Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Climate Confident is for business leaders, climate professionals and policymakers who need to understand what is actually cutting emissions—and what it takes to make those solutions work at scale.
Each Wednesday, technology and sustainability analyst, keynote speaker and former SAP Global VP Tom Raftery speaks with the executives, engineers, scientists, founders and policymakers turning climate ambition into measurable progress. Together, they examine the technologies, business models, policies and implementation strategies reshaping energy, transport, industry, supply chains, food and finance.
These are not conversations about distant targets, vague pledges or greenwash. They are candid discussions about what is working, what is failing, where the real bottlenecks lie, and how leaders can make better decisions about decarbonisation, resilience, investment and risk.
You will hear:
- Proven approaches to reducing emissions
- Hard-earned lessons from real-world implementation
- Analysis of the markets, technologies and policies driving the transition
- Honest examination of costs, trade-offs, setbacks and unintended consequences
- Practical ideas for turning climate commitments into action
New episodes are published every Wednesday at 7am CET. Subscribers also receive bonus episodes featuring highlights, analysis and emerging themes from across the series.
Follow Climate Confident for practical climate solutions, informed debate and the insights you need to turn ambition into measurable progress.
Guest suggestions and feedback are welcome at Tom@tomraftery.com.
Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
The Lithium Isotope Bottleneck Between Nuclear Breakthroughs and Power Plants
Get in touch - leave me a message
Advanced nuclear could have a lithium isotope problem long before it has a commercial power plant. Promising reactor designs need specialist materials that are barely produced at industrial scale.
John Elling, CEO of Molten Salt Solutions, joins me to explain why isotope separation matters to both advanced fission and fusion. Getting enough of the right lithium, at a price developers can plan around, is an engineering and investment challenge - not simply a procurement exercise.
We explore the surprising reason some fission reactors want to avoid lithium-6 while many fusion designs depend on it. We also examine how material prices can change reactor design, and the dilemma facing suppliers asked to invest in production capacity before customers can commit to buying it.
Listen now to understand what needs to happen between a nuclear breakthrough and a power plant delivering electricity to the grid.
Sign up to Climate Confident+ for deep dive analysis of the major climate and energy stories of the day.
Podcast subscribers
I'd like to sincerely thank this podcast's amazing subscribers:
- Anita Krajnc
- Cecilia Skarupa
- Ben Gross
- Jerry Sweeney
- Andreas Werner
- Stephen Carroll
- Roger Arnold
And remember you too can Subscribe to the Podcast - it is really easy and hugely important as it will enable me to continue to create more excellent Climate Confident episodes like this one, as well as give you access to the entire back catalog of Climate Confident episodes.
🎤 Looking for a keynote speaker on climate, energy, AI, or sustainability?
I help executive audiences understand the technologies, trends, and decisions shaping the low-carbon transition.
Download my Speaker Pack: https://tinyurl.com/spkrpck
And a quick note before you go: I’ve started a new Reddit community for serious, evidence-led discussion on climate solutions, clean energy, decarbonisation, policy, technology, and what actually works in practice.
If you’d like to suggest future guests, challenge ideas from the show, or share climate reports and solutions worth discussing, join us at r/ClimateConfident
There's incredibly exciting things going on in the physics of advanced nuclear, in the physics of fusion, but none of this will ever get in to the grid. None of it will ever do any good unless there's a supply chain so that they can take their really cool new physics tricks and build power plants. And the supply chains have to have unique materials that haven't been produced at commercial scale before. Lithium is one of them. There's plenty of others. These are the picks and shovels of the gold rush.
Tom Raftery:But here's the catch with those picks and shovels, someone has to invest in making them before anyone knows which nuclear designs will succeed. Good morning, good afternoon, or good evening, where ever you are in the world, this is Climate Confident Stories and Strategies that cut emissions Episode 299, and I'm your host, Tom Raftery. My guest today is John Elling, CEO of Molten Salt Solutions, which is working to produce specialist lithium isotopes at industrial scale. He explains why the availability and price of those materials can shape a fusion reactor's design even before a commercial plant exists. John, welcome to the podcast. Would you like to introduce yourself?
