Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Climate Confident is for business leaders, climate professionals and policymakers who need to understand what is actually cutting emissions—and what it takes to make those solutions work at scale.
Each Wednesday, technology and sustainability analyst, keynote speaker and former SAP Global VP Tom Raftery speaks with the executives, engineers, scientists, founders and policymakers turning climate ambition into measurable progress. Together, they examine the technologies, business models, policies and implementation strategies reshaping energy, transport, industry, supply chains, food and finance.
These are not conversations about distant targets, vague pledges or greenwash. They are candid discussions about what is working, what is failing, where the real bottlenecks lie, and how leaders can make better decisions about decarbonisation, resilience, investment and risk.
You will hear:
- Proven approaches to reducing emissions
- Hard-earned lessons from real-world implementation
- Analysis of the markets, technologies and policies driving the transition
- Honest examination of costs, trade-offs, setbacks and unintended consequences
- Practical ideas for turning climate commitments into action
New episodes are published every Wednesday at 7am CET. Subscribers also receive bonus episodes featuring highlights, analysis and emerging themes from across the series.
Follow Climate Confident for practical climate solutions, informed debate and the insights you need to turn ambition into measurable progress.
Guest suggestions and feedback are welcome at Tom@tomraftery.com.
Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
How Important Is Storytelling When It Comes To Climate? A Chat With Dan McDougall
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Get in touch - leave me a message
Creating a narrative is all-important in any sphere.
All the more so in the climate space where the stakes are perilously high, and as we heard in last week's episode, climate anxiety is becoming a very real thing.
To explore the topic of storytelling, particularly as it pertains to climate I invited multiple award-winning journalist, British Foreign Correspondent of the Year, and filmmaker Dan McDougall to come on the podcast.
We had a fascinating conversation discussing all aspects of climate storytelling. Check out the conversation.
If you have any comments/suggestions or questions for the podcast - feel free to leave me a voice message on my SpeakPipe page, head to the Climate 21 Podcast Forum, or send it to me as a direct message on Twitter/LinkedIn. Audio messages will get played (unless you specifically ask me not to).
And if you want to know more about any of SAP's Sustainability solutions, head on over to www.sap.com/sustainability, and if you liked this show, please don't forget to rate and/or review it. It makes a big difference to help new people discover the show. Thanks.
And remember, stay healthy, stay safe, stay sane!
Music credit - Intro and Outro music for this podcast was composed, played, and produced by my daughter Luna Juniper
Sign up to Climate Confident+ for deep dive analysis of the major climate and energy stories of the day.
Podcast subscribers
I'd like to sincerely thank this podcast's amazing subscribers:
- Anita Krajnc
- Cecilia Skarupa
- Ben Gross
- Jerry Sweeney
- Andreas Werner
- Stephen Carroll
- Roger Arnold
And remember you too can Subscribe to the Podcast - it is really easy and hugely important as it will enable me to continue to create more excellent Climate Confident episodes like this one, as well as give you access to the entire back catalog of Climate Confident episodes.
🎤 Looking for a keynote speaker on climate, energy, AI, or sustainability?
I help executive audiences understand the technologies, trends, and decisions shaping the low-carbon transition.
Download my Speaker Pack: https://tinyurl.com/spkrpck
And a quick note before you go: I’ve started a new Reddit community for serious, evidence-led discussion on climate solutions, clean energy, decarbonisation, policy, technology, and what actually works in practice.
If you’d like to suggest future guests, challenge ideas from the show, or share climate reports and solutions worth discussing, join us at r/ClimateConfident
And as storytellers, we have to really look at how we can connect and we can cut through the attention economy. You know, people are scrolling cats and on Instagram, and you want to talk to them about, you know, potentially their city being underwater in 20 years' time. Where do you begin? Or who do you begin?
SPEAKER_01Good morning, good afternoon, or good evening wherever you are in the world. This is the Climate21 Podcast, the number one podcast showcasing best practices in climate emissions reductions. And I'm your host, Global Vice President for SAP, Tom Raftery. Don't forget to subscribe to this podcast in your podcast app of choice to be sure you don't miss any episodes. Hi everyone, welcome to the Climate 21 podcast. My name is Tom Rafftery from SAP, and with me today I have my special guest, Dan. Dan, welcome to the podcast. Would you like to introduce yourself? Sure.
SPEAKER_00My name is Dan McDougall. I'm a film director and writer. I work as a foreign correspondent as well. I was a Sunday Times Africa correspondent and the Guardian South Asia correspondent. I report to some 127 countries now. So I've traveled a fair bit. And I also own a branded content film company called Merin that works for Google and MasterCard and lots of companies in around the issues of human rights and sustainability.
SPEAKER_01And have you won any journalistic awards? Oh gosh. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I grew up in a housing estate outside Glasgow, so you tend not to post. I've won a few. I'm the British Foreign Correspondent of the Year and I've won more amnesty awards than any other journalists. The amnesty awards are, I guess, the gold standard for human rights reporting, Royal Television Society Award for Documentary Making, Martha Gailhorn Prize for War Reporting. Over the years, many awards. I've been very lucky, and I think having worked for great publications and also for the BBC, I think I've been fortunate to be at the heart of a lot of stories. Fantastic.
