Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Climate Confident is for business leaders, climate professionals and policymakers who need to understand what is actually cutting emissions—and what it takes to make those solutions work at scale.
Each Wednesday, technology and sustainability analyst, keynote speaker and former SAP Global VP Tom Raftery speaks with the executives, engineers, scientists, founders and policymakers turning climate ambition into measurable progress. Together, they examine the technologies, business models, policies and implementation strategies reshaping energy, transport, industry, supply chains, food and finance.
These are not conversations about distant targets, vague pledges or greenwash. They are candid discussions about what is working, what is failing, where the real bottlenecks lie, and how leaders can make better decisions about decarbonisation, resilience, investment and risk.
You will hear:
Proven approaches to reducing emissions
Hard-earned lessons from real-world implementation
Analysis of the markets, technologies and policies driving the transition
Honest examination of costs, trade-offs, setbacks and unintended consequences
Practical ideas for turning climate commitments into action
New episodes are published every Wednesday at 7am CET. Subscribers also receive bonus episodes featuring highlights, analysis and emerging themes from across the series.
Follow Climate Confident for practical climate solutions, informed debate and the insights you need to turn ambition into measurable progress.
The investment community has enormous influence on global markets (by directing capital flows) and the climate emissions space is by no means immune to this.
I invited J.P. Morgan's Head of EMEA ESG Debt Capital Markets Paul O'Connor to come on the podcast to talk about how this works.
I know next to nothing about finance as you can probably tell from the questions I was asking, but Paul was excellent, and explained it all extremely well, so even I could understand, and I learned loads.
As you can probably tell, I thoroughly enjoyed our conversation. I hope you enjoy listening to it too.
If you have any comments/suggestions or questions for the podcast - feel free to leave me a voice message over on my SpeakPipe page, head on over to the Climate 21 Podcast Forum, or just send it to me as a direct message on Twitter/LinkedIn. Audio messages will get played (unless you specifically ask me not to).
Podcast subscribers I'd like to sincerely thank this podcast's amazing subscribers:
Anita Krajnc
Cecilia Skarupa
Ben Gross
Jerry Sweeney
Andreas Werner
Stephen Carroll
Roger Arnold
And remember you too can Subscribe to the Podcast - it is really easy and hugely important as it will enable me to continue to create more excellent Climate Confident episodes like this one, as well as give you access to the entire back catalog of Climate Confident episodes.
🎤 Looking for a keynote speaker on climate, energy, AI, or sustainability?
I help executive audiences understand the technologies, trends, and decisions shaping the low-carbon transition.
Download my Speaker Pack: https://tinyurl.com/spkrpck
And a quick note before you go: I’ve started a new Reddit community for serious, evidence-led discussion on climate solutions, clean energy, decarbonisation, policy, technology, and what actually works in practice.
If you’d like to suggest future guests, challenge ideas from the show, or share climate reports and solutions worth discussing, join us at r/ClimateConfident
Paul O'Connor:
You know, using those science based targets, you can calculate back and sort of interpolate a trajectory to get to those points and within that you can see which company is on the right pathway. And that is very helpful for investors because it allows them to allocate capital preferentially, a, they can allocate capital away from sectors that are very carbon intensive. And B, in the event that they need to maintain a diversified portfolio, they can pick the operators within those sectors that are changing their business models at the right at the right pace.
Tom Raftery:
Good morning. Good afternoon or good evening wherever you are in the world. This is the Climate 21 podcast, the number one podcast showcasing best practises in climate emissions reductions. And I'm your host. Global vice president at SAP, Tom Raftery. Climate 21 is the name of an initiative by SAP to allow our customers calculate, report and reduce their greenhouse gas emissions. In this Climate 21 podcast, I showcase best practises and thought leadership by SAP, by our customers, by our partners and by our competitors if they're game in climate emissions reductions. Don't forget to subscribe to this podcast in your podcast app of Choice to be sure you don't miss any episodes. Hi, everyone, welcome to the Climate 21 podcast, my special guest on the show today is Paul. Paul, would you like to introduce yourself?
