Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Climate Confident is for business leaders, climate professionals and policymakers who need to understand what is actually cutting emissions—and what it takes to make those solutions work at scale.
Each Wednesday, technology and sustainability analyst, keynote speaker and former SAP Global VP Tom Raftery speaks with the executives, engineers, scientists, founders and policymakers turning climate ambition into measurable progress. Together, they examine the technologies, business models, policies and implementation strategies reshaping energy, transport, industry, supply chains, food and finance.
These are not conversations about distant targets, vague pledges or greenwash. They are candid discussions about what is working, what is failing, where the real bottlenecks lie, and how leaders can make better decisions about decarbonisation, resilience, investment and risk.
You will hear:
- Proven approaches to reducing emissions
- Hard-earned lessons from real-world implementation
- Analysis of the markets, technologies and policies driving the transition
- Honest examination of costs, trade-offs, setbacks and unintended consequences
- Practical ideas for turning climate commitments into action
New episodes are published every Wednesday at 7am CET. Subscribers also receive bonus episodes featuring highlights, analysis and emerging themes from across the series.
Follow Climate Confident for practical climate solutions, informed debate and the insights you need to turn ambition into measurable progress.
Guest suggestions and feedback are welcome at Tom@tomraftery.com.
Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Enhanced Rock Weathering’s Scaling Bottleneck Is Proof, Not Rock
Get in touch - leave me a message
Enhanced rock weathering looks deceptively simple: crush suitable rock, spread it on farmland and let chemistry remove CO₂. The harder question is whether you can prove that removal reliably enough to make the economics work.
I speak with Chris Zair, Director of Partnerships at UNDO, about what happens when enhanced rock weathering moves from controlled trials into real fields. For buyers, investors and policymakers, the stakes are practical: measurement and verification can account for roughly half the cost stack, and weak data can stop credible carbon removal from becoming financeable infrastructure.
We look at why disappearing rock creates an unusual MRV problem, what changes when carbon-credit contracts pay only on delivery, and why having plenty of rock and farmland still does not guarantee scale. We also examine the trade-off between durability, cost and speed - including why particle size can radically alter how quickly CO₂ is removed.
Listen now to understand what is really holding back enhanced rock weathering - and what has to change for carbon removal to become measurable, financeable and repeatable at scale.
Sign up to Climate Confident+ for deep dive analysis of the major climate and energy stories of the day.
Podcast subscribers
I'd like to sincerely thank this podcast's amazing subscribers:
- Anita Krajnc
- Cecilia Skarupa
- Ben Gross
- Jerry Sweeney
- Andreas Werner
- Stephen Carroll
- Roger Arnold
And remember you too can Subscribe to the Podcast - it is really easy and hugely important as it will enable me to continue to create more excellent Climate Confident episodes like this one, as well as give you access to the entire back catalog of Climate Confident episodes.
🎤 Looking for a keynote speaker on climate, energy, AI, or sustainability?
I help executive audiences understand the technologies, trends, and decisions shaping the low-carbon transition.
Download my Speaker Pack: https://tinyurl.com/spkrpck
And a quick note before you go: I’ve started a new Reddit community for serious, evidence-led discussion on climate solutions, clean energy, decarbonisation, policy, technology, and what actually works in practice.
If you’d like to suggest future guests, challenge ideas from the show, or share climate reports and solutions worth discussing, join us at r/ClimateConfident
With enhanced rock weathering, it's a real challenge because you're in the, these open soil systems. And essentially the proof that CDR has taken place, or some of the proof that CDR has taken place with enhanced rock weathering, is the lack of existence of the rock that you've put there.
Tom Raftery:And if you can't measure removal reliably, you don't just have a science problem, you have a credibility, finance and scaling problem. Good morning, good afternoon, or good evening, wherever you are in the world. This is Climate Confident Stories and Strategies that Cut Emissions episode 297, and I'm your host, Tom Raftery. Chris Zair is Director of Partnerships at UNDO. And the real question here is what it takes to move enhanced rock weathering from promising chemistry, to something buyers, farmers, and financiers can trust at scale. Chris, for anyone new to this, what exactly is enhanced rock weathering?