John Elling:Thanks, Tom. Yes. My name is John Elling. I am a analytical chemist by training from extremely far back. Went to work at Los Alamos National Labs, largely because Los Alamos National Labs is located in the mountains, and I'm a big fan of hang gliding. And so I picked a job that was as close as possible to my favourite recreation which of course immediately turned into skiing because we have some great skiing here in the Alps. And I lasted at Los Alamos for seven years and left to start a company which was artificial intelligence and chemistry, which was about 20 years before its time. But then that taught me a lot about startups and particularly got me very excited about the value of new technologies and in particular how to get that value in the hands of people that can use it. So I stayed in the entrepreneurial space stayed in New Mexico. I've worked very closely back with Los Alamos in helping them transfer technology out of the national labs. And in particular I have looked at how to create the first commercial implementations of some cool new technology that they've discovered at the, the laboratories. So I've really enjoyed over the years being able to meet some of the best minds in their area, find out what makes them excited about what they're doing, and then help them figure out if this could be commercially viable. Get it out of the lab, get it in the hands of customers and see whether or not we can generate some, some value from it from a commercial standpoint. So that's really what led me to entrepreneurship. I'm still enough of a scientist that when I see something cool, I, I always get engaged by the science, the bright shiny new objects in science. But at the end of the day, my job is to see whether or not we can take that innovation and make it worth something to somebody.
Tom Raftery:And you went on then to found Molten Salt Solutions. You're CEO. What does Molten Salt Solutions make and, and why?
John Elling:Well, molten Salt Solutions is an interesting company. We founded it to look at problems in molten salts for advanced power. And then of course we immediately stopped doing anything in molten salts. So we always end up with sort of a, having to explain that molten salt solutions doesn't do molten salts. What we found is we were looking at molten salts was the real limitation in using molten salts in nuclear applications where there's an infusion, where there's neutrons involved, is the isotopic requirements of some of the elements that are in the salts because there are isotopes that you just don't want to put in a neutron environment, in a nuclear reactor, in a, fusion machine. And we saw that while making the salts was very important, the bottleneck in creating commercial quantities of these salts. And by that I mean hundreds of tonnes of salts, thousands of tonnes of salts was getting hundreds and thousands of tonnes of small stable isotopes to put into the salts. So we pivoted. We said, okay we're going to look at how we can create the capability of enriching small, stable isotopes by the hundreds of tonnes in a cost-effective manner. You can enrich isotopes any way you want, and Los Alamos knows every way to enrich isotopes because one of their jobs is to keep an eye out on people that are enriching isotopes that we don't want to enrich isotopes. So we took a clean sheet of paper and we said, alright, if you want to enrich a thousand tonnes of lithium seven or lithium six, or chlorine 37, how would you do it cost effectively? How could you do it at low risk? Then we started the company in order to create that industrial capability because really the bottleneck in these new approaches to nuclear and fusion one of the major material bottlenecks is that they just need hundreds of tonnes of this and people aren't producing it or they're producing it by the gramme.
Tom Raftery:Why do they need it?
John Elling:That's an interesting question. So when you put elements into neutrons, they become other things. It's transmutation. It's very annoying if you're a chemist because you're here, you are, you're making one thing and then you put it into a reactor and it becomes something else. So when we started looking at these problems, we looked at the elements that were gonna become something problematic. In fact, we started looking at chlorine because the depleted uranium chloride fast reactors, the molten salt reactor technology that is being developed in that area doesn't want the isotope chlorine 35. They want all chlorine 37. And the reason is that 35 captures a neutron and becomes chlorine 36. And chlorine 36 is a nasty, long lived beta emitting radioactive waste. So you just don't wanna make that in your reactor. We looked at that problem and then we looked at lithium, which is a much broader applicability in both molten salt reactors. They used a new generation of small modular reactors and then in fusion after that there's only two isotopes of lithium, lithium six and lithium seven. And amusingly, the two markets, the molten salt reactors all want lithium seven in their salts because lithium six captures a neutron and turns into tritium, and tritium is a radioactive form of hydrogen. So now you're saying, okay, well they wanna avoid generating a nasty form of hot radioactive hydrogen in their new generation of nuclear reactors. Makes perfect sense. In fact, they have to do that now, but they use a little bits of lithium now to prevent the cooling water and the current generation of how pressurised water reactors from becoming corrosive. Again, it's a problem. They want to remove all the lithium six so that they don't generate tritium as a byproduct while they're running their reactors. So they need hundreds and hundreds of tonnes of lithium in their salts that is as pure lithium seven as they can possibly get. Now what's really funny, but what's great for our company is fusion is the next generation of nuclear power after this new generation of fission reactors. They want lithium six for the same reason, because it captures a neutron and generates tritium. And most of the concepts for fusion is the compression of deuterium and tritium atoms. That's their fuel, right? Deuterium is an isotope of hydrogen that's readily available. You can extract it easily from seawater, but tritium they have to make while they run their fusion machines. And they make it by using the fusion neutrons to collide with lithium to produce tritium. So one of our customer markets wants to avoid lithium six because they don't wanna make tritium, and the other market desperately wants to get lithium six because they do need tritium. From our standpoint, that's nirvana because there's only two lithium isotopes, six and seven. And our machines, our, technology, separate them so we can sell one to the molten salt reactor crowd. And one the other end of the process to the fusion crowd.