Paul O'Connor:
Sure, yeah. Hi, it's Paul O'Connor speaking. I look after ESG debt, capital markets, at JP Morgan. I cover the EMEA region. My background is on the environmental science and engineering side. I was in management consulting for around 10 years. I worked at the European Commission in the ozone protection team and I joined JP Morgan in 2012 originally and a risk role looking at how JPMorgan as an institution was approaching the sort of ESG agenda. And effectively, over the last few years, I've just taken that ESG skill set and started deploying it in the debt capital market space. So I spend all my time now helping our clients understand ESG issues that are relevant to their industry sector, help them understand how investors are thinking about ESG. We've obviously seen an explosion in the the volume of capital that is being allocated to addressing ESG challenges. And so the idea is to help our clients create financing instruments that they can use to engage that investor interest in allocating capital on an ESG basis. So that's the day job. Thank you for inviting me and look forward to the discussion.
Tom Raftery:
Yeah, great. Before we start, for anyone who is unaware, could you just expand a little bit about what ESG stands for?
Paul O'Connor:
Sure. So ESG stands for environmental social governance. It's a shorthand, really, which provides a kind of an umbrella term to cover those issues that are not typically or haven't traditionally been covered in company financial accounts. So all the elements and aspects of a company's operations that aren't captured by traditional financial data, they tend to be put under this sort of ESG umbrella term. And it's really a way of communicating the fact that companies have much broader impacts in society and on the environment other than what has been reported traditionally in financial accounts. And it's a way of looking at those issues. It's a shorthand and a kind of a common terminology to look at issues like global carbon emissions, impact on water, emissions to air, social issues like worker health and safety, labour rights, human rights, governance arrangements. You know how the company is managed ya know, dealing with shareholders and other stakeholders. All of these things we need a kind of a common language to talk about them. And so ESG is the term that has started to be used. ES and G typically don't have much to do with each other and that does cause some problems which we can we can get into. But at the moment, most people working in this space that use ESG is a sort of a shorthand. You will hear the term sustainability used interchangeably in a lot of cases, and that's that's a term that others use. But ultimately, we're talking about the same things. We're talking about the broader impact of business models on society.
Tom Raftery:
OK, OK. Obviously, this being the Climate 21 podcast. We're more concerned with climate emissions than anything else. But you mentioned there was an explosion of interest by investors in this space recently. Can you talk a little bit about why that is?
Paul O'Connor:
Sure. So there's a couple of things in play here, really. It's the asset owners that are sort of driving the bus, if you will. So asset owner preference, now, the asset owners, I guess, is a term we can use for the people who actually own the money. So it's pension funds, pension fund trustees who manage pension funds on behalf of beneficiaries. It could be high net worth individuals. Anyone who is storing capital, they typically are changing their views into how they would like that capital to be managed. They are increasingly sensitised to the fact that some of the business models out there are just not sustainable over the long term. You know, there are ESG related challenges which would make those business models less competitive and for various moral and ethical reasons, a lot of asset owners want the money to be out there doing things which are useful and helpful to society, ideally, or at the very least, not causing adverse impacts on society to the extent possible. So the asset owners have started developing these views. They're not just looking at returns anymore. They're looking at a longer term time horizon and looking at the longer term resilience of the business models that underpin their investments. And they are starting to express their preference through the asset manager relationships that they have. So a lot of asset owners will appoint professional asset managers to effectively run their money. And in order to be a successful asset manager these days and to continue to gather money to manage, you now need to show those asset owners that you can. Assets on an ESG basis, as well as generating returns, you know, as well as giving the the asset on or what they want in terms of conventional investment considerations, the asset managers also need to show that they can respond to this asset owner preference, and that is driving a real competition within the asset management industry. So if you are looking to gather funds to manage, you now have to show that you are an effective ESG manager as well. So that competitive pressure is really starting to be felt in the market. But it is originating at the asset owner level. Sovereign wealth funds and people who manage money on behalf of taxpayers and governments are also thinking along these lines. And all of that money is now being pointed in a certain direction. And that is the real impetus behind all of this. Government is starting to provide a tailwind to a certain extent in the European Union we have a very ambitious, sustainable finance platform and a whole raft of measures being taken at European Union level, which are going to provide even more tailwinds to this ESG investing objective, I guess you could call it. So that's that's kind of what's driving it. But there's quite a long way to go. There are still a lot of assets being managed on on a purely conventional basis. And, you know, some of these pools of capital are gradually being woken up to all of this. And that is the process we are seeing playing out in the market at the moment.