Chris Zair:Definitely. So in, enhanced rock weathering, it's in the field of carbon removal technologies, which scopes nature-based elements all the way through to your kind of direct air capture and enhanced rock weathering really sits in, sits in the middle. It's a nature-enabled approach with a permanence. You're looking at kind of 10 to 100,000 year permanence. So from our side, it's a, a best of both. And The weathering process has happened naturally on, on Earth for tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of years really. It's, you're looking at silicate rocks, so things like basalt. So you've got huge basalt formations. Think of the Giant's Causeway over in Ireland. What happens rain reacts with the CO2 in the atmosphere, so when rain hits the ground, it's actually a weak carbonic acid, so there's, there's CO2 in there, and we know that's the stuff we're trying to remove, from the atmosphere. So, when rain lands on the Giant's Causeway, it's really, really gradually dissolves the Giant's Causeway. What we do with enhanced rock weathering is we're speeding that up. So we looked at the comparison. It's as if you put a, if you put a, a whole coffee bean in your mug of coffee in the morning, you would get a very, very weak coffee. You wouldn't get any dissolution. You probably wouldn't see the color, change at all. But if you crush that coffee up, grind it up like we do in the, the coffee-making process, you'll suddenly see there's a lot more of that coffee coming into contact with the water, then you make a pretty good brew of coffee. So what we're doing with enhanced rock weathering is, similar. We're increasing the surface area of the rock. So we're crushing up the rock then spreading it up on agricultural land. What happens then is the accelerating that natural process because yeah, when the rainwater falls on the land, you're then dissolving that rock. The dissolution is, happening. Depends on the type of rock, how fast it's going to dissolve. But over time, you've got two real things. You've got micronutrients being released into the soil, so the things that the, plants love that you'd often find in chemical fertilisers are being released into the soil. The uptake is different with different plants, but it's… Yeah, we're, we're seeing there's a positive impact for different, crop types. So that's the kind of the, co-benefit side of things, and then there's also the carbon removal side of things. So when these silicate rocks dissolve, they're releasing cations so magnesium cations into the soil that react. Essentially, that process is reacting, and it's locking up the CO2 from the atmosphere as a solid bicarbonate. So rather than going back into the atmosphere, it's gradually locked up as a solid bicarbonate form that moves gradually down the soil columns. So it's moving down the soil, and it will gradually make its way into, the river systems, into the ocean systems, and then that will be locked up there for tens of thousands of years. So that CO2 cycle is where we're really interfering in the CO2 cycle by placing these silicate rocks there, preventing the CO2 getting drawn back up into the atmosphere.
Tom Raftery:And what about measurement? Because measurement seems to become a make or break issue for enhanced rock weathering right now, right?
Chris Zair:Big time because, I mean, with any carbon credit, so whether that is reforestation, whether that is direct air capture, biochar, or rock, enhanced rock weathering, it's-- you're only as good as the credits that you can generate. And to generate credits, you need to be able to measure, measure what is happening. You need to be able to justify that a, a ton of carbon has been removed from the atmosphere. And for what we define as open system, technologies like enhanced rock weathering this is really challenging because it's not like biochar where you can, go through the pyrolysis process and pick up a lump of biochar or for reforestation. You can visibly see that tree, and you can, estimate pretty much how, how much carbon is there, and you can prove that it's been sequestered because that tree is there. With enhanced rock weathering, it's a real challenge because you're in the, these open soil systems. And essentially the proof that CDR has taken place, or some of the proof that CDR has taken place with enhanced rock weathering, is the lack of existence of the rock that you've put there. Is the fact that it has, dissolved, which presents real challenges when it comes to, measurement. But we're in a, really exciting moment because when you'd have spoken to Simon and Mel a couple of years ago, there were no credits generated. There weren't even methodologies that approached this. And we're now… It's now over twenty thousand credits that have been verified for enhanced rock weathering. So we're moving from a, "Can this be done?" into a, "How scalable is this measurement? Are there different measurement approaches?" It's a really positive time to have come from that kind of real question mark. Is this, measurable? There's no kind of question is the CDR taking place? But you need to generate credits. You need to be able to prove how much and, and when, and the kind of time frames. And we're now in this, period where companies are proving it. And it's then now looking to the future is how can you prove this at a, a, much greater scale?'Cause there's no point in removing and verifying twenty thousand tons of, carbon or generating twenty thousand credits because you're not really having an impact on, on what we're all here for, Tom.
Tom Raftery:Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So how does it scale? How well does it scale? And how can you measure and verify it?