SPEAKER_01So we've established your credibility. Fantastic. That's great. And like myself, you're a Celt living on the Iberian Peninsula, but you're at the other end of the Iberian Peninsula, you're up around Barcelona, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean it's only slightly less hot here. It's still incendiary. We're living both living in the furnaces in Seville, you're certainly in the fine time. I'm not sure where that would be. I'm under the grill, perhaps. Yeah, we're both suffering with our freckles.
SPEAKER_01You know, you bring up the subject of heat, and this is the Climate 21 podcast, Dan. And you are, as we've established, a journalist of some note. The whole issue around climate storytelling is one that's coming to the fore. I recently spoke to uh a journalist from Grist about the issues of climate anxiety that are starting to rise and ways to get around those. But talk to me about climate storytelling. What is climate storytelling and why is climate storytelling important?
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, that's that's a million-dollar question. I mean, let's start with the pandemic. For me, COVID-19 is the kind of mirror for how we're not reporting climate, because the pandemic is effectively a climate story. The pandemic originated because of our expansionism from urban areas into rural areas, the living cheek by gel with species and the animal kingdom in a way that we'd never done before. And that shakes viruses from the tree, right? As we saw with the Bola, I certainly came across that in Uganda, the Congo reporting there. And then obviously in Wuhan, we have this leap between species. And yet the COVID-19 story has been universally sold as a health story. And I guess the climate story is at the heart of our lives in so many different ways. And I certainly did a lot of reflecting during the pandemic because it was the first time in my career that I hadn't traveled to the same degree, like 60% of my life on the road. And during that time, I reflected on a lot of notes from old stories from disparate amounts of countries from Burma to Patagonia, from Congo to Greenland. And I started to piece together a lot of the witness testimony from old notebooks. And they were all telling me similar things. They were saying things like the temperature's changing, glaciers melting, the rains are coming at unusual times. And I started to kind of realize that the climate is a kind of red line that has gone through a lot of my journalism over the years, over the decades. And that was quite troubling. It was almost like a wake-up call. And the reason that strikes me as unusual is because if you had asked me a year ago, even two years ago, if I was a climate reporter or climate writer, I would have said, no, of course not. And I've done a lot of reflection on why that is. And maybe we can talk about that a little bit later. But I think during the civil war in Syria, I covered the ISIS murder and persecution of LGBTQ citizens. He traced the loved ones of those who'd been thrown off roofs, went to safe houses in a Lebanon and other parts of the world, interviewed witnesses of what ISIS had done. And then around that time in the Pew report, it basically directly linked the Syrian civil war to climate. And we know from Yemen, we know from Afghanistan that there are climate factors at play. But I think it's almost like what it takes from a journalistic perspective as a helicopter view of all the stories you've covered and think, is there a climate link to the story? And in my case, it's extraordinary how many stories are linked to climate.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And this is something that you hadn't realized until you stopped to reflect. Do you think others have done similar, or is it something that needs to be talked more about to make people realize that all of these things are actually climate stories?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think part of it is to do with credibility. So I'm going to talk historically here. When I first entered a newsroom, there weren't any climate correspondents, obviously, but then it became the case, it was maybe an environmental journalist in the room. But they were never, it was never really in this way sound conceited. It was never really fashionable to be a climate journalist. It was almost the guy in the corner in the sandals that went home for you know then course pub. And so there wasn't that kind of social element there, and it wasn't anything that it didn't feel like a kind of career trajectory to become a climate journalist, right? As opposed to a war correspondent or an investigative journalist or human rights journalist. So I guess that was one factor. And I think that has changed now. But I think that for me, the main factor in terms of why it's difficult to be a climate journalist is credibility. And I know, you know, going back to my my work in Trivel Blue back in 2006, 2007, when I reported on climate refugees, because there have always been conspicuous climate stories in my life, and I've known that I've gone after it. I was an early adopter of the climate crisis narrative in terms of storytelling. I just didn't realize that all the other stories I was covering could also be linked to climate in the same way. I mean, I can give a very good example of that, you know, child marriage, you know, my work around child marriage or children in prison and a lot of stuff from children in prison. So child marriage in the Sahel or child marriage is documented in India or Pakistan, the pressure on families through climate is what creates that dynamic. So when you have seven children and your crops are failing, and there's a there's an enormous heat wave that's lasting for three, four months, is you know, these kind of wet bowl heat waves, people are dying in the heat, then it normally it's the you have to make a decision about your children, about your daughters, about their future, and and and this is a direct correlation between climate and in something like child marriage. So there's that kind of subtle aspect of it. But it but the reason that it's never really pieced together in that way is credibility is people are scared to link climate to everything journalistically. And I think that's part, I think that's a problem. And I wonder where that comes from. Certainly, no, when I covered the Tuvalu story and we called the Tuvalu, it's climate refugees. I was one of the first journalists to do so. The story was criticized a lot. There was a lot of skepticism around it. Well, climate change refugees don't exist. I mean, I even to this day, I just shot a film in Senegal, and the film is framed around climate, putting pressure on families, and that's why they're coming to