Tom Raftery:
OK, and is this interest a flash in the pan or is it for want of a better word, sustainable?
Paul O'Connor:
Yeah, good question. And, you know, we see various fads come and go for various reasons. You know, the reality on this one is that none of the problems are going away. And it's hard to see this changing in the in the short, medium or long term because there's a long way to go before these problems can be actually successfully addressed. And so, you know, the issue then is, you know, how do we make it bigger and how do we start to redeploy this capital effectively? Climate change isn't going away. The effects are really starting to be felt now in a way which makes it hard to argue that it's not happening. You know, most people are starting to accept the reality of these things. And as populations grow and the pressure on the natural resources which, you know, form the kind of support system for society, you know, as the pressure starts to grow and those natural resources, commodities, agriculture, all of these things being adversely affected by ESG related challenges, you know, those problems are just getting worse. And, you know, it's hard to see them getting better in the short term. And so given that dynamic, I think we're going to see more of this. And it's hard to see it abating as a sort of a trend in the market. If anything, I think it's going to increase because what's happening in Europe, you know, is starting to happen in the US and in Asia. And those markets are catching up quickly. And we'll see a lot more of this thinking coming through the market over time.
Tom Raftery:
OK, and how are the asset owners measuring whether or not this is being done? What kind of metrics are they using?
Paul O'Connor:
Yeah, yeah, that's a great question. And actually, that's really challenging, partly because of the sort of highly intermediated nature of the investment industry where you've lots and lots of intermediaries. It makes it quite difficult to gain visibility over, you know, what the users of capital are actually doing. And there there's a long, long I guess it was it was a great distance between the the owners of capital and the sort of the the the users of that capital. And it's very highly intermediated. So getting getting ways to measure what's happening is is difficult. And effectively, what we need to do is shorten that distance between the user of capital and the provider. And there's various different ways of doing that. If we look at some of the models in the investment industry, if we look at the way private equity works, they are typically very close to the companies that they invest in. They often have a seat on the board when they are thinking of acquiring those companies. They are very, very keen on understanding every aspect of how their company works. So they have a lot more visibility of data streams and what might be available. And private equity managers do have that visibility, which they can then pass on to their their own end investors so, the people that invest in the funds that are advised by private equity managers, you know, those private equity managers are often quite close to the companies. It's a bit more difficult if you're an equity investor, you just buy the shares and the stocks of those companies. You have to rely on the company reporting. And that is why there is a lot of pressure on corporates these days to provide more ESG data, better quality ESG data, ESG data that's measured on a consistent basis within industry sectors and on a consistent basis over time and is externally assured. So, in the same way that you would get a financial auditor to sign off on your your your annual report, your accounts, you need some sort of comfort that the data you're reporting in the public domain is is is of high quality, and that is how equity investors get some visibility and how they can start talking to their and clients about impacts because they in theory, once they have that, you know, more useful data stream on ESG coming from companies, they can translate that and aggregate that. And we do see a lot of effort in that area. Fixed income, debt, investors, it's sort of the same. They rely on company accounts. And again, there is pressure there to get companies to report more of this data. And there is a number of industry initiatives. SASB and GRI and some of the accounting firms have been working on this, trying to come up with a better way to ensure that corporate reporting on ESG is more useful. But in theory, that is how investors supply data on ESG impacts to their end users and how they gain visibility over that. But it is very challenging, basically, because there is not much consistency at the moment in how that data is reported, which makes it less useful. And so it's quite difficult to interpret and understand who's doing a good job and who has some way to go in terms of the quality of the data that they're able to access and report.
Tom Raftery:
OK, so that that actually gets to my next question or almost even answers my next question. I was going to say how cross comparable is the data? Are there standards there around reporting that people are adhering to? Are the standards? If there are standards, are they mature enough?
Paul O'Connor:
Yeah, so it's a very mixed picture for some issues like carbon emissions, the data quality is quite good, partly because in some jurisdictions there have been carbon emissions trading schemes, you know, established for a while. So the European Union, we've had one for for quite a number of years now. If you need to report carbon and you're participating in a carbon emissions trading system, you need good quality data. So you have spent the time getting that data to where it needs to be, where it can underpin effectively a financial instrument, a carbon credits for things like carbon. The data tends to be quite good for things like industrial safety. So last time, accidents and injuries, things that companies have been measuring for a long time because it's critical for their own internal performance objectives, that data tends to be in quite good shape as well. There are other areas of of ESG that are just harder to get to grips with, things like emissions to water. How do you measure those emissions to atmosphere other than greenhouse gas emissions? You know, there's a lot of other things there. Also on the social side, supply chain risk management and metrics associated with that. You know, they are more challenging to to measure and report. And so it's a very patchy picture. But there is a lot of effort going on to try to introduce some accounting, effectively accounting standards that would help everybody understand how best to measure and report these things. So it's a little bit like where we were before accounting standards emerged. And now we have us GAAP and we have IFRS and all these internationally recognised accounting standards, you know, which provide a consistent basis for companies to report against, you know, where we're a little bit behind when it comes to ESG. And, you know, for certain types of data, it's just very hard to get good quality information. And part of this is due to challenges within the company. You know, if you're a conglomerate or if you are a company which has a lot of subsidiaries, there is a a challenge around just getting those data streams up and running. So there is there's a long way to go. But I think we are making good progress and we are fairly close on some of the metrics, particularly ones around climate change, which tend to be a focus at the moment. We now have pretty good data for a lot of industry sectors in certain jurisdictions, which allows investors to make a comparison and allows investors to understand on a like for like basis who's doing a better job of decarbonising their business.
Tom Raftery:
OK, and what are you seeing amongst your own client base?
Paul O'Connor:
So, again, it's a spectrum. You know, the region that I spend most of my time in the European Union countries and more and more generally has been working on this agenda for longer than other jurisdictions. To a certain extent, there has been an expectation that companies report on ESG. And so, you know, in a way I have it easy compared to my colleagues that cover other parts of the world where there hasn't been the same level of expectation on ESG reporting. There hasn't been a regulatory expectation, you know, the stock exchanges or the financial regulators or the other markets supervisors haven't been asking for it until, you know, more recently, now it is starting to come. And the fact that European corporates have been doing this for a while, obviously other companies can can look to emulate what they are doing. So it is getting better. And as I say, I'm lucky in a way sitting here because we do have a longer track record of reporting on ESG, which makes things definitely easier, but other jurisdictions are definitely catching up fast.
Tom Raftery:
OK, and can you talk to some examples of what your clients are doing?
Paul O'Connor:
Yeah, sure. So I would say the main challenge at the moment for investors is to understand who is the biggest part of the problem. If we take an example like climate change and carbon emissions, greenhouse gas emissions, you know, we need to understand on a sector basis, you know, which industry sectors are contributing most to the issue. And within those sectors, investors need to understand, you know, who is moving in the right direction at the right pace. With the introduction of the Paris agreement, we have effectively established an opportunity to to see a kind of an end point. And we need to we need to look forward to that end point, at which point the economies need to be sort of carbon neutral and, you know, calculating back. We can see pathways for different industry sectors and we can see whether or not companies within those sectors are on the right trajectory. And so a lot of work and analytics have been done in the more carbon intensive sectors to plot those pathways, the the pathways that are implied by the Paris Agreement on Climate Change, which seeks to limit global warming to a maximum of two degrees and ideally to one point five degrees, you know, using those science based targets, you can calculate back and sort of interpolate a trajectory to get to those points and within that you can see which company is on the right pathway. And that is very helpful for investors because it allows them to allocate capital preferentially, a, they can allocate capital away from sectors that are very carbon intensive. And B, in the event that they need to maintain a diversified portfolio, they can pick the operators within those sectors that are changing their business models at the right at the right pace. So what we call these kind of transition candidates, people who are coming up with new technologies and ways to run their business that don't involve you burning as much fossil fuels. You know, there are a lot of strategies being announced in the market from those sectors which seek to, you know, highlight and demonstrate how the company is going to transition over time to be a lower carbon intensity business model. So if we think of power utilities, they're all well down the track in terms of shifting away from coal and coal fired power into more renewable energy, wind and solar, things of that nature, the oil and gas sector, steel, cement, aluminium, chemicals, these sectors that use a lot of energy, which has historically been supplied by fossil fuels for the most part, you know, transportation, aviation, shipping are also sectors where this is relevant. They are now seeking to use technology to move away from a business model that is reliant on burning fossil fuels to power itself. And all of these announcements are being accompanied with, you know, quantified targets which say, you know, if we think of power utilities, which are probably the most advanced, they say for every unit of electricity that we bring onto the grid, that is being generated at a lower and lower carbon intensity. So you can measure the grams of carbon dioxide per megawatt hour that are being brought onto the grid. And you can compare companies on a like for like basis and you can pick these kind of what you might call a transition play or a net zero play or a low carbon electricity generator story. And the investor has the opportunity then to allocate capital to that company and sort of reflect their investment belief that these are going to be the more successful companies of the future. A, they won't be penalised as much for emitting carbon. And now we have carbon pricing. We have these carbon markets which will penalise over time a bigger emitter of carbon. Those carbon markets are spreading around the globe. So now that we are pricing in carbon, if you are an electricity generator that's emitting less carbon, you suddenly have a competitive advantage over those players that are being punished by this carbon pricing mechanism. So that allows the investor, you know, an opportunity to understand all of this and understand who will be resilient and continue to generate returns over time. And we're already seeing these winners start to play out. You know, we have the concept of the new energy major, which is a company which has managed to shift away from a high carbon intensity business model to one that is based on more renewable energy. And these will likely be the big energy players of the future. And they have huge opportunities in terms of their ability to help other sectors decarbonise. And we've seen some of these industrial partnerships popping up where electricity generators are starting to work with other industry sectors to help them, you know, reduce the carbon intensity of their businesses. So in sectors like steel, you can still use hydrogen instead of burning coal to make steel and blast furnaces. Where are we going to get the hydrogen? The best way to generate the hydrogen, what they call green hydrogen, is to use renewable energy to split water. So this technology has been around for ages. Anyone who has spent in a science time in a science lab might remember doing these experiments where you pass electricity through water and you separate it off into hydrogen and oxygen and the hydrogen can be used as a fuel. And so there's huge opportunity for these renewable electricity generators to use renewable energy, renewable electricity to split water and supply that hydrogen to to industry. Now, there's a long way to go. It's expensive at the moment to do it. But as all these generators really scale and the prices start to come down and the cost of energy starts to come down, you know, this will be likely a meaningful kind of technology option for these carbon intensive industries to to start to transition their business models.
Tom Raftery:
Interesting. Interesting. I heard you in that last answer. Use the word opportunity three or four times, which is great. It sounds like that this problem is now switching from being a problem to being an opportunity, which, of course, is huge, because it means if it becomes financially.
Paul O'Connor:
Attractive,.
Tom Raftery:
Attractive. Yeah, exactly. If it becomes financially attractive to be sustainable, to emit less, then, you know, then it's going to happen.
Paul O'Connor:
Yeah. Yeah. No, absolutely. And that's that is the Holy Grail really is to make this, you know, attractive from a core investment consideration point of view. You know, in the old days of ESG investing, it was typically perceived as well. I can't invest in certain companies. I have to constrain my funds. I have to reduce my diversification and I'm going to lose out. And investors were very worried about missing what they call their benchmark, which is basically how they get compared to other managers, you know, in terms of their investment outcomes. So I think we're well beyond that. And the more sophisticated investors we see operating in the ESG spaces are entirely thinking about this in terms of opportunity. You know, some of this stuff is is really what they call early stage investing. I mean, it's kind of venture capital or equity type investments. You know, it is feeding through, into the debt space as these technologies mature. Renewables is a great example. I mean, that is a mature technology. Yeah, certainly onshore wind. Certainly solar. Again, we're pushing the boundaries where we're going into offshore wind. We're going into more exotic forms of solar power. And again, there's a technology and a construction risk issue there. And so we have a different type of investor in the early stage. But those investors that have been involved with those successful technologies have made good returns. You know, we we did in the early stages of the renewables market. You know, we did have a situation where we were relying on government support and subsidies. You know, in a lot of cases, that picture has changed dramatically. You know, the technology has got much cheaper. And, you know, there is good money to be made in investing in in these technologies. It's very hard to pick the right winner, you know, and it is still easy. It's not for everybody. And all of these technologies have challenges. And, you know, at certain points in the in the kind of maturity journey, they will become more attractive to different types of investors where they can show that they can generate, you know, stable returns over time. Then they become more of a sort of a debt investor play. But absolutely, I think everyone in the market has recognised, you know, we have moved a long way from the days where we thought ESG was a, you know, a dampener on on returns. And it is now being seen as a huge opportunity. And for companies that can get this right, you know, there's huge opportunities there. And for the the investors that backed them, you know, there's also huge opportunities there.