Chris Zair:Yeah. So there's-- in terms of the, measurement approaches that are out there at the moment, you're trying to understand what is happening in the soil and what is happening in the liquid, in the kind of the rainwater as it pulls through. And this is one of the challenges of being in, in an open system. If we were doing this all on top of a, a swimming pool where some of the scientific research centers are doing that, and you're essentially able to catch all of that water as it pulls through, then you can understand everything that's going on. But there's not many farms out there when you do this at scale that are built on top of a swimming pool. So it's how do we take those kind of perfect conditions that you might find in a, lab or in these research sites, and then how can you get similar results out in the field with the farmers? Because what we don't want to be doing is making assumptions that, okay, this happens in a lab or this happens in a perfect trial site, therefore this will also happen out in the field. We need to remove any of those assumptions or as many of those assumptions as possible and that requires us to be able to measure what is happening in the actual deployment sites or the fields in which we are, in in which we are spreading the rock. The big thing we're working on at the moment at UNDO, and you might have seen a, a release recently, is how can we create a scalable measurement technique that allows us to continuously pick up the soil pore water and the soil samples from our measurement sites? Because with the climate conditions that we've got at the moment, it might be that you can go out and take soil samples and get of brilliant data coming through or take pore water samples and get loads of pore water coming through when the climate conditions are brilliant, when there's been good rainfall. But more often than not using traditional techniques like ri-rhizon samplers or lysimeters, so you're thinking kind of syringes that you leave in the soil and you try and, you try and draw out the pore water from the soil. If the climate conditions are good, brilliant. That's really, really good. But if, there's any deviation or if there's not that much rainfall, the ability to, for you to consistently draw water and understand what's going on in the soil is really, really challenging. Or you might have found a rodent has come along and nibbled through your lysimeter, and therefore you've gone back and you're thinking you're gonna get all this great data, but you can't pick it up. So this is something that we faced at UNDO, and we've been doing this for… Well, I've been here for, for six years, so we've been, been doing this a while, is this kind of trial and error across all these different measurement techniques. And we found that there was just a low level of consistency in the data that you're able to collect or the kind of the pore water that you're able to collect from these different techniques. So we've been working really hard with a range of institutions, so John Hutton Institute, Newcastle University, and also in partnership with McLaren, to look at this end-to-end sampling approach and work out how can we make this more reliable? How can we make it more efficient? How can we make it more cost-effective? And we've launched SAT-C and this, this starts in the field, so we've had field teams out there with manual augers. So think of the equivalent of kind of standing on a spade and having to shove it into the, soil. And we've all, we've all been there where in the summertime it's really tough to get in. So this is kinda the first challenge is how do you get this stuff, how do you get the auger into the soil? So we've created a, a battery-powered auger, and this is the part with McLaren that allows us to not require big, burly field technicians to be able to stamp it into the soil and be able to do this in a really replicable, replicable way. So this has been a brilliant process with us and, and, and McLaren and their design team to how to, how to design this automatic battery-powered auger that allows the team just to go out there and repeat, repeat, repeat. You're getting consistent soil samples taken up, and they'll come up, come up in a, in a, kind of a cylinder, up to 30 centimeters depth. So this is the kind of the first part of the puzzle is being able to go, out there and actually take the samples in different soil conditions, in different weather types. And I think it's a real benefit to our field teams when they, when they report back and say, "Okay, this is saving us time. It's allowing us to be consistent."'Cause if you, screw up 25% of your samples, it means there's a lot… There's a cost, there's a frustration for the team, there's a time, there's a time issue if you're looking at specific windows for, for taking these samples. So that's where it starts and then
Tom Raftery:And are, are they providing your field team with vehicles to get to site?
Chris Zair:So not, not yet. That would be, that would be pretty good. And we've had a few people-- We've been, we've been on site at the McLaren base, and there's been a few people over who are very happy and that they'd love to have some of their vehicles. But at the moment, at the moment, not yet
Tom Raftery:Fair enough. Okay. And is, is SAT-C basically a better receipt for an invisible transaction then?
Chris Zair:Yeah, exactly. So, I mean, SAT-C is just… The, the auger is the first part of SAT-C. So the auger allows us to take that sample, and then you might have a really, really dry sample. So you're taking that sample to, the labs, and the SAT-C process carries on at the labs. So it's how do you consistently extract the pore water. So you are… yeah, it's a receipt. It's allowing you to understand what is typically gonna be un-unknown. If you're, if you're using other techniques, if you're using a syringe, you're not drawing any of that water out. So you two could be taking the same, core of, of soil where with traditional approaches, you get nothing. You're getting no water from that. What SAT-C is allowing us to do is to take that to the labs. We then dry it and prepare it in a special way, in a proprietary way, and then we use centrifugal force to draw out all of the pore water from that soil column. This end-to-end process from the field teams all the way through to the labs and then what we're passing on to our external labs for analysis allows us to generate just consistency. Because the whole challenge here is it's not can you do this under perfect conditions and do it once because there's no real, value in just being able to do it once and not have that transferable. So everything we've done at UNDO is, okay, we need to be able to do this in a really, really tough conditions with really dry soils in different parts of the world, and we also need to be able to pass this on to a different team. This can't be a kind of a, a recipe that only your grandmother can recreate in her kitchen. It needs to be something that you can pass on to these different teams. Otherwise, enhanced rock weathering will just remain a kind of a niche, niche, thing that never makes it to the scale that it, needs to be
Tom Raftery:And where does this standardised SAT-C method matter most? Is it in places where you have dry soils, different climates? Is it about lowering cost? Is it about buyer confidence?