Tom Raftery:Just to kind of set expectations here, the molten salt route is the small modular reactors that everyone is talking about. And small modular reactors have been five to 10 years away for as long as I can remember. And fusion has been 20, 30 years away for as long as I can remember. Is your market gonna be 10 to 20 to 30 years away for as
John Elling:For forever. Yes. Yes. Well, that's, that is, that's an interesting technical and an interesting commercial question. So I'll start with the technology. Small modular reactors. The generation four of nuclear power is fundamentally different from the current generation of nuclear power, because it's called walkaway safe. What that means is if a tidal wave hits your reactor, or if everybody at the plant suddenly dies simultaneously from a heart attack and you stop managing the fusion reaction, it turns itself off. Alright? So the physics and the design of the plant is that if you're not actively managing it, it turns itself off. Intrinsically safe by design. And some of the molten salt technologies are incredibly clever at how they use just the raw physics of neutron moderation, neutron amplification to control the fission. It's, it's really tremendously cool stuff. And then of course, you're talking about small modular reactors. It's right in there in the name. So making them in a shipyard rather than in these big bespoke projects is a much better commercial model to producing cheaper power as is built. And then you have the opportunity of providing these since they're small, again at a distributed sites. So, you can power a small community rather than an entire state or, or multiple state complex or even a data centre. So I think the business model for small modular reactors and this next generation of nuclear power is finally to the point where it is going to see commercial penetration. The technology is moving along very, very rapidly. The Department of Energy in the United States has really sped up the process of permitting these first of a kind small modular reactors. They've sped it up primarily by getting out of the way, but either way it works. There's 10 to 12 companies in the United States that are all in on developing their approach to this and, are now on the fast track. So I think this is the last time it's five to 10 years away. You see the commercial pull. Kairos has sold six reactors to Google. You see the, the prototypes standing up and operating. The technology is very mature. You see this echoed in other countries. The Chinese have declared that their next generation of nuclear power is going to be molten salt thorium reactors. So fundamentally, new physics fail safe. Now, fusion is a different topic. Fusion, they're not done inventing fusion yet. When I started Molten Salt Solutions, there was 13 companies in fusion. Now there's well over 60. And each one is pursuing a different technology for achieving the fundamentals of fusion, which is taking this deuterium atom and this tritium atom and squeezing it hard enough that you get them to fuse. Thus fusion. So you can argue that that part of my market is still science fiction. But in 2022, Livermore showed that they could actually achieve the pressures necessary to get more energy out than they put in. And that sparked this huge new investment interest and popular interest in moving fusion forward. Since then, as I said, the companies went from 13 to well over 50 closer to 60. There's seven government funded efforts around the world to achieve fusion. And the attitude has changed from, this is an interesting physics experiment to the engineering. Now there's this feeling like we know we can get fusion to produce energy. Now how do we put it in a device that can be used to put electrons on the grid? How can we generate power with it? So it's really a sea change in the attitude of the physicists. Now the physicists are taking a backseat to the engineers, and the engineers are saying, great. Now how do we make it work? How do we build a machine, produce power, make money. And the investors are of course, all over making money. So the, the, The economics is for my company is yes, I am starting a company to sell to science fiction markets, but it is a chicken and an egg problem right now. If they don't know that they can get lithium six, literally they cannot proceed with fusion. Some of the designs require tonnes, tens, hundreds of tonnes of lithium six even in the research. And so, yeah, as an entrepreneur, I, I coach entrepreneurs and I always tell