Europe. And people still criticize that dynamic. They're saying, well, they're just economic migrants. I challenge you to go to St. Louis in Senegal, where we just filmed. It's a beautiful film. And the the whole front row of the town is gone to the sea. Sure, there's a fishing squeeze, right? As we as the Spanish fleet expands, as the European fleet expands, and you know, even the Taiwanese Chinese fleet expands and overs up the poleg fish stock and and and leaves the fisherman with slim pickings. There is that story. Um, but even that's a climate story because they're following the fish, right? And the fish migration's changed. It's a perfect storm of climate over fishing, and and they're going to Europe because they can't work the land anymore. And certainly in the north, it's certainly gone, it's incredibly hot, which we know. So, and even now to this day, I'm still being kind of accused of well, that's just sensationalism, you know, it's emotional journalism, it's activism, not journalism. And that's a real problem with that narrative because it's a skepticism around what a climate story is, and we're all in trouble. And I think that's certainly a historical story, as we saw with a lot of climate deniers. And then there was a campaign to follow the science, and then there was a whole issue of what we call it. You know, is it is it is it global warming? Is it the greenhouse effect? Is it climate change? Is it climate crisis? Now, is it a climate catastrophe? I mean, the world's newspapers can't even agree what to call it. New York Times calls it something different from The Guardian, BBC calls it something different from Greenpeace. So we don't even know what to call it. Don't get me started on the whole semantics of the climate storytelling narrative. So I think credibility is a problem historically, it remains to the case today where we were worried about linking climate to these major global world issues because we feel that we're going to be challenged as in terms of our balance as journalists, but also in terms of the credibility of the storytelling. There's a reason for this, uh, which we can talk about, which is data. We need more data around climate storytelling. I can give some good examples of that. Please do. Well, one of the stories that I'm I'm fascinated by is the concept of solistalgia. Solistalgia is super interesting. And basically, what we're looking at with solistalgia is uh a feeling of discompobulation. It was an Australian psychiatrist account, and uh, and and it's uh and the theory is basically feeling homesick in your own home. And this is particularly true at the extremities of the earth, in you know, perhaps Nova Scotia or in the Arctic or in certain parts of the southern hemisphere where you do have definitely this very conspicuous sense of change around you, you know, the the sea's higher, the the glaciers melting, and and you start to feel uncomfortable that something around you is not right. And it creates this thing called solistalgia. And it's it's linked to mental health. And I knew that I wanted to do a story about mental health in the Arctic. I knew that I wanted to touch upon solistal, but I also knew that if I directly link climate change to mental health, I'll be scrutinized and I'll be criticized. So I kind of did the deep dive and looked at anyone who was doing surveys in the Arctic. And when I say surveys, I mean like the broadest possible surveys, right? Political surveys, social surveys. And I found this tiny little Danish NGO. And they were working in partnership with an academic and a larger foundation, and they were basically carrying out the biggest survey in Greenland's history. And the survey sample was around, and please forgive me, it's not exactly accurate, but five or six thousand people, which might sound tiny, but Greenland has a population of 57,000 people. It's a huge sample, you know, from a from a data perspective. And so I realized instinctively, wow, that's that's an extraordinary opportunity. And I said, Did you ask the five or six thousand Greenlanders about climate? Yeah, sure, there's two questions. And one of the questions was, is the climate situation making you feel sad? The first one was, Are you aware of it? And the answer was overwhelmingly, yeah. It's making us feel depressed, it's making us feel discombobulated. There's almost a living evidence for solostalgia. And it was enshrined in data, right? It was enshrined in the individual testimonies, but then the cause of the concept of analysis, that it was it was just a solid piece of research. And I used that effectively as a stepping stone into the narrative. We went to Greenland and made a film called Open Water, which won in Guardian documentaries and you know won lots of awards and got lots of attention. But then I wrote another piece, a long front piece, about mental health and climate. That felt to me to be the perfect marriage of data and storytelling, and was bulletproof. Most importantly. And you know, there was obviously some some criticism of it, but it was fundamentally bulletproof because you're following the data, you're following the stats, you're following, you know, and I think technology has a real role to play in in future storytelling. Yeah. But yeah, so that's so that's a good example of where we can marry, you know, um, and and I think this is one of my big issues. I once spent a couple of weeks in an ice station in Greenland with some climate scientists and climatologists, and I ended up in a kind of daily battle with them or a nightly battle around the dinner table. I'd I'd spend my days climbing up a glades here and there. I'd I'd watch them take samples. And then at night I'd listen to them talk about peer review and the importance of the scientific community. And and I was screaming at the table. I was thinking, you shouldn't be talking to each other. You should be talking to the world. Yeah. Some of them are sitting on work that has taken three or four years. And I appreciate that to get it's the same, it's the same argument I'm making here of my credibility of writing. I appreciate it's hard to get information. You need to spend a long time to make sure it's copper bottomed. But at the same time, most of the serious work on climate and where we are as a species is published in periodicals. It's published in scientific journals, it's published for peer review. Yeah. They should be on the front page of the Times or the maybe the Lancer, or maybe, you know, maybe new scientists, or maybe maybe not achieve or not necessarily them, but someone will pick up a line. But the real deep thinking on climate isn't being translated into the mainstream. And so peer review is the enemy of climate, as far as I'm concerned. I mean, scientists right now