Chris Zair:It's a bit of everything really, 'cause we are now-- as I mentioned at the start, we're now moving from this does ERW work? Can it be credited? We're now moving to this, What's the data that you can provide us to justify and, and demonstrate that the work has been carried out, and how can you then make this, scalable? What SatC provides now is that ability for us to, replicate this process. We're not out there doing kind of trial and error, doing three or four different techniques, which are, costly to do, and you're asking the field teams to be out there as part of a science experiment, right? You are suddenly moving from a science experiment where you've got these multiple techniques into the ability to say, "Okay, we're gonna take one type of sample, and from that sample, we've got our liquid,
Tom Raftery:we've
Chris Zair:got our soil samples from the same, sample." You see you've got the soil data coming from the same sample. So you're removing questions around, okay, well, you got the water from there and you got the soil from here. How can you prove that those are the same? You actually, by having this, coming from the same soil core, you're not only saving costs, but you're removing uncertainty. So it's allowing us to drive costs down around MRV as well, which is at the moment, pretty much fifty percent of the cost stack for enhanced rock weathering is MRV. So if you can drive, costs down, drive efficiency, then also pass this on to new operations in different parts of the world, 'cause again it comes back to, get to the kind of the, the four billion tons, which is often cited as the, target or the potential for enhanced rock weathering. There are assumptions that you're able to measure on different soil types or there's assumptions that you're able to measure in areas where there is rainfall in one part of the year, but then you've got a lot of, dry spells. And unless you've got a technique which is consistent and you can stand behind and say, "Yes, we know that is gonna work," you're really going to fall short. So it's, pivotal for, for all of the areas that you mentioned, for cost, for consistency, for, financiers as well, because they're looking for this, ability to create consistent data. And the data that we're getting from SatC is providing-- We're starting to provide that confidence that the projects that they're financing are delivering the data that will allow the credits to be generated. A lot of carbon is this kind of cyclical, how can you unlock finance that can be driven time and time again into these projects?
Tom Raftery:Sure, sure, sure. And obviously proof only matters if deployment works outside of the lab. So at commercial scale, where does ERW get messy? Is it around rock supply? Is it around transport, farmers, timing, contaminants, cost, something else, all of the above?
Chris Zair:ERW done well should be able to navigate… I mean, all of those are pitfalls for ERW done badly. I think the, most important thing is soil health. We come back to a kind of, as a minimum, do no harm. So you need to be testing, the feedstock. And this is a kind of a fear that people go out there and spread feedstock. There's a, there's a fear that we give off the idea that ERW is easy. It's just about spreading rock, finding rock, crushing rock, and spreading rock, and it-- that's really not the case. You need to be going through all these kind of safety checks for the feedstock that you're picking up at the start. But provided that you've gone through those steps or you're removing any contaminants in there, in the feedstock that you've got, there's a heck of a lot of feedstock out there. We're getting contacted by people every week saying, "Look, we've got this, we've got this basalt feedstock, or we've got this wollastonite feedstock, but we don't know how to, turn it into enhanced rock weathering. Come and, come and help." So I think that there's, there's huge amounts of feedstock in different parts of the world. Where it does get messy is, data, is the ability to collect end-to-end data, because the registries, so the, the Isometrics, the Puro.Os who are the… For those who don't know, they're the kind of the gold standard, the the Veras of the permanent carbon removal world, who have come and created the standards and the protocols for enhanced rock weathering and, and a few of the other newer technologies. There's a lot of data that you need to collect for a project, even more so when it's an open system an open system project, because you need to be able to prove exactly what type of rock you have spread, where, how much of it. Otherwise, someone's just gonna be like, "Well, it's disappeared, has it?" I don't know how. So brilliant. You've-- It's… The rock's disappeared, therefore you've, you generated loads of credits. No, you need to be able to prove exactly the type of mineralogy of the rock that you've, moved from the quarry, justify what you've spread on each, field, be able to track the time and the volume that's being spread on each field. So I think where it gets messy is that, data piece and being able to really understand every piece of data that you need to collect from the operational side and then also from an MRV side, making sure that you're taking your baseline samples in the right way so that you're comparing the changes in the soil or the changes in the pore water to a solid baseline.