them, start companies for markets that exist. And here I am doing something completely the opposite. So yeah, do, do as I say, not as I do. But it is a, it's a profound chicken and an egg question because if I can't assure the markets that there will be lithium six, then some of them can't design their fusion machines and the others can't design efficient fusion machines. I had a conversation that illustrates this with Thea Energy in New Jersey. They're pursuing a stellarator technology. And I talked to them about the availability of lithium six and did they wanna schedule to buy some in the future? And the chief science officer said, oh, we don't need enriched lithium six, meaning they have designed their fusion machine to use natural abundance isotopes of lithium. And in the same sentence, he said, but if we could get some, we could save on our magnets, right? So what that means is it is now an engineering problem. What is the techno economic optimum? I have to tell them how much it's gonna cost. You can put that into the engineering design. You can't engineer anything until you know how much it's gonna cost. What's the cost benefit of, of a degree of enrichment? And so that's what I'm doing to the market now. You know, right now it's clearly gonna be a need. Just the R&D need in the next five years. They need 500 tonnes of enriched lithium six. You can't buy a kilogramme of it right now. And in the next five years, they need 500 tonnes. So the need is acute. They can't move forward in their R&D to build prototype reactors without it. And they have to know now what the price is gonna be in two or three years, or they can't design it. And that's that what we're working on now.
Tom Raftery:And the big criticisms of nuclear tend to be a) it takes 10, 20, 30 years to build out a, a nuclear power plant. And b), the cost and typically cost overruns of building nuclear are astronomic. And when you compare that to the cost to build out, for example, a solar plant backed with batteries, you're looking at a two to three year timeline versus a 20 year timeline. In that kind of scenario, does nuclear have a future, do you think?
John Elling:Yes. I think that that is one of the real transformational parts of this new effort in advanced nuclear, which is the small and small modular reactors. Because not only does it change the business model of, of where you can put these things, but it means that you can make them in one spot and move them to where you need them. The analogy that people use are shipyards, right? You could build a small modular reactor in industrial complex as, much as ships are built in a shipyard, and then move it to where it's needed. And this goes even as far as people calling them nuclear batteries, where when the fuels are exhausted, you pick them up and you take 'em back to the shipyard and crack them open and add more fuel. And I think this business model is going to get around the problem of these large bespoke plants that are enormously expensive to begin with, and then typically end up three times more expensive by the time they're done with the cost overruns. Because if you can consolidate all of the expertise necessary to make a small modular reactor, and these designs are also simpler, right? Because if the physics turns them off, or if the physics modulates the, fission reaction, then a lot of the plumbing necessary for these safety systems goes away. If you can build them and move them from a central location like a shipyard to where they're needed you're going to reduce the cost of that first water generating capability by a factor of five to 10. And in fact, not only is that work out on putting a hundred megawatt example reactors on the grid, but there are companies like Thor Con, for example, who's looking at, okay, we're gonna literally build these in shipyards and make the next generation of cargo vessel vessels nuclear power. That is also an enormous benefit to the environment because the cargo vessels burn awfully dirty fuel now. You know, It's sort of an example of the extreme reduction in the cost to build these things that you can now, talk about cost effective on big shipping ships.
Tom Raftery:Factory building reactors could change the economics, but that's still a proposition to be demonstrated at commercial scale. The relevant comparison isn't just with yesterday's nuclear plants. It's with the solar storage and other options that investors can build now. And going back to the lithium, what makes lithium isotope enrichment so hard to scale?