will be listening to this saying, no, we need peer review. We need, you know, we need but we we are in a hurry. We are in a hurry and we're in a crisis. I mean, today I read that Phoenix is 120 next week, the fastest heating city in America. We certainly know Colkata's the fastest in South Asia and Baakan, it's like we're living in Spain right now in the middle of an extraordinary heat wave. It's August weather right now, we're seeing conspicuous elements of climate everywhere. And yet there's still this kind of glacial, glacial movement, you know, in terms of storytelling. Yeah. And the media are culpable. The media are definitely culpable, I would say. And how do we fix this, Dan? Well, I think one of the problems is that I mean I've worked for the BBC, you know, it's a public service broadcast model, right? So let's think about what that means. What does public service broadcasting mean? It means that we have a duty as storytellers to the public in the UK to license feeholders or you know, if you're in cable, you know, to subscribers. We have a duty to inform and educate the public, first and foremost, right? And I'm not sure if that's happening. I think that so I had a really interesting conversation at the A Festival, this wonderful literature festival on the Welsh borders, the biggest in the world, beautiful festival. And I interviewed Professor Lucy Eastal, who is the Downing Street British government's key advisor on disaster recovery. Fascinating academic. And we were laughing and had this extraordinary conversation on the stage about where we're going wrong with climate storytelling. And she thinks that there's this media response of narrative around climate that is probably irresponsible. I mean, there's there's a number of things, right? So last week we had a heat wave in England, and uh the front page of the Daily Mail, the biggest selling newspaper of the UK, or one of them, was Happy Friday. Right? So let's think about this, right? So forget kid skin cancer and all the other aspects of the story is that they're celebrating the heat.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And it's such an extraordinary way to react to the narrative, right? But then we we also see other problems. We see problems in in how we cover drama, how drama covers uh natural disasters and climate change, you know, and extremists, you know, like apocalypse scenarios and stuff like that. Rather unrealistic scenarios that do make people skeptical. So I think we face enormous challenges to try and get people on board with the story. And the solution has to start with, arguably has to start with resource. So, you know, we're unfortunate in the sense that we live in an era when we need a responsible media more than ever, at any time in history, even during the wars. We need a response to media. And we're in this perfect storm where there has never been such a profound decimation of an industry as it has been with the media. I mean, as a foreign correspondent for decades, I mean, I would, I would say that it's expensive to keep foreign correspondents in the field. Sure. And the the first thing that go in newsrooms are things that are most expensive. So the foreign correspondents, you know, like the Los Angeles Times, you know, basically closed the bureaus and then they've reopened with a few more. But that you certainly have all these newspapers that realize that we can't have so many people in the field. We can't invest so much money in foreign reporting. And what that creates is a vacuum, it creates uh it creates a black hole where there's no light getting in and there's no stories in the shadows anymore. And that's a problem. So one of the issues is resource. So there needs to be more money put put towards climate storytelling. And if newspapers can't afford it, who fills that gap? And I read a really interesting thesis recently that suggested that Silicon Valley should give 10% of revenues to support newspapers and to support the media to cover human rights and climate. And that should be on that should be a completely unscripted scenario. That should be this is by law, this money is handed over to support a media that is that is professional, that is intellectual, that is balanced, that is all the things that media should be, right? But then the other argument is you know, with public service broadcasting, the BBC has a couple of environmental, well, I think BBC in fairness now has an environmental uh or climate bureau, but it still doesn't cover it in the comprehensive way it should. But there's uh the public broadcasting element of the story is important. Could there be a mandate that says 10% of all public service broadcasting journalism should be about climate and should be educational? And going back to my conversations with Professor Lucy East up at the Hay Festival, she really believed that the media needs to play a responsible role to help people respond to crisis. Education, educational role, right? To help them mitigate against it in Australia when the fires hit. And people didn't know how to treat burners locally, they didn't know how to cope then how what you know what way to follow the wind in a fire. You know, in the UK they're building flood centers very discreetly, but people still don't really know through the media how to how to cope with the flood. The way that we cover flood as a story is we go in and we we film people uh underwater, their homes are underwater, and then we might go back a year later and we show the recovery. It's such a one-dimensional approach to storytelling. And I think that natural disaster storytelling that I I you know I've covered tsunamis and earthquakes is that you go in, you you tell the story of loss and then repeat a hundred times, and then you go back a year later and you tell the story of recovery is how we're approaching climate. So I so I think resource is an issue. I mean, you work with SCP. I mean, I you know, we we we know that there's a role that brands can play in that. I mean, I look at Unilever's ad spend of four billion, right? Yeah. To sell detergents, to sell household products and you know, the things that they sell ice cream and and I think, well, could could they just hand over 10% of their ad spend and basically say, well, because because in 30 years' time they're not going to have any customers. So, you know, in in certain in certain countries, in southern hemisphere countries. So can they hand over 10% of their ad spend and and can that be pushed towards advocacy? Can it be pushed towards, you know, can it fund one of my big passions at the moment is globalization. Can it fund storytellers in cities around the world? Because if people can't engage with the kind of stories I tell in the Amazon or Congo and the Pacific