Tom Raftery:Okay. And just to give me an idea of scale, if you're spreading, make up numbers here, a, a thousand tons of basalt, crushed basalt onto a field, roughly how much CO2 is that gonna sequester?
Chris Zair:So it's a very good question. The rate of CO2 that's removed is really dependent on, largely on the feedstock that you've got. So not every basalt is the same. So before we do any operations, we need to really understand what's the mineralogy of that feedstock? What are the different minerals that, kind of feedstock comprise. So we'll send it off to, to labs to do XRD and XRF analysis. From that, you can understand, okay, what's the theoretical total potential of per ton of rock, how much CO2 can we remove? And then you look at how, to go back to the coffee bean analogy, how fine can I crush this, coffee bean, this, this basalt rock? Because the particle size of the reactive surface area, essentially how much of that rock is coming into contact with rainwater, then drives how quickly that CO2 is being removed. So you might have a basalt that is a, a four to one ratio, so I spread four tons of rock to get one ton of CO2 removed. But if it's really big chunks, that might take you a thousand years. Whereas if you can crush it up really finely, you might be removing that, the one ton over a 10-year period. But as a, as a kind of a, a rule of thumb, you could be looking at some of these feedstock that we're looking at anything from a three to one ratio, so three tons of rock, even sometimes down as, down as, fine as two tons, two tons of rock to one ton of CO2, all the way up to eight. Eight tons is really you're looking at from a, an economic side of things, it becomes more challenging to remove, to make the economics work if you're having to spread eight tons of rock to, remove one ton of CO2. But that's, yeah, a lot of the operations that we're looking at is three, three, four, five tons of rock per, per ton of CO2
Tom Raftery:Okay. And for eight tons and above, there's got to be a Fawlty Basalt or Basalt Fawlty joke in there somewhere.
Chris Zair:They're very good. Yeah, don't mention the war. So yeah, but there are hopefully, because we're driven at the moment by unit economics around someone having to buy the rock and someone having to spread the rock and high costs at their unit economic side at the kind of when you're looking at trying to vertically integrate operations. But there is a future where even the quarry owner or the rock owner is able to join in more in a kind of a partnership where you're not-- Those costs can be reduced over time when, where people, it's not a transactional approach. So I think there is even the potential to look at those slower weathering or less potent feedstocks, because carbon removed over fifty years is still, really useful for us. And but at the moment, the kind of the commercial driver is we need carbon removed by twenty thirty or twenty thirty-five. Yeah, I wouldn't rule out if, if people are listening and being like, "Okay, I've, I've got a basalt, and I've done some, some testing on it." There is a future. There needs to be a future for all of these kind of safe silicate feedstocks to, to be used because we wanna get every, every farmer on the planet removing CO2 and have this become as synonymous with farming as spreading fertiliser or spreading, lime because that's really how we get to, significant scale
Tom Raftery:Mm-hmm. And what's the relationship like then with the farmers? And is there anything the farmers have taught you that a lab trial never could?
Chris Zair:We've got to be really careful when we're working with farmers because if you're a tech, you're just gonna seen as a, a tech startup, whether it's climate tech or, or whatever. Farmers know their land back to front, and if you come in and start claiming ridiculous yields, why, with kind of one year of yield data or, less than that, they see this coming a long way out. So we've, we've learnt that, and we know that we've-- we're building really, really strong relationships from within the farming community. So we've done that in Scotland, and then we're doing this similarly in, in Canada, is really starting to open up everything, to show them all the mineralogy and let them really understand exactly what you're putting on the land 'cause you've got to build that confidence, with them. But then once you're inside that farming community, and we've seen that from time to time where you've, tried and tried and tried to get farmers on board, then you get one on board, then someone's looking over the fence. It's anecdotal evidence. We're like, a bit greener over there." And then suddenly you'll get a flurry of messages the next week 'cause they've been down the pub and told them about, " Oh, UNDO aren't that bad." And you you slowly get into those relationships, and they're the first ones to come back to you and say, "You know that trial that you did on my land? I can now see that there is a slightly stronger higher corn growth or stronger grass if they've just been doing it on grassland." So it's amazing to work closely with those farmers and, and they're ensuring that, we go to the lengths that we need to do from an agronomic perspective before we start claiming that this is gonna be a world-saving kind of from a crop perspective solution. We know it, We, we know that kind of the potential is there, and we know that there is, a lot of research being done globally where they're starting to see year two, year three consistent crop yield, but we've got to be kind of slowly, slowly with any of those claims as we're, coming through. And as, as a real minimum with farmers, it's a kind of a, absolute do no harm. They get the, the feedstock for free. So it's, it's win-win for the farmers.