John Elling:Lithium is one of the easiest isotopes to enrich, but it's still very, very hard to enrich any isotope. And the problem is isotopes are basically small variations of exactly the same atom. So what do you grab a hold of, right? I'm a chemist. What are you going to grab and pull these things apart? There's just so little difference between an atom of lithium six and an atom of lithium seven that it becomes difficult to separate. What we do is use the weight of the atom. Lithium six is lighter than lithium seven. So we just dissolve a bunch of lithium salt in water and you have those atoms in there vibrating in their little salt hydration environment. And there's a slight vibrational energy difference between a lithium six salt and a lithium seven salt. And so we then contact that with an oil layer, just the same way you'd be making salad dressing, right? You put the water or the, vinegar in there and some oil in there and you shake it up. And what happens is just based on that vibrational energy difference there is a small change in the lithium isotopes of the lithium salt that goes into the oil out of your salt water. Very small and, and it's just that because the lithium six has a slightly smaller vibrational energy than a lithium seven that it hates being in the oil, oil layer less than the lithium seven hates to be in the oil layer. They both hate being in there. It's just lithium six hates it a little less. And we're talking about maybe a 3% difference in their reluctance to go into the oil layer, which means that, the easy thing for us is to make salt water. You just buy some salt, put it in the water, you're done. The hard thing is that we have to then do 3% changes in the isotope ratio a thousand times to go from 7.5% lithium six, which is the natural abundance of lithium, six to 90%. So it's extremely expensive in buying a thousand machines to do a thousand stages of separation between a fresh oil layer and your salt water. And that's why it's very difficult for us to do this. Now we have a magic machine that we spun out of Los Alamo's technology that is extremely efficient at doing that multi-stage separation. So a lot of other companies are actually using the same principle partitioning between salt and oil salt water and oil that we are. And they have one piece of equipment per stage, so it's very expensive for them to buy it to fill it up, to operate it. Our machine will do 400 to a thousand stages of separation in one device. So that's where we get our cost advantage. But it's plain vanilla engineering. It's, it's called an exchange is a chemical engineering purification process. It's been around for 200 years. So we took a low risk approach because we said, look, there's lots of ways of doing this. We just wanna make sure we can get it done. And we also had this magic technology from Los Alamos that made it a hundred times more efficient using this approach. There are companies that are pursuing every other conceivable approach to separating lithium ions. They, turn the lithium into a low temperature atomic gas, right? So you vaporise it in a vacuum and then you hit it with lasers to turn them into ions. Once you've got an ion in a vacuum, that's easy, right? You can just pull that apart with a magnet. So you've got companies that are doing that. You know, you could do centrifuges, you could do plasmas, you can do ions, you could do anything you want. We looked around and said of all of these different ways of enriching lithium, and again, Los Alamo's job is to know how to enrich isotopes. We said that chemical engineering solvent exchange been around for 200 years. We have a way of making it more efficient. That's what we'll choose.
Tom Raftery:And what about then the idea of supply agreements? I mean, you're, you're talking to these startups. Have you got agreements in place? Are you putting agreements in place? Where are you on that kind of spectrum?
John Elling:We've announced two offtake agreements with Gauss Fusion and Type One Energy. And there's a third with another big fusion company in the works, and then a fourth and a fifth and a sixth after that. And these are agreements where yeah, they're, they're at, the end of the day, they're non-binding. I mean, if they don't get their fusion magic to work then they don't have to buy my lithium, of course. And, and even if they had to, they wouldn't be around. So who would I enforce it against? So these are letters of intent. What they're allowing me to do is schedule the production and just these three letters of intent. I've already exceeded my scaling capability. So, from a business problem, three of the 56 companies in Fusion has already exceeded my plans to, scale up production. That really speaks to the demand in this marketplace. But what it does for the fusion companies with whom I'm signing these agreements, it gives them a fixed price point. I'm telling them, look, you can buy enriched lithium six at 90% lithium carbonate for this amount per kilogramme by the hundreds of kilogrammes on this date. So that's giving their engineers something that they can go to and say, all right, if this is the going to be the price of one of the materials in my fusion breeder blanket, then this is how I'm gonna design my fusion breeder blanket. I did a great project with X Fusion. It was really funny because they really wanted to design their breeder blanket. They never published this, which was unfortunate. I wish they had. I gave them the price of the lithium material they wanted in their breeder blanket, and they went back and decided that the optimum enrichment for lithium six in their breeder blanket was 29.13%, which shows you that, yeah, obviously when you know how much it's gonna cost and you can design what the optimum is for the physics and the engineering around that. The reason it was funny is that my prices were good to be like, plus or minus 20%. So I, I thought maybe they had a little too many decimal points in that, but it sort of shows where the industry is now. As they need to know what's coming. They need to know roughly what the price is gonna be and then they can design for it. You, you don't design for unobtainium, right? If you, if you can't find it if you can't buy it, you, you can't design for it.
Tom Raftery:Those disagreements are a useful signal, but there's a distinction worth keeping in view. A non-binding letter of intent gives an engineer a price assumption. It's not the same as a bankable order or an operating supply chain. Sure. Sure. And what about the DOE? What are they working on at the moment in this space? Have they created specs around this and does that tell us anything about the maturity of the market?
