Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Climate Confident is for business leaders, climate professionals and policymakers who need to understand what is actually cutting emissions—and what it takes to make those solutions work at scale.
Each Wednesday, technology and sustainability analyst, keynote speaker and former SAP Global VP Tom Raftery speaks with the executives, engineers, scientists, founders and policymakers turning climate ambition into measurable progress. Together, they examine the technologies, business models, policies and implementation strategies reshaping energy, transport, industry, supply chains, food and finance.
These are not conversations about distant targets, vague pledges or greenwash. They are candid discussions about what is working, what is failing, where the real bottlenecks lie, and how leaders can make better decisions about decarbonisation, resilience, investment and risk.
You will hear:
- Proven approaches to reducing emissions
- Hard-earned lessons from real-world implementation
- Analysis of the markets, technologies and policies driving the transition
- Honest examination of costs, trade-offs, setbacks and unintended consequences
- Practical ideas for turning climate commitments into action
New episodes are published every Wednesday at 7am CET. Subscribers also receive bonus episodes featuring highlights, analysis and emerging themes from across the series.
Follow Climate Confident for practical climate solutions, informed debate and the insights you need to turn ambition into measurable progress.
Guest suggestions and feedback are welcome at Tom@tomraftery.com.
Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Climate, geopolitics, and supply chain risk - a chat with Jacob Shapiro
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Get in touch - leave me a message
So much of what's happening in the climate space revolves around geopolitics that I thought it might be interesting to bring an expert in to talk about that.
So, I invited Jacob Shapiro to come on the podcast to talk about these issues. Jacob is the Founder and Chief Strategist at Perch Perspectives, as well as the host of the Perch Pod podcast.
As we covered the supply chain risk implications of geopolitics in the podcast, I published a lightly edited version of this conversation (less climate info, more supply chain data) on the Digital Supply Chain podcast.
But we covered off its of other climate related topics in this chat too.
As you can probably tell, I thoroughly enjoyed our conversation. I hope you enjoy listening to it too.
If you have any comments/suggestions or questions for the podcast - feel free to leave me a voice message over on my SpeakPipe page, head on over to the Climate 21 Podcast Forum, or just send it to me as a direct message on Twitter/LinkedIn. Audio messages will get played (unless you specifically ask me not to).
And if you want to know more about any of SAP's Sustainability solutions, head on over to www.sap.com/sustainability and if you liked this show, please don't forget to rate and/or review it. It makes a big difference to help new people discover the show. Thanks.
And remember, stay healthy, stay safe, stay sane!
Music credit - Intro and Outro music for this podcast was composed, played and produced by my daughter Luna Juniper
Sign up to Climate Confident+ for deep dive analysis of the major climate and energy stories of the day.
Podcast subscribers
I'd like to sincerely thank this podcast's amazing subscribers:
- Anita Krajnc
- Cecilia Skarupa
- Ben Gross
- Jerry Sweeney
- Andreas Werner
- Stephen Carroll
- Roger Arnold
And remember you too can Subscribe to the Podcast - it is really easy and hugely important as it will enable me to continue to create more excellent Climate Confident episodes like this one, as well as give you access to the entire back catalog of Climate Confident episodes.
🎤 Looking for a keynote speaker on climate, energy, AI, or sustainability?
I help executive audiences understand the technologies, trends, and decisions shaping the low-carbon transition.
Download my Speaker Pack: https://tinyurl.com/spkrpck
And a quick note before you go: I’ve started a new Reddit community for serious, evidence-led discussion on climate solutions, clean energy, decarbonisation, policy, technology, and what actually works in practice.
If you’d like to suggest future guests, challenge ideas from the show, or share climate reports and solutions worth discussing, join us at r/ClimateConfident
Wouldn't that be great if the US and China could say, you know what, we disagree on all these different things, but we agree that we're not even going to be around to fight each other if the climate sucks. So let's focus on fixing the climate together and then we'll fight around the edges. That would be great. That would be a that would be the sort of geopolitical step forward that would validate that thesis that we can use this to unify rather than to divide and compete.