Tom Raftery:And does it mean that they need to spread less lime or less fertiliser or something like that? Is there that additional benefit to them? Or does it mean more time on their side because they're doing more spreading because they're now spreading the crushed basalt on top of the other things that we would be spreading on the soil anyway?
Chris Zair:So it's not yet a direct lime, lime replacement, because if you look at the pH shift of lime is going to be a quicker shift when you're applying lime than when you're applying a basalt feedstock. We do see-- we're seeing that kind of buffering, effect of, of silica rocks when, when they're applied, not to the length that you would see with, with lime. So it's not a direct replacement. So we are starting to now see farmers, rather than applying lime every X years, it's maybe they're doing it X plus one. So they're delaying those costs and offsetting those costs slightly. A lot of the early farmers that we work with are the regenerative farmers who are saying, "Look, we understand. We know everything that's in this basalt. We know the kind of the parts of the NPK fertiliser that this could replace, but we're not using that anyway." So they're often the ones that come to us and say, " Look, we wanna do this," because they understand the nutrients in that feedstock that we're spreading. Direct replacement for fertili not there yet, and this is, yeah, not something we're trying to, claim. We think, we can get there over a, a few years, where you're seeing the kind of the positive impact on crops.
Tom Raftery:Okay. And let's, let's talk then about the buyer side because where is the line then between responsible carbon removal and let's say a license to delay emissions cuts?
Chris Zair:It's a really important question, and I think there's been a lot of kind of net zero guidelines have been chopping and changing. I think it's fair to say with any-- if you speak to any sustainability teams, they're not sure about what they're, they're meant to be doing. I'm hoping that there's gonna be a little bit more of kind of consistency now of understanding the role that carbon removal and carbon credits in general play on that journey, and that it's gotta be, decarbonise first. You've gotta be able to show that your decarbonisation pathway is on track before you can then start using carbon, credits. It can't be a credit for everything approach. And a lot of the work we do with our early customers is starting to understand, okay, where are you on that journey? And making sure that they're not just going straight to carbon credits, 'cause you might… We get some come through who don't have a sustainability team. It's just that someone in the team has it's been thrown onto their desk saying, "Okay, we need to go and, do this because X, Y, Z investor has said we need to do it." And a lot of that is kind of the best of intentions, but you have to educate people around the pitfalls, the greenwashing elements that could come out of that. Where we are really seeing people become a lot more interested in what we're doing is where they've got those residual emissions within their carbon calculations, and they know that by 2030 or by 2035, they've really gotta build up the capacity and the supply of, of carbon removals So there, we're seeing more and more people s- moving away from enhanced rock weathering being a, "Oh, that's nice. I can put that in my sustainability report at the end of the year to say that we've been out there and supported that project in Scotland and put some voters out there." It's now moving more towards,"We really, really need these credits. We're now gonna put a portfolio of different carbon removal technologies out there," and ERW is increasingly seen as, one that will be bolstering those, carbon removal targets.
Tom Raftery:But why would a corporate buyer choose ERW instead of more familiar carbon removal pathways?
Chris Zair:It's a balance. What we're typically seeing is that they won't go with one or the other. We are seeing cases where we'd get a, a request come through, and then they understand the cost of, of enhanced rock weathering. So you could be anywhere in the kind of the, around that kind of three hundred dollar per ton mark versus a reforestation where you- you're still gonna be in the, double digits. You're not gonna be up above a hundred, hundred dollars per ton typically. So often we get challenges around how do you convince the finance director to, to sign off on a technology that is more expensive, and this is where the portfolio approach is beneficial. You'll get some, to be honest, that just go straight for filter by price. Does it tick the, box? And we filter by price, and you say,"Look, brilliant we'll try and educate," and maybe they'll come back and do five percent of their portfolio as something more expensive and more durable. you've got to let people go on that, journey, and we're already seeing people who have been on that journey come back round and say, "Okay, we now need to build something that's more durable and more, scalable." And this is where enhanced rock weathering has one of, one of its fortes is we're not building machines. We're not building a biochar pyrolysis machine. We're not building a DAC plant. The switch to go from nothing to operational, once you've got through the hurdles of understanding is it, is it the right rock type and stuff like that, it's pretty quick to be out there distributing and spreading the rock on, on these operations on the kind of the operational fields. So when customers have said, "Okay, maybe first off, we want five thousand tons as-- for a whole portfolio at the start for twenty-thirty," they're now saying, "Okay, twenty thirty-five, this is gonna be a much bigger, target. What are the scalable approaches that we can do to get there?" And ERW has really been pushed to the front as a really scalable approach because that ability to ramp up operations and bring in the supply of these, credits is, it's seen as a real strength.