John Elling:Well, the DOE is a different beast entirely. The DOE is really the only western world effort that ever enriched lithium, and they did it back in the 1950s and 1960s. They enriched 400 tonnes of lithium six which was an important component of the nuclear weapons programme. And they shut it all down. They used actually liquid, liquid extraction. Same underlying technology that we're using. One of their liquids was mercury, which did not work out well for the environment. But they shut that whole project down. They converted a fair amount of their lithium six that they enriched to tritium, which was what they needed to put into the, the weapons. And Tritium has a 12.8 year half-life. So as we've done this wonderful nuclear arms reduction with Salt One and Salt Two, they just took the tritium and they put it somewhere and they reused it on the remaining warheads when they needed to refresh it. They've run out of tritium. It's been quite a while. It started to decay to the point where they need to generate more tritium. So the US nuclear weapons complex is steadying up their own effort to start doing lithium six enrichment as well to replenish the nuclear stockpile. We very much would like to interest them in becoming a customer for the fusion folks who are producing enriched lithium in the civilian needs because that kind of a dual use makes perfect sense, right? Why, why not buy it rather than make it? The annual reports, I mean, we get to, we, we, of course, all of this is secret. My scientists and I come out of Los Alamos and we all have security clearances and that kind of a thing. But what we do is we follow this particular part of the nuclear weapons programme in their annual report to Congress. And like anything in the government they're enormously behind schedule and over budget. So, we're, we're very much hoping that, as they become aware that there is going to be a civilian market in enriching lithium six for fusion R&D, and eventually fusion commercialisation that we can get them to buy on the open market. And for me, then that becomes a third customer. Now I have the Department of Energy, the US government. I have fusion on lithium six side, and then I have fission for lithium seven. That could really be the foundation of a lithium enrichment market. They could basically make the market by being a government sector of a dual use technology. So we're, we're optimistic that we can make that case. It makes great sense at a high level. We just have to convince the people that would lose their money that, they, they should do it for the greater good. And you, I mean, you know the government, right? I mean, it's, hard to change a an activity that's moving at that speed at, at that level. So as much as it might make sense economically, there's always some government operation that's gonna lose the money that you want to take from them. So we have to address the sensitivities.
Tom Raftery:Okay. And if, if governments want advanced nuclear as a future option, what should they fund now? Should they fund reactors, materials, standards, manufacturing capacity? All of the above? Something else entirely?
John Elling:Yeah, all of the above. I mean, I, you, you look back at, the current generation of nuclear and putting reactors on naval ships in submarines and in aircraft carriers created the civilian nuclear reactor industry. Because they needed to enrich uranium which they did with the same technology, pushed it out into the civilian sector. They needed the materials, they needed the designs. So that's a really great example of the fact that the entire current nuclear industry and design is rooted in the fact that they wanted to put these things on, on naval vessels. The same thing is really going on now. Especially in advanced nuclear. And especially in advanced nuclear for ships. I think that there is a big need for fundamental advances in molten salts. As I said, the permitting environment has changed dramatically in this administration. It used to be that nobody thought you were gonna permit a first of a kind new reactor design. And now if you go to Tennessee, every single building site in Oak Ridge is occupied by a small modular reactor company building their first of a kind reactor. I mean, it's, it's. It's wonderful to see what can happen when, when the government aligns with the commercial drivers. So I would say that to answer your question, all of the above. I think that the, the government has a bunch of technology that they can release and they can fund a bunch of technology, especially in fusion that is going to en enable the engineering around the fusion science that's being done. For example, you have to have some knowledge of the material that you're going to build your fusion machine from. And that material has to hold up to fusion energy neutrons, which are very, very energetic neutrons compared to fission energy neutrons. Fusion energy neutrons are 14.1 million electron volts. So they fly around like bullets compared to marbles rolling across the floor, which is the, fission neutron energy. Where are you going to test your material in 14.1 MEV neutrons? There just isn't a way of doing that. So, the federal government has a really great role. Federal government loves to build big science projects like neutron generators. There's a really great role in creating the infrastructure that says, here is a flux of 14.1 MEV neutrons in some sort of neutron accelerator. Now, the industry can use that to test their materials, which helps the government as well, because how is the government going to permit a particular material in a fusion machine if we don't know how it behaves, if we don't see how it behaves in a high flux of those neutrons. Again, this is another chicken and egg problem, is you have to have the infrastructure that can be used to develop and test materials at that level. I would love the government to fund lots and lots of work on lithium enrichment. Trust me, I'm more than happy to be self-serving about this. There's all sorts of other areas where they need to chip in. And especially with fusion there's a lot of infrastructure that can be enabled by government investing in R&D infrastructure and government participating in the R&D.