SPEAKER_00Climate 21 is the name of an initiative by SAP to allow our customers calculate, report, and reduce their greenhouse gas emissions. In this Climate 21 podcast, I will showcase best practices in thought leadership by SAP, by our customers, by our partners, and by our competitors if they're game in climate emissions reductions. Don't forget to subscribe to this podcast in your podcast app of choice to be sure you don't miss any episodes. Hi everyone, welcome to the digital supply chain and Climate 21 podcast. Yes, you heard that right. It is today we are for a change combining podcasts. We're doing a twofer. My special guest on the show today is Jacob. He will introduce himself in a second. But the reason we're having a twofer, the reason we're having the two podcasts in one is because Jacob, from perch perspectives, uh is a I I well, I'll let I'll let him introduce himself because uh there's too big a chance I'll mess it up. But we're gonna be talking about something that's relevant to both the Climate 21 podcast and to supply chain. Intrigued? Well, Jacob, introduce yourself and we'll uh the the the the reasons why it would become more obvious, I hope.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I hope I live up to it. So hello listeners again. I'm Jacob Shapiro, um founder and chief strategist of Perch Perspectives. We're a human-centric geopolitical, business, and political consulting firm. Um and there's a lot of mumbo jumbo words there, but the way I the way I have to approach climate change when I'm dealing with clients and thinking about geopolitics is tied directly to supply chains. Um so it's actually a good chance to do a crossover episode because the first thing I'm thinking about when I think about, let's say, renewable energy is about well, where are you getting the metals and the minerals that go into the production of green technologies? So we're looking at cobalt in the in the DRC. We're looking at lithium in places like Chile and Argentina. Uh, we're looking at having to process all those things in China, and then China having to push those things out all over the world. That's, you know, from the highest, from the highest level, abstract level point of view, that's what that supply chain looks like. And I feel like a lot of times when we're talking about climate change, when we're talking about renewable energy initiatives, um, there's a tendency to forget that all of the things we're talking about are built on a globalized supply chain that really wasn't fit for this post-COVID world. And we're gonna have to deal with that and we're gonna have to unravel that. And the second point I would make is just that um, you know, I we call ourselves a human-centric consulting firm because I think humans actually get lost when it comes to this space quite a bit. Uh, and I feel that that's happening with climate change in some ways too. Like, yes, it's important to focus on carbon emissions, and yes, it's important to focus on sustainability. Um, but I think the people who who get shortchanged are the actual humans on the other sides of these supply chains, the folks who have to um find new jobs because their industries are going away because of sustainability concerns, the folks who are subject to a climate disaster and can't afford to rebuild their homes and do all other sorts of things. And so a lot of what I'm doing is trying to figure out the geography of climate change and how those things affect each other. And then how does it affect humans? And helping helping companies understand that it's not just about putting a number on carbon and meeting a quota. It's about are you creating better outcomes for human communities, for the people who are actually most affected by that stuff? Because that's the only way you're going to get the feedback loop and the momentum to create real systemic change, which is what we're talking about when we're talking about dealing with climate. It's it's more than a company, it's more than a government. It has to be all of us pushing in the same direction.
SPEAKER_00Interesting. Yeah, you make some very valid points. Um I I will push back on some of them as you you might expect me to. Great, let's do it. So uh your point about the supply chain for renewables is well made. Uh, sure. Things like the solar panels, yeah, they source minerals or maybe for the motors in the um wind turbines or the gearboxes, I should say, in the wind turbines, they source parts from maybe Africa, ship them to China, manufacture them in China, ship them to the Europe or the US or wherever where they're deployed. Uh but that's the same for cars, that's the same for phones, that's the same for pretty much everything that that's that's manufactured these days. The fact that it's renewables doesn't make it any more uh any different to anything else, I would say, in the first place. The the second main point you had, uh the human side of it is is very well made as well, and it's very true that there are a lot of jobs lost uh in the fossil fuel industry, and there will be a lot more uh coal mining, all that kind of thing. The even uh refineries are shutting down. Uh and you know, at a macro level, this is a good thing, but for the workers in those places, you know, not so much. Um, and that's a that's a that's a tough one to kind of square, I guess, particularly, you know, if you are that coal miner or that oil refinery worker. Uh but going back out to the macro side again, when you listen to some of Biden's pronouncements around the things that he's going to do or the Green New Deal here in Europe, the amount of jobs that's going to create, even just one of Biden's uh pronouncements, was that the federal fleet, which is I think 640,000 vehicles, they're going to all be made electric. Uh, and they are going to be made electric with vehicles manufactured in America. And it even goes so far as to say the percentage of components within those vehicles, I forget how much, but it's like 50 or 60% of the components in the vehicles have to also have been manufactured in America. So, and that's just one of the pronouncements. Never mind the the, you know, the massive upscaling in wind turbines and solar panels and all the associated jobs in transmission and distribution that go along with that. Uh, batteries as well. There's uh several big rollouts of batteries in New York and California and other places as well. Uh again, those are US-specific ones, but there are lots of ones like that happening in Australia, here in Europe. So, you know, uh, yes, some jobs are being lost, but many, many more are being created. So the net job numbers go up as a consequence of this significantly. Uh, and they're using yeah, components which, you know, come from different places and are manufactured in other places, and that's kind of how modern manufacturing works.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and uh the the fact that we have to rotate back and forth between the macro and micro, even in this conversation, I think shines a light on the real difficulty of of how to deal with these sort of things. And I guess the, I mean, humans are always on the top of my mind because of what we do at Perch, but it's also particularly on the top of my mind because I'm doing research on a book about New Orleans right now. I live in New Orleans. I was um had to attend a family's a family member's funeral um earlier or last week or the week before. I'm sorry. Um in Raceland. Uh it's okay, but um, but uh in Raceