because as we said, 70% of the problem is the easier to solve it's capital allocation. And as Eric said, we have the lowest interest rates, you know, in generations. What does that mean? What that means is, governments can borrow at very low rates close to zero, sometimes negative, and they can invest it and create assets create wealth. So when people talk about the cost, people often talk about the cost of net zero, you know, there was a McKinsey Report, today, 9 trillion a year between now and 20 2050, required to get us to net zero, that's it that's 10% of GDP. And it sounds terrifying. And the number of times we hear on BBC Radio, an MP being interviewed, and the interviewer said, Who's going to pay for this, who's going to pay for net zero, this is a big misunderstanding, essentially. And the the analogy we use in the book is, you can you can borrow money from the bank for a holiday. And when you do that, you know, the money's gone, the value is gone, you've had a nice time, you've relaxed, and yeah, there's an intangible value to that, but you've not created any wealth. Or you can borrow money from the bank to do an extension on your house. And then you've created value, because you've added to the value of your house. This is in the latter category, we are building new assets, which will be better on many accounts than the old assets. So so there is a very strong business case for action. And we were lucky that we happen to be even if interest rates go up from where they currently are, they're still in historical terms extraordinarily low. So so that's a really important point here is we can create wealth and create jobs. This is not a cost as such. And this point around interest rates. It's relevant, particularly that many people don't know that. Governments can borrow at different rates from companies. And different governments can borrow at different rates from each other, usually based on level of economic development. And that is a tool, which people are a kind of a hack that some folks onto but isn't being used nearly enough, because we really should be sort of translating those lower interest rates through to the parts of the economy that need it. So governments should have, you know, the UK government where we live should have a targeted Lending Scheme where the UK Government passes on its low interest rate through to green infrastructure spending. And we also propose in the book what we call green Bretton Woods, which is, you know, the original Bretton Woods was post world war two major mobilization of capital middle parts, the global economy, we are endorsing the same thing, based on the fact that European economies by and large, can borrow at one to 3%. And emerging markets such as India can only borrow at, say, 10%. To why doesn't Denmark, borrow its low to 3%, pass that capital over to India, she's going to invest it in a whole lot of green infrastructure, which Denmark then owns part of. And that's, that's an income generating asset, Denmark's making money. And India has access to a low cost of capital. So then, the number of projects that can finance goes from a small share, which makes sense on that 10% cost of capital to a much bigger share, which makes sense on a 3% cost of capital. So we apologize in the book for how much we talk about interest rates, because they're quite, they're quite boring, but they are fundamental. And thinking about these we talk a lot about hacks. We've got quite a lot of policy hacks, one of these policy hacks, which which is being done at small scale, but nowhere near at the scale. It should be is these taking interest rates and parts of the economy that can access them and channeling them where they're needed to build green infrastructure?
Tom Raftery:Yeah, I think, I think a fundamental point that you made there at the start, that's very important that when people talk about the cost of doing these projects, it's not like you're taking all that money and you're burying it at a hole in the Round, you're actually, as you said, you're, you're creating things that, you know, first of all means you are creating jobs to create those things. And then those things themselves, create things. In this case, if it's renewable energy, they're creating cheap, clean energy, which is then going to help decarbonize the grid. So, you know, it's a win win for everybody. It's not a cost, it's actually absolutely bit well, it is a cost of wind, but it's still generating wealth and generating assets.
Eric Lonergan:That that's so true. And this comes up an awful lot. And again, you know, I pull my hair out every time you listen to listen to the radio, or TV or media coverage of this, it's all about how big the cost is. But that's also not how people understand the term cost. You know, we don't think it does you rightly say what we're actually creating wealth. And this is one of the other things we'd look at in the book fan. Well, who are the losers? And actually, the losers are, effectively the really big losers of the owner of fossil fuel assets. Because what we're doing is we Yes, we are destroying the value of fossil fuel assets. And we are creating a whole load of new assets. And then there's an interesting sort of distributional questions to who should own the new assets. But again, I think there are a lot of scare stories about the value of those assets, because also, if you look at what's been happening in financial markets, is actually the value of fossil fuel assets has already declined dramatically, the cost of borrowing is going up. And the cost of borrowing is going up. And markets can sort of see the future in that sense. And they're going look, these these assets are risky, they're not going to have the value that they've had in the past. You know, and also, there are, obviously there are social challenges in certain geographies about the people who work in the fossil fuel industry. But I have to say, again, if you look at that, for the world, and in the aggregate, it's relatively good news, I would say, you know, you're talking about less than 1% of the global labor force. Now, if you look through a normal economic cycle, you get, you know, more than 1%, you know, typically in in a recession, the labor force, you know, you might see four or 5% of the labor force losing their work, we're not we don't even want 1% to lose their work. But if you think the amount of jobs that are going to be created by these huge capital investment programs that we're talking about, and redirections of industries, you know, I think that is a relatively isn't really a significant problem at the aggregate.