Tom Raftery:
Tremendous, tremendous shifting gears as we start to wind down the podcast. Are you when you think about all these things and when you think about where we are in terms of climate change and the future of the planet, are you optimistic?
Paul O'Connor:
I am optimistic. I mean, technology has a huge role to play in this and the ability that, you know, investors have to work with industry partners and invest in companies to scale things quickly is incredible to see. So if you look at what's happened in China in terms of the renewable energy industry that they've built, they're in a very, very short period of time. You know, that is a cause for optimism. I mean, it's a bit of a dampener that we still have a lot of the, you know, the fundamental problems around how we use resources. And, you know, the that the sort of what I call the linear economy, where we put raw materials and energy in one end of the pipe and we spit waste out the other, you know, we need to create more circularity. And that's going to be a challenge. I mean, I think we will solve a lot of these problems, but maybe a little bit too late to avoid some of these negative externalities. So we are definitely going to see that. We are already seeing that. So we're going to have to start living with a new normal to a certain extent. But it's sadly, you know, a part of human nature that we don't believe the risk until it's actually right in front of us and is undeniable. And, you know, a lot of the actors in the economy and in society more generally are just not incentivised to change it for various reasons. Some of it is generational, and that's a perfectly economically rational position for them to take. Unfortunately, it has negative connotations for future generations. But if you're somebody who's not too worried about that, then you're not really motivated to do things in a different way. And that's fundamentally, fundamentally part of the problem. The tragedy of the horizons is I think Mark Carney referred to it as so we'll continue to wrestle with that. But I'm a big optimist in terms of technology and ability to kind of put technology together with capital and make that scale and the ability to scale it with, you know, a supportive government or policy environment. You know, things can scale very, very quickly. And that is really encouraging.
Tom Raftery:
OK, super, super. OK, second last question of the of the podcast. Is there anything I haven't asked you that you kind of wish I had or is there any topic we've not touched on that you think it's important that people be aware of?
Paul O'Connor:
One thing that I'd like to see more attention given to is the concept of, you know, payments for what we used to call payments for ecosystem services. And again, this goes back to the industrial partnerships idea. So if we look at the forest FPP, what they call forest paper and pulp, that sector I think has got big opportunities to play. And some of these industrial partnerships, you know, to position themselves as almost like a waste manager. So if you're a growing trees for the wood content, I think you can also grow trees and present them as a carbon storage unit. And so you can work with partners, you know, people who are industrial emitters of carbon who need somebody to take that waste away effectively rather than going up into the into the air. You know, I think there are some opportunities for industry sectors that historically have had very little interaction and very little to do with each other to start working together because they are holding a piece of the jigsaw and putting those pieces of the jigsaw together could be very powerful. And so I think some of those payments for ecosystem services models where we effectively, you know, it's almost like a fee for waste management, you know, that goes straight into, you know, growing forest for conservation purposes, you know, long term storage of carbon. You know, these types of opportunities, I think could be really interesting and really powerful.
Tom Raftery:
Superb, superb, superb. OK, last question, Paul. If people want to know more about yourself or about JPMorgan or about any of the things we've discussed on the podcast today, where would you have me direct them?
Paul O'Connor:
So I'm on LinkedIn, so just feel free to to reach out and, you know, we can be in touch. So always happy to to talk to people with shared interests and, you know, look forward to continuing the debate.
Tom Raftery:
Super, super. Paul, that's been great, Thanks a million for coming on the show today.
Paul O'Connor:
Thanks very much, Tom.
Tom Raftery:
OK, we've come to the end of the show. Thanks, everyone, for listening. If you'd like to know more about Climate 21, feel free to drop me an email to Tom Dot Raftery at SAP dot com or connect with me on LinkedIn or Twitter. If you like the show, please don't forget to subscribe to it. And your podcast application of choice to get new episodes as soon as they're published. Also, please don't forget to rate and review the podcast. It really does help new people to find a show. Thanks. I'll catch you all next time.