Tom Raftery:And over the next 5, 10 years, let's say out to 2035, what has to happen for ERW to matter at, let's say, climate scale?
Chris Zair:Finance is the key because for any of these projects the benefit of building a DAC plant is that you have, assets there. Even before credits are not generated, you have an asset that can be financed against. With biochar, there is a, track record of credits being delivered for biochar. So if I'm a financier saying, "Would I put my money into this biochar project?" You're more confident to be able to put cash in there, which allows biochar projects to go out and sign offtakes where buyers pay on delivery.'Cause this is the, conundrum that we're in, in the carbon market, is that the early purchasers that came through, the early frontier and Microsoft purchasers had some money upfront, so you could go to an early technology. Early technology takes that cash and goes to try and make, it happen. The contracts were written away in a way where if you didn't make it happen, they're not gonna come after you. You need to try and make it happen as best as you can. But there is the level of security there where it's you're trying to scale these technologies. Whereas now, a lot of these secondary contracts, a lot of the big the newer frontier, the newer Microsoft contracts that are coming through are all payment on delivery. So you've got this huge contract, but unless you can finance it and get cash in, you're stuck. And it's really dangerous to be spending equity money on operational costs 'cause then you can, get stuck. So that's the question has always been: How do we, how do we get the financial markets involved? How do we unlock credit? How do we unlock debt for, for these types of projects? And for a few years, it's been, "Well, come back to us once you've got some credits," or, "Come back to us once you've proven that the rock that you're spreading, that you say is so fantastic, is actually going to generate the credits that allow you to pay back this whole cycle," which is completely fair enough. But what we are seeing is because we're going through these first rounds of verification, people are now picking up the phone. They're kind of-- These conversations are now advancing with a lot of these banking partners, and we signed our first debt, facility deal with Inlancis, who are a fund in Canada for a Microsoft contract that we signed last, last year. we're now getting to this place where we're able to unlock debt that can allow this cyclical process, this kind of self-fulfilling process of ERW to happen. Because we can get, the contracts in, and these contracts should start to grow over the coming years. We can then unlock the debt that allows us to get the operations going, and then you create this flywheel effect where you deliver the credits, and the credits repay the customers, more offtakes come in. You get that cash from the customers to pay back the majority of the debt. And you've got this flywheel. And this is something that for ERW to get to the scale it needs to over the next few years and can continue growing, we need to continue generating credits. We need to continue generating proof of work that demonstrates to the financiers that this is actually relatively low risk. SAT-C plays a huge part in that because it's, proving that consistency. So it feels like we're at the, edge from moving from a science project into a project that is now scalable at commercial scale. It's exciting, and I think we're, there. We do need more buyers to come into this market. We need that continuation of, buyer demand. The compliance markets are hopefully not decades away, but there is that, need to bridge the gap for these operators to continue growing until we get to the compliance markets, which should hopefully open up more demand and consistent demand in the future.
Tom Raftery:And a left field question for you now, Chris. If you could have any person or character, alive or dead, real or fictional, as a champion for ERW, who would it be and why?
Chris Zair:That is a great question. Well, I'm, hot off watching The Lord of the Rings, and I think you can't go beyond Gandalf the Grey turning into Gandalf the White kind of looking after you, because we're on a, a journey. You could potentially frame the kind of Sauron as the evil of, of, climate change. So having Gandalf by our side, yeah, I, I'd say I, I choose Gandalf to guide us through the next the next months and years
Tom Raftery:Brilliant. Chris, before we wrap, let's pin down cost. How much is a tonne of ERW carbon removal today compared with, let's say, planting a tree in Borneo? And how far can you realistically drive that cost down?