Tom Raftery:What I mean, it's like arguing against the invention of the automobile, saying, saying all the blacksmiths would be put out of work
Eric Lonergan:Well, this is right, where, you know, we talk about the high street, if you think what's happened to lots of industries, the telecoms industry, so many industries have faced this sort of creative destruction.
Tom Raftery:So the book has all these policy hacks, as you say, how do we get them from policy hacks in the book to actual rollout hacks in the real world?
Eric Lonergan:I mean, that's a great question. And something we've thought about a lot, I think what we are hopeful to hear about, and we've made a really big effort is a ton of other people, people can judge that from listening to us here. But we have tried to make it as accessible and readable as possible. And then what we've elected to do is put a lot of the background technical information and research into sort of endnotes at the back of the book. So about a quarter of the book is sort of endnotes. If a text is a dialogue, it's hopefully very clear. A very short read, you know, you can read this book in three or four hours. But I guess the one of the one of the really important things is a lot of this is being done. But it's not being done in a very clear way. And part of what we're trying to do here is make it make the problem as tractable as possible, as accessible. And then really be clear about what has worked and what is working. And then hopefully, that clarity. And I think also a very strong sense that we're squandering an opportunity at multiple levels. So it's not just so we're not tackling climate change. But also, this is actually a huge economic opportunity in many ways. That capital investment and innovation, these are all really good things. There is no reason why collectively, we won't be a lot better off coming out the other side, because that's really important.
Tom Raftery:I mean, Corinne, you said that the I think was you said McKinsey reports that we have to spend something like 9 trillion a year. But I mean, yeah, that means we're buying 9 trillion a year worth of stuff. Somebody is actually benefiting from receiving that 9 trillion a year. Not somebody but somebody is whoever is creating this stuff. So you know Money doesn't just evaporate when you spend it, it goes to somebody else that's creating wealth for somebody so underappreciated too, I think,
Corinne Sawers:exactly many policymakers getting, you know, next lesson has been trying to make this point for decades, drawing on the work of the economist, Carlota Perez, who's, who's mapped that can essentially industrial revolutions, which, which is what we're going through. And technological disruption creates huge wealth and raising and living standards. But there's still there's a, at the general population level, there's a sense that this is this requires sacrifice and cost, which is not going to, at the end of day is comes back to our point about governments governments have to be elected, that's not going to help governments achieve this, you know, if that's what people believe?
Eric Lonergan:Sure, sure, sure. And I think you know, that there's a counter argument that we do come up against, you know, because this almost sort of then starts to sound too good. And if we just give positive incentives everywhere, you know, what does that mean, you know, for government borrowing and for these other things, and again, I think it's really important to separate, as current alluded to whether you're borrowing for holiday, or whether you're borrowing borrowing to do investment spending. And this is overwhelmingly about borrowing to create assets. So you have wealth on the other side of you have debt on one side, but you have assets that you've created on the other. So I think, yeah, that's, that's very, very important to be aware of. But if there is a situation where, you know, government deficits are a problem, we think tax should just be treated independently of our, our emissions objectives. Because, you know, the fact of the matter is, we have to do this. And if if it ends up being the case that, you know, the government's do need to raise taxes, because they don't have enough revenue? Well, we need to look at that independently, I think it's a disaster to have this idea of green taxes, we really don't want that to be the overriding political message. But if we then say, okay, we need to raise taxes, well, let's look at that intelligently and have optimal tax, you know, whether it's, we use the tax system to improve the distribution of wealth, or the distribution of income, or to tax, you know, rents within the economy or monopolies. That's a much more sensible way to approach the issue of government revenue, then trying to sort of confuse the two, because we have an emergency that we have to solve. And for which, you know, I'm an economist, the fiscal implications, to be honest, are very, very unclear if you said to me hand on heart, if these policies are followed, what will the fiscal position look like in five or 10 years? I really don't know. There are lots of other factors that are going to dominate that.
Tom Raftery:But I mean, one of the other factors is particularly if particularly if you're a European country, you're not having to give lots of money to Russia to buy oil and gas, if you're generating that electricity at home.
Eric Lonergan:I mean, absolutely. And this is very frustrating at the moment that somehow the narrative about electricity prices has been associated with sustainability, which makes really no sense to me at all. The main problem at the moment is we are still dependent on gas. And the price of gas is extraordinarily volatile. It is determined globally. So what any individual country is doing with respect to you know, sustainability isn't really relevant. And you know, we are going to have unless we remove our dependence on gas, we're going to have to live with extremely volatile electricity prices. Now, we're witnessing how terrible that is. Right? So the solution is, let's use what's free, which is wind and solar, and storage, let's build these assets. And let's reduce our dependence on something that is highly volatile. So you know, I find it very frustrating and people saying, oh, yeah, but wind and solar, you've got intermittency problems. Look at gas where the price can go up. 1,000% in 18 months, it's a nightmare. You know, and actually, you know, it's the intermittency problems are investment problems. Yeah, we need storage. And you can use things like pumped hydro, there are lots of ways where you don't need scarce minerals, and it's not all about money. There are lots and lots of of solutions that we have for these problems.
Tom Raftery:SuperGrid, isn't it best that the sun is always shining, or the wind is always blowing somewhere. So if you have a large enough grid, you just transfer the energy created to to and from wherever it's being made needed. Yeah. How do we get individual action going? Because I mean, I think, yeah, policy is great, but Polit to get policy to actually be rolled out, we need the right politicians who want to enact that policy. So you know, we need I think, individuals yourself, myself, people listening to this to actually become activists themselves right and vote in the politicians who will actually An act of change.
Corinne Sawers:Yeah. 100%. And that's, you know, again, we talked about this in the book about the role of the individual that, you know, in some ways, the individual has never been more powerful through social media to influence both, both politicians and companies and call out companies. But the most powerful thing you can do is, is to become an activist. But part of our frustration is that activists often don't quite know what they're asking for. And, you know, Obama had this advice, advice for the Black Lives Matter activists, you know, in 2020, he said, have a very concrete clear asks, because it's much more likely it's going to happen, right? That's also part of what we're trying to achieve in the book is almost give activists a manifesto of things to ask for, for to their respective governments or to corporates, you know, if that's the target of their activism,
Eric Lonergan:yeah, and, and there's lots of interesting research and ideas that we include in the book about, you know, how to be a really effective activist to collaborate with other activists. And we use examples like, you know, they're there, it is amazing what three or four people can achieve with social media. You know, one of the things we haven't spoken about that much is that, you know, the changes that have occurred within the corporate sector that we have observed over the last two years, companies are now they both have public commitments on sustainability and emissions reduction, but they are highly sensitive to this. And, and again, our power as activists through social media is really quite profound. I think it's also worth talking maybe a little bit about, you know, this, this sort of extinction, rebellion philosophy, which draws on the work of an academic called Erica Chenoweth at Harvard. And, and we talk about this a lot in the book, which it's a form of minority rule. And what what Erica Chenoweth and other scholars in America have done is they've looked at these sort of, you know, historically major social change and how it's occurred, such as the civil rights movement in America. And what's really interesting is they have this sort of magic number, which is, it's usually because three and a half percent of the population puts their foot down and says, This has to change. And so if you can imagine if three and a half percent of the population are on the streets, you get legislative change, at least in democratic societies or near democratic societies, right. And I actually think, you know, there are lots of complex nuances to that. But in one way, that's very motivating. And this is what we talked about this when you know, Koren use the term herding sheep, and you know, we put ourselves into this category. But in a way, those those those leaders, the people who are at the cutting edge, are really, really very powerful and influential. And I think, if we can get a very small number of people to put their foot tines and raise their voice, and generate the pressure, you can and are getting pretty phenomenal change. And the small contribution really of the book here is, we don't know at the moment to us, there's no manifesto, so we just want Okay, so let's say you are in a room with the government, and they say, what do you actually want? And I can understand why extinction rebellion and people like Greta Thunberg, I think as a matter of strategy, they've slightly avoided that because in a way, they don't want to get caught up in the weeds of something, some of the difficulties in the tech, and they actually I understand that as a strategy. But I think ultimately, we do need more, you know, we don't just need, you know, people blocking the motorways and bringing the traffic to a halt, we do need a text that says, and this is what needs to be done.
Corinne Sawers:And I would just add on that point about minority rule that we talked about this in the book, we we've also seen it play out in corporate environments, where you seen very small numbers of employees influence the agenda on climate and sustainability topics by being incredibly vocal, and you know, coordinated, we're talking, you know, 456 individuals. So we really can't emphasize enough how that both in smaller groups, and at the national level, that minority rule ability, if you're organized to really set an agenda and be vocal is extraordinarily powerful.
Tom Raftery:We're coming towards the end of the podcast now. Is there any question I haven't asked that you wish I had, or any aspect of this that we've not touched on that you think it's important for people to be aware of? One thing,
Eric Lonergan:I think maybe something that current alluded to, but just to emphasize again, one thing that we encounter an awful lot is that this sort of we won't make a difference line, where you know, if you look at what's happening to coal within India's infrastructure, or you look at what's happening in China, and You know, speaking, on my own personal level, I think a lot of those views that I did have, I have to say in researching the book, I very significantly changed my mind. And I think there's two dimensions to that, I think I've changed my mind about China and India. But I've also changed my mind about how we can have an impact. And I think one of the most like, if you just think of our discussion of, you know, what Norway has been doing within electric vehicles, Norwegian electric vehicles have virtually no impact on global emissions, you know, you're talking about a fraction of 1%, it has a big impact on their on their emissions, but not on global emissions. But that example, has actually shown us all what to do. So they've been incredibly influential and powerful, right. And so, you know, leadership is about example setting. So what we should and and also know how and skill and technology because we can learn from what they've done, we can learn from what goes wrong, where they have difficulties, they're exporting their technologies. So that's the first point that I think is really, really important is, you know, if you think about ethics, and this is this really is an ethical challenge is we can't be free riders or cheats, we can't say let's leave it to other people. Everybody has to show that they're able to do it. And then we can all collectively learn from that. I think that's really, really important. And then the second thing I would say is that China and India are really motivated. I mean, if you look at what they're both doing, like India is probably doing in Mill speeds. Yeah. And things like solar, then. Yeah, it's built six times very, very successful solar. And China, you know, is very motivated. Now, that is not to say that we can't do a lot to to impact that. I think there are poor regions in India, where there's heavy industry like steel, and which are very coal intensive, and you have a whole political economy around the coal industry. And I think collectively, we have to sit down and do what Karen said, which is, we have to strike a deal. And we have to go, you know, if you look at how much India borrows, it's sort of seven, eight or 9% to fund its investment, they're financially constrained. We can borrow at fixed rates of interest of one to 2%. Why don't we sit down with India and say, let's draw up an investment plan. Let's transfer these coal assets into solar assets, because you are now leading the world in many areas of solar power. And, you know, we'll we'll lend three or 4%. So this isn't a we're not going to give them money, we're going to lend to them at a at a rate of interest higher than the one that we pay, but much, much lower than what they are currently. And we've done the numbers on this, you know, if you look at what Europe borrowed during the pandemic, it's equivalent to what India needs to to invest over a decade. If we can do that in 12 months. Why can't we make an investment in India? Yeah. So there's a lot we can do about this. Yeah,
Corinne Sawers:we just ended that. Supercharged me. It's fundamentally an optimistic and hopeful book. And and because we believe that's how we should all feel that this is, you know, as I opened with a real, this is a tractable problem. We have the solutions, it's solvable. That's not to say we are on already on course, for some pretty devastating climate change. But we can we can hit the global targets of 1.5 to two degrees. And we can do that by raising living standards for the vast majority of the population and not kind of the ownership of fossil fuel assets is absolutely tiny. It's less than naught point 5% of the population. And then those are mainly very rich people focus on not going to lose out. So it's fundamentally an optimistic thesis.
Tom Raftery:Good. Good. Good. Fantastic. Last question. If people want to know more about yourselves, Corinne and Eric, if people want to know more about the book, supercharged me, where would you have me direct them?
Corinne Sawers:We've got a website, which is www.superchargeme.org. Where we've got some bios and we are doing some blogs. We've done one blog. We've got a few more due to come up in the next few weeks. And that's one place and then we're both on Twitter. Eric is very active on Twitter. He loves it. He loves a debate on Twitter. Sometimes content to be a bit nicer to people.
Tom Raftery:I get that too. I I've tweeted once or twice myself as well. So yeah, I know we are fantastic. Erica Korean. That's been really, really interesting. Thanks a million for coming on the podcast today.
Eric Lonergan:Lovely to chat. Thanks so much, Tom. We really, really appreciate it. Your generosity in time, much, much appreciated.
Corinne Sawers:Indeed. Thank you so much, and you know, great work you're doing.
Tom Raftery:Okay, we've come to the end of the show. Thanks, everyone for listening. If you'd like to know more about climate 21 Feel free to drop me an email to Tom Raftery at SAP COMM or connect with me on LinkedIn or Twitter. If you'd like the show please don't forget to subscribe to it and your podcast application of choice to get new episodes as soon as they're published. Also, please don't forget to rate and review the podcast. It really does help new people to find the show. Thanks. catch you all next time.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Buzzcast
Buzzsprout
Wicked Problems - Climate Tech Conversations
Richard DelevanClimate Connections
Yale Center for Environmental Communication
The Climate Pod
The Climate Pod
Climate Action Show
Climate Action Collective
The Climate Question
BBC World Service
Energy Gang
Wood Mackenzie
Climate Positive
HASI
Climate One
Climate One from The Commonwealth Club