Tom Raftery:There's a wider policy point here. Governments don't have to predict the winning fusion design to make useful investments. Shared testing facilities and materials capacity could advance several competing approaches before the market decides which ones scale. And where does all this go over the next five to 10 years if things work out?
John Elling:In five to 10 years, most of the major fusion development efforts will have achieved generating neutrons. So everybody now is building. The ones that are building are building their first of a kind. So Commonwealth Fusion Systems is building arc in Massachusetts and, and Type One Energy is in Virginia building their first prototypes. And these are, these are the first prototypes. It's, it's how can they get their physics of squeezing these atoms together demonstrated, learn how to use them, that kind of a thing. And the next five to 10 years, we're going to see half a dozen to a dozen of those efforts actually generate neutrons. And that's gonna be where the rubber meets the road in down selecting which technology is going to be the winner in fusion. Because you're going to have to not only achieve the pressures necessary, but you're gonna have to do it in a way that's a device that could be produced commercially and scaled up. And in five to 10 years they're going to be building, their second of a kind. They're full scale prototypes. So I would say that we're gonna go from 60 fusion efforts down to 12. And it will be a technical sort whose squeezy technology works. And some of the ideas are fantastic. I'd love to see them work. I, again, back to my roots as a scientist. Bright, shiny, new physics. It's really cool. And some of the down select is gonna be economic who can raise the money to build a prototype fusion reactor. Those things aren't cheap. I mean, I, I just got back from touring the Commonwealth site and I'm a businessman and I've been doing startups for 30 years, and it's jaw dropping how much money they've invested in stainless steel. I mean, the fusion, the Commonwealth alone has raised $3 billion and you can see it, right? It's, it's bright, shiny, stainless steel all over that place. There's just not enough money in the world for 60 companies to raise $3 billion each to build their prototype reactors. So there's going to be a down select economically who can raise the money to move their physics forward. And there'll be a physics down select whose physics works. In the meantime, everybody has a role to play, right? You have to have high temperature superconducting tape to make the magnets that are gonna be used at any, well, in most physics situations. They all have to have lithium, right? Unless you're planning to mine helium three on the moon, which is some physics is actually deuterium helium three. And that's great. I mean, they wouldn't need lithium, which would be tragic for me. They're gonna go get their fuel by, mining helium three off the moon. I'd be happy to have that business model too, as long as I get to come back from the moon. But they'll, there'll be a down select. And all of the technology that's now being diffused into 60 efforts will be consolidated as well because it's, it's all enabling. So they're not wasting their money. There'll be mergers and technology acquisitions along the way.
Tom Raftery:And after listening to this conversation, what should people hear differently when a company says, advanced nuclear is nearly ready?
John Elling:Well, advanced nuclear fission is nearly ready. You've got companies, in fact, there's two companies, Kairos Atomics down in Albuquerque, just south of me, and Copenhagen Atomics naturally in Denmark. They're moving so fast that they decided they needed to enrich their own lithium seven because they're in a hurry to generate neutrons and they are generating neutrons this year, both of them. So if somebody hears that, what they should be really hearing is really, it's happening this time, right? I mean, this is, this is, for the last time it's five years away. You have companies who are standing up prototypes who are generating neutrons. A lot of it is technology that was developed in the sixties by the federal government that's being taken, that had a mothball is dusted up, modernised. It's going to happen, and the business model supports it. The public perception supports it. The drive for economic security and energy security supports it. Everything is now aligning on advanced nuclear. And fusion is real, right? We, we've now seen unambiguously that you can get more energy out than you put in. And now it's a question of, not will it work, but how can you make it work to, at the end of the day, as an entrepreneur, how can you make it, make money?