Islands, they certainly will engage with a story here in the city of Barcelona, where there's where there are water shortages. Yeah. This idea of climate storytellers in cities is fascinating. And I think that what we didn't show during the pandemic, and I'm going to pay credit here to media in many respects, is that we covered the pandemic in a really imaginative way. The New York Times had some extraordinary front pages. There was one I remember vividly, which is all the names of the dead and tiny print at a certain point in the pandemic. But there was a lot of wraparounds, there was a lot of really imaginative abuse of data. And I think we could probably learn lessons from the imaginative way that we covered the pandemic. And if the ticking clock narrative of the pandemic was powerful. Storytelling. We were glued to that, right? We were watching it and we were thinking, well, okay, today the numbers are here, the projected numbers are there, and the world was dripped, newspaper sales actually went up. Why can't we translate that into the climate story, which is even more urgent?
SPEAKER_01So my my my my thinking on that, Dan, would be that the pandemic was a very short-term. It didn't feel like it at the time, but it was a very short-term issue. And yes, we were all glued to it. But now we still have waves of the pandemic ongoing, and it's not reported anywhere because we got tired of it. We saw the same thing with the war in Ukraine. Uh, it was on the front pages of all the papers all the time in February and March, and then as we got into April and May, it started to go. Down the headlines a bit, and now we barely see it reported, and it's still ongoing. Climate is a decades-long issue. So are people going to get tired of that if we start reporting on it all the time? I mean, how do we maintain people's interest in a story like that?
SPEAKER_00There's a really interesting philosophy at the moment that's emerging called Twilight Thinking, and how we are viewing the climate crisis as a species, almost like children. We are in this state of denial. We're looking away and pretending that this isn't happening. And in the belief that this is a slow process. But as we're already seeing in the world that there are people right now living in the front line of climate, right? I mean, as a society, we're spending more money on walls now than we're spending in arms. So governments are starting to already think forward. They're thinking about the language of containment. Why is India building such a large wall along the Bangladesh border? What are we looking at here? We're looking at the language of containment. We're looking at how we can potentially contain enormous refugee exodus. I mean, obviously, our focus right now is on the refugee crisis in Ukraine, which is heartbreaking and a travesty. But we know that there are more refugees from climate than more today. And so I think that the long-termism argument doesn't really wash anymore. I think that the reality is we're living in a climate crisis, as Dream Priest would say, a climate catastrophe now. And this process of twilight thinking and denial is quite frankly burying your head in the sand. And I think that we as storytellers, experienced storytellers, have a responsibility to try and force the kind of greater narrative into the mainstream and maybe take that short-termism away from people's worldview. I mean, it's it's feasible that cities could be unlivable within 15 years, 20 years, according to the latest data. So one of the things the UN Secretary General Guterres basically said it's the governments that are doing nothing that other radicals now. Not that, you know, so which I which I quite I quite like that quote. But even I mean, even the way that we cover radicalism, right? The thing that worries me most about mainstream media coverage at the moment of the climate crisis is the language that's creeping in. We're starting to walk shame. So protesters are called eco-zellics, right? Extinction rebellion are covered in a way that shows them as destructors, isn't beyond radical anarchists, you know, people who are going to ruin our businesses, ruin our lives. I wonder how that narrative will look in 30 years' time. I wonder how we will view them then. And of course, then you've got the the way that we cover Greta, the way we cover the youth movement. It's much more empathetic. The media covers the youth rallies and the school strikes in a way that is this is really sweet, this is really nice. But Extinction Rebellion are doing the same thing. So they cover adults protesting in a way that is walk-shaming, and they cover youth doing it in a way that's well, this is great, you know, uplifting everything else. And then obviously the media did turn on Gretel and certainly the right-wing media, certainly, as we expected, but um and I think that there's there's a real inconsistency in terms of the coverage. And this goes back to there's a really great Neil study called The Six Americans. And it's a study I really recommend if anyone gets a chance to read, and it's been a 10-year programme, and it basically categorizes America into uh the six categories. And so what it basically looks at is how America has different opinions on climate. So there's the alarmed who are convinced global warming is happening, right? Which is probably us. The concerned who basically believe it's happening and it's a threat, but it's still a low priority issue for them. And then there's the cautious who haven't made their mind up yet if you could actually believe that. But then it gets worse because then there's a disengaged and who know nothing about global warming. The biggest concern about the disengaged is the fact that they don't believe the media is covering it, so that's why they don't know about it. And then there's a doubtful who don't think it's happening at all, and then there's an outright dismissive, which is basically Donald Trump. So for me, the most revealing piece of data in the Six America study by Yale is 69% of Americans believe climate change is happening, and I see that as real progress, massive progress. But here we go, 30% aren't discussing it. So I find that concerning still. And then less than 25% of the Yale study do not come across or hear about a climate crisis in the media. A quarter of all the Americans interviewed in the study. They don't think that the media is covering it, they don't hear about it in the media. So a lot of the data trends are concerning. And us in America, where we have a developed media, democratic free media. So what happens in other countries? And in the same way, we're seeing that this pushback towards autocracy, you know, in countries, media control. How will that threaten the storytelling ability of journalists?
SPEAKER_01Again, how do we fix that? Because you mentioned earlier having climate storytellers in every town. And I think that's an awesome idea because the whole issue with humanity, I think, is that we only care about things that are local to us. So the the example that comes to mind here is again our attitude to the war in Ukraine versus our attitude to the war, and I'm talking about it when I say us now, I mean here in Europe, versus the war in Yemen, let's say, or Syria, let's say, which is further away, and so we care less about. So I think it's something about us as a species that if it's happening local to us, we care a lot more about it. The further away it's happening, the less we care. And so having local climate storytellers talking about things, whether it's a drop in the number of migratory birds that come to your town every year as a result of climate change, or whether it's reduced water in the wells as a result of climate change, or whatever it is. I think that's one possible way that we have a dedicated or several dedicated local climate storytellers who were talking about that. But again, that comes back to funding who funds that and what other ideas are there?
SPEAKER_00I think it's a really good point. I mean, I find when I was in Vanuatu just before the pandemic, shooting a film, and it was really interesting to be back in the Pacific. And and one thing I realized there was that in in Vanuatu, Micronesia and Polynesia, but everything is climate storytelling, right? It's like you know, it's the beginning, it's the middle, and it's the end. Okay, we know that. But what was interesting to me about the way that they were, and and I mean a topa here in the sense that I, you know, one of the things that annoys Micro Asians in particular is the helpless island and narrative, you know, we're sinking and medate that story. And you know, which is a story that I, you know, when I first started covering climate, I seldom reported on. And you know, I we could sit here and have a moral or philosophical argument about whether that was right at the time to raise awareness, to kind of joke people into action. But their anger with that story as time goes on is completely understandable. But the lesson in the way they cover climate is super interesting. So, someone I think who was talking uh about journalism is that every beat, as they say in America, every part of the journalistic office from sport to conflict or war correspondence or foreign correspondence to economics to business department, everything is about climate one way or another, but you can always find a niche that links to climate. And they've really taken a leaf out of that philosophy in Micronesia and the Polynesian newspapers, but they tell climate stories across the board every day, but they're really embedded in solution arts. So uh when I was in Vanuatu, I was reading a story about a climate-resistant tarot and how they were how they were making uh a kind of floating version of the planet that worked and could could work in flood waters. And and and then you've got other stories that you know they talk about the rugby season being impacted by by climate, talk about I mean so it's really interesting how they they they've created a dynamic kind of a local narrative around climate that is a kind of combination of hopeless and hopeful, but it's quite a subtle thing. And it's and and I think the resilience stories there really work because people are inspired by that and they're motivated to action. And and and as someone who historically, I mean, I mean, look, I I you know, I'm one of the only journalists to this to this day who's really reported on child rape in South Africa as an in a pandemic, you know, children are the levels of child rape in in South Africa are appalling in particular, and that that's a kind of unforgiving storytelling that I really believe has a place. And and a lot of people wouldn't. A lot of people say, well, we shouldn't be reporting, you know, writing 6,000 words on child rape, but it's happening. And I think that one of the biggest issues with the fatalistic approach or the bleak storytelling is people do lose hope. In Polynesia, we're seeing that. So globalization could provide that kind of balance between the hopeless, which is the truth, and the hopeful, which is the look, you know, humanity, we can come together and we can come up with solutions. Because but I think the first part of that is necessary because I think I don't think that we should be lying to people, you know, journalistically. I I think that our you know, our job is to tell the truth. And then, of course, this is where journalism is often accused of veering into activism. You know, I mean, I I grew up in it you know, with a series of detachment. I mean, I guess my life as a storyteller, as a foreign correspondent, changed during the Civil War in Kashmir when I I went into the aftermath, like I heard a suicide bomb go off and covered the aftermath of it. And traditionally what we would do is we would we would report you know on the event, on the moment, but I kind of waited. And I and instead I just waited and waited and didn't write anything, and then I went to the few notes and followed the stories days and days after of the women and their journeys and became a much more emotional story led by witnesses. And that I took that philosophy on for the rest of my career and still still hold it dear, is that you know, Gabriel Garcia Marquez says that everyone has three lives a public life, a private life, and a secret life. And I'm fascinated by that quote because I think as as storytellers, we've got to, I mean, I've gone further than the private lives sometimes and told us unpalatable truth with a lot of the stories that we've covered, but I think that we do have to try and tell the stories through case studies in the most powerful and impactful and emotional way that we can. And I've got a storytelling philosophy that I can talk about that cuts into that, this idea, which is how you can use certain devices as storytellers, but that would be more technical if you're interested in it.
SPEAKER_01Go for it.
SPEAKER_00Well, I I think that basically again, and you you you'll know as well from you working with SCP, about your your your long time working in businesses. But the interesting thing about even from advertising, a corporate branding perspective, is you're you're told to never piss off the potential customer and never you know, never make people angry, right? That's never going to work. And I don't think that's true. You know, we live in the misattention economy now where we're fighting for attention. Yeah. And uh the BBC did this super survey about storytelling, and it categorized our our response to stories in a number of different ways. And it was sadness, anger, surprise, hope, and belonging. And these kind of key touch points to what you're trying to kind of touch on to be a successful storyteller. So sadness is something I've definitely done very successfully in my career. Even though we in the climate story, we've we've communicated a lot of sadness, a lot of loss, a lot of death, a lot of suffering. Anger is probably at times has come from, I guess, from us, right? Activist journalists, I guess, if you want to call this that. Now, I mean, Jorah Berger's book, Contagious, uh, explains that. He says that angry content, like it's more boring because and happy content, is more likely to get shared. So angry content is what we saw with the Gretz movement, right? There's a lot of anger in there, and it was very successful, high authoritifying perspective. But then we've got surprise. Surprise for me is the most important one. I mean, I reported in the war in Afghanistan and got bored with what everyone was doing. And so I went to Fiji and reported on the war dead in Fiji. You know, Fiji is fighting on the front line in Afghanistan for Britain and then dying. I covered, you know, I instead of writing in the front line in Kandahar, I focused on opium clinics and child opium addicts. In China, I reported on, you know, execution orphans, children orphaned by executions. So I'm always trying to find that line that's going to surprise you, that's going to really pull you in and think, you know, make you think, fuck me, I did not know that. I had no idea. That is extraordinary. I just, I'm surprised by that. I'm really stunned. And that's the thing that's grabbing you and making you read more. And I think surprise is underestimated. And I think that there's a lot of space in the climate narrative for surprise. But then, of course, there's also hope, right? Which we've talked a little bit about, you know, enveloping the climate story is resilience generally. And the kind of, I guess, the spirit, the spirit of the blitz, as you say, in the UK, where which we saw during the pandemic, that was a hopeful narrative.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, in some respects, in terms of the hero and the hero's art, right? The hero's story, um, which we saw a lot. But then there's belonging. And belonging is an interesting story as well, an interesting narrative is that bringing your audience into a cause is is all about creating a movement, something that you can be part of. And I probably did that quite successfully with child labor. I was a very, you know, you know, uh investigated a lot of the companies for child labor. And really help, you know, was part of a movement that really probably helped to force that out of the industry to a large degree. It still exists, but not so much now, certainly with fashion. So I think that creating a movement is a really uh important way to pull people in from a climate storytelling perspective. And as storytellers, we have to really look at how we can connect and we can cut through the attention economy. You know, people are scrolling cats and on Instagram, and you want to talk to them about, you know, potentially their city being underwater in 20 years' time, where do you begin? Or do you begin?
SPEAKER_01We're coming towards the end of the podcast now, Dan. Is there any question I haven't asked you that you wish I had, or any aspect of this we've not touched on that you think it's important for people to think about?