Chris Zair:So we always come at this, we need to be doing everything, right? This isn't me coming on saying, "Don't plant that tree in Borneo." We need to be doing everything, and this is where the kind of the beauty of portfolios comes in because you get that balanced price. At the moment, we're operating in the kind of the low, to mid three hundreds per ton of-- That's US dollars, so high two hundred pounds. And there is a ability in new regions to drive that down where the input costs are a lot, lower. So this is our kind of our main operation is in Ontario, in Canada, which are really-- This has been an important first step because you've got stable geography, you've got stable politics. So from an investor perspective, they're like, "Brilliant, I'm happy to finance that operation," because it's very unlikely… Well, I don't want to say that. It's very unlikely that they're gonna kinda come into kind of hostile conditions up in, up in Ontario. But on the flip side, you've got pretty high input costs up there. Whereas some of the new operations that we're looking at with partners, your input costs are, half the cost. So you, you've got the ability, if you can nail MRV at a kind of a scalable, reliable way, that you can be getting down into the, into the low two hundreds. The challenge is that MRV piece. So once you've reduced your input costs because you've built really strong long-term relationships with, your rock supplier, once you've reduced those input costs, it's then MRV. And to be honest, you can, spend thousands of tons on MRV and not get any data. So this is the whole challenge that… Projects have been spending. If you look at the verified credits to money that's gone into ERW at the moment, they're not, three hundred and fifty dollar a ton credits. they're much higher. And that really, the driver behind that is, MRV. And going back to where we started the conversation, SAT-C allows you to focus on a single, technique, so you're eliminating all the costs of doing your science experiments. And then you're taking that reliable in-field measurement data, which is the starting point, but over time, the aim is to be able to predict what's gonna happen in certain field types. So moving from a heavy measurement approach, which is high cost, towards gradually towards a, an informed calibrated model approach, still being grounded in some measurement. But over the next decade, this is what we're looking to get to that can really, really drive MRV costs down and have the chance to get really down to that golden two hundred dollars per, ton mark
Tom Raftery:Okay. And what are the chances of ERW ever hitting that four gigaton mark?
Chris Zair:I think we need, government support, and this is something that we've been frustrated about over the last few years. We really need governments to take this seriously because the input, the kind of-- the resources are there. There is no doubt that the resources are there, and this is what the studies have been based on. It's like, is there enough of the right type of rock and is there enough farmland? And, yes if it was that simple, if it was as simple as crushing up the right type of rock and getting it on the farmland, then we'd be able to… I'd be very confident. But it's what are the steps, Tom, to get us between knowing that stuff is there, but also then being able to fund and get into these agricultural networks. And we've seen in the US, lesser at the moment, the kind of the subsidies around carbon removal projects and carbon credit subsidies coming in that have really previously helped accelerate these, carbon removal technologies. If we can start to see similar momentum in, the UK, in the-- in Europe, which we are starting to see, and we're also seeing this in Canada at the moment, where government procurement schemes are coming in and kind of tax incentives for, for carbon removal projects, that will allow us to reduce the cost early on, get it more into an affordable band for every buyer on the planet, which allows you to then scale up, which further drives down costs. And it would really help give us a a, a head start in driving down, costs and driving up volumes. But the rock is there, the fields are there. The intention is there from, the great ERW project developers that are out there. We just need, we need the support. We need the headwinds, sorry, the tailwinds. We don't need the headwinds. We need the tailwinds to help us, help us get there. But measurement, in particular, is really-- it's taking leaps and bounds at the moment going from, as I said can we measure this? It's now, how do we measure this in a repeatable way?
Tom Raftery:Great. Super. Chris, that's been really interesting. If people would like to know more about yourself or any of the things we talked about on the podcast today, where would you have me direct them?
Chris Zair:I think the most in- interesting stuff is on the UNDO blog. So if you pop to the UNDO website, which is un-do.com, 'cause we couldn't quite get our hands on the UNDO.com URL, but we're working on it. So we've got a blog, blog that you can sign up to there, where we put weekly, information out. You can find out about SAT-C recently being published on a, on an article there. Follow UNDO on, on LinkedIn and social media, depending on your favorite social media types. I think most of them are UNDO, UNDO on there. So you'll be able to find us, but yeah, through the website and, yeah, I'd love to connect with people who are interested in this space, so you can find me on, on LinkedIn putting my name on there. There's not many Chris, Chris Zairs out there
Tom Raftery:Okay, super. Great. Chris, that's been fascinating. Thanks a million for coming on the podcast today
Chris Zair:Brilliant, thanks for having me on
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Buzzcast
Buzzsprout
Wicked Problems - Climate Tech Conversations
Richard DelevanClimate Connections
Yale Center for Environmental Communication
The Climate Pod
The Climate Pod
Climate Action Show
Climate Action Collective
The Climate Question
BBC World Service
Energy Gang
Wood Mackenzie
Climate Positive
HASI
Climate One
Climate One from The Commonwealth Club