Tom Raftery:There's a distinction I think matters here. A fusion experiment producing a promising energy result is not the same as a power plant delivering dependable electricity at a competitive cost. That's still a significant engineering and commercial hurdle. Mm. Okay. And a left field. Question for you, John. If you could have any person or character, alive or dead, real or fictional as a champion for the hidden supply chains behind advanced nuclear, who would it be and why?
John Elling:So I love the question. I'm a private pilot for fun, and Kelly Johnson is a hero in aviation. He's the fellow that ran the Lockheed Skunk works that designed the SR 71 Blackbird, the ultra secret spy plane that we, we needed back in the Cold War. And your question was secret supply chain. And there's a great story about the Blackbird is, when they designed it they knew it was gonna be moving so fast that even at the cruise altitudes, the skin of that aeroplane was gonna be 900 degrees Celsius. And there's just, how do you build an aeroplane that doesn't melt? So the, the answer was you make the skin of the aeroplane out of titanium. Alright, well now there's a supply chain problem because the only titanium mines in the world were in Russia in the Soviet Union. So we needed titanium to build a spy plane from Russia so that we could go spy on Russia. So they created this entire mock industry of nuts and bolts and, and titanium parts in the United States. And they bought a whole bunch of all, all of these CIA controlled companies, went out and bought all of this titanium from Russia to make these nuts and bolts, even made the nuts and bolts out of titanium, shipped the titanium parts from Russia to the United States where they promptly melted it all down and put it into the skins of the aeroplanes And it was just a, a complete subterfuge. There was no titanium civilian industry. It was just an artifice to get the titanium out of Russia so that we could build planes that would go back and fly over Russia.
Tom Raftery:Wow.
John Elling:but it was really an example. And, but now of course you can buy titanium nuts and bolts for your parts that are nice, lightweight and high heat resistant. So, so they created deliberately a domestic supply chain that they could leverage with this huge subterfuge of, building the SR 71s. And that I think is, I, I don't think we should do it with the subterfuge, but that I think is, is really where we need to be in the government right now, is to say, we really need to create a dual use supply chain in fusion so that we can use this high energy physics that the government mastered a long time ago. We invented fusion over in, Los Alamos across the, river from me. That expertise needs to diffuse out into the commercial sector and the supply chains need to diffuse out into the commercial sector because that's the limitation. There weren't very many people in the world that knew how to do fusion and we watched them very carefully. What a great legacy for the nuclear weapons complex to take this physics that they figured out as weapons and turn it into, the ultimate final power source for mankind. And they don't even have to steal it from the Russians.
Tom Raftery:John, we're coming towards the end of the podcast now. Is there any question that I didn't ask that you wish I did or aspect of this we haven't covered that you think it's important for people to be aware of?
John Elling:No, I think you, you very well covered it. I think the, the take home point is there's incredibly exciting things going on in the physics of advanced nuclear in the physics of fusion, but none of this will ever get in to the grid. None of it will ever do any good unless there's a supply chain so that they can take their really cool new physics tricks and build power plants. And the supply chains have to have unique materials that haven't been produced at commercial scale before. Lithium is one of them. There's plenty of others. These are the picks and shovels of the gold rush. And not only are they a great business model, but they have to be there. You can't do these things. You can't reduce these great shiny new science tricks to generating power to run your toaster and turn on your lights unless you have this supply chain in place in time to make this happen.
Tom Raftery:Sure, John, that's been fascinating. If people would like to know more about yourself or any of the things we discussed on the podcast today, where would you have me direct them?
John Elling:Our website. Info at Molten Salt Solutions Elling at Molten Salt Solutions. It's kind of, kind of hard to ignore me, actually. I'm on podcasts, I go to conference talks. Better question is, how can they get rid of me? But yeah, finding me on social media should be fairly easy. And I love to talk. I mean, I'm very excited about just the, the whole transition in humankind all the way down to what my company is doing. I, I really love it.
Tom Raftery:Fantastic. John, that's been great. Thanks a million for coming in the podcast today.
John Elling:Thank you so much.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Buzzcast
Buzzsprout
Wicked Problems - Climate Tech Conversations
Richard DelevanClimate Connections
Yale Center for Environmental Communication
The Climate Pod
The Climate Pod
Climate Action Show
Climate Action Collective
The Climate Question
BBC World Service
Energy Gang
Wood Mackenzie
Climate Positive
HASI
Climate One
Climate One from The Commonwealth Club