SPEAKER_00I think one of the interesting things, I guess, for for me is, and this is going to sound strange coming from a a white Scottish male, is the white lines that we we tell stories through. I think this is a problem, uh and I think it's a challenge, rather. I think it's a challenge. Is that um climate storytelling is too often told in English. It's too often told through a northern hemisphere privileged prison. I mean, I've just been giving a talk in Switzerland, and whenever I'm in Geneva, I I really feel this is the center of so much policy and so much decision making. And it's kind of multicultural, but it's not. And I think that you know, even within the the UN, a lot of storytelling is told through white lines. And I think that one of the ways that we can really empower people is by is to give them these storytelling skills. I have a dear friend from Vara Reilly, a point photographer who's who's engaged in a project right now in a Congo, which is giving photography skills to Congolese to try and try and help them tell their own stories. And that's a good investment. That's sound investment. Going back to globalization story, it shouldn't really be people like me parachuting in and telling the story locally, it should be local people trying to tell the story. But then that also creates one single problem and it's platform. And platform for me is probably the single biggest challenge that we have as climate storytellers. I have a list, I have an idea spanking on my laptop of the climate stories. And there are there's probably about 300 stories around the world, every corner of the world. And I get around to doing my stories over time. But one of the biggest challenges is finding the platform, particularly the kind of stories I tell, or you know, I tell with my team, which is you know, beautiful cinematography, incredible words, incredible photography with the world's best photographers. But A, that's expensive, to be honest. But also, it's also hard to get a platform for that story. So the BBC aren't doing enough storytelling, or or they're doing a lot of financial partnerships. The BBC with NGOs really pay to platform stories on climate, if you can believe that, which I think is unethical. But then there's also lots of scenarios where certain newspapers won't carry stories of that weight. You know, and it there's only so many stories you can publish in the guard in. And the arduous areas you've reacted in the guardian, guardian, and you just believe, right? And you're really not winning over any audiences. You want to tell that story in Daily Mail or the New York Post, or certainly some of the Australian tabloids just started covering climate as you know, a lot more vigorously after the fires, as we know. So platforms are a huge issue. I mean, I recently joined the board of Waterbear. And Waterbear is really worth looking at. You know, obviously, a declared interest, I'm a trustee and I advise Waterbeer on storytelling. And Waterbear is a dedicated climate storytelling platform. It's a Netflix for climate. That's basically the top line, right? Right. And my ambition and I hope for Waterbear is Waterbeer becomes more confrontational in their storytelling. In this detention economy, we really have to put a marker. We have to have more target-oriented journalism. We have to be more robust in our storytelling, more truthful and more unforgiving in some respects to make people listen. And I think that the more platforms we have that dedicate content to climate, the better. And that probably includes brands. You know, I'm I'm so sick of going to international conferences. And I lecture at Cambridge and I'm a media leader at WEF, and I know how this world works, but I'm fed up being told that Patagonia are doing this and Patagonia are doing that. If I had a dollar for every time Patagonia is mentioned as a model for how we should climate storytelling our millionaire, why aren't we talking about other brands taking that mantle, grabbing the thistle, and becoming climate storytellers in their own right? But then then you have to convince the brand of one simple thing. Tell their story, don't tell yours. Don't try and chew your product into the story. Just tell the story for its merits. Yeah. You know, one of the things we work on at Warribear is this idea of unscripted where there's money given to master storytellers to just tell the story, not to link it back to the brand. And I think there's a lesson for brands listening that they really could become brilliant storytellers by stepping away from their determination to try and market themselves. And I think that's the question I probably wouldn't want you to ask me.
SPEAKER_01Fantastic. Fantastic, Dan. That's been great. If people wanted to know more about yourself, Dan, or any of the topics we discussed on the podcast today, where would you have me direct them?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, you could start with my film company Murin, M-I-R-E-N, Murin Media. You know, certainly a lot of my work here is freely available online, but you know, there's there's some incredible journalists out there that are covering climate. I would I would recommend that people read about the the recent murder of Dom Phillips, extraordinary journalist in the Amazon, a guardian freelance journalist. And and this is the one thing about journalism is it can be a thank a thankless task. You know, journalists are over-educated and underpaid, and that are journalists, there are journalists dying in record numbers. There are environmental activists dying in record numbers for telling the truth. And you know, you can make an argument that time will time will serve them well, people will look back and think that they were crescent, they were heroes, they were that doesn't really comfort their families. The fact that so many journalists are being targeted right now for storytelling and being killed and being kidnapped is appalling. And and then we have this tension between between governments and vested interest and the truth, which is an old story, but it's at the heart of the world at the moment. Because one of the one of the side effects, of course, of the pandemic is that there's definitely a push towards autocracy in a lot of parts of the world. Someone in the north who runs an incredible NGO that works with democracy in parliaments across the world told me recently there's been a thousand tasks since the pandemic. And you really think about that and you think, well, where does that put us in terms of storytelling in the future? So, yeah, I would also suggest looking at some amazing NGOs, obviously, that are about working in this sphere, particularly with indigenous peoples. I'll send you a list because I can't think of talking about it.
SPEAKER_01Fantastic, fantastic. Dan, that's been really great. Thanks a million for coming on the podcast today.
SPEAKER_00You're very welcome. Thank you for giving me the time to speak. Thanks, Tom.
SPEAKER_01Okay, we've come to the end of the show. Thanks everyone for listening. If you'd like to know more about Climate 21, feel free to drop me an email to tom.raftere at sap.com or connect with me on LinkedIn or Twitter. If you like the show, please don't forget to subscribe to it in your podcast application of choice to get new episodes as soon as they're published. Also, please don't forget to rate and review the podcast. It really does help new people to find the show. Thanks. Catch you all next time.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Buzzcast
Buzzsprout
Wicked Problems - Climate Tech Conversations
Richard DelevanClimate Connections
Yale Center for Environmental Communication
The Climate Pod
The Climate Pod
Climate Action Show
Climate Action Collective
The Climate Question
BBC World Service
Energy Gang
Wood Mackenzie
Climate Positive
HASI
Climate One
Climate One from The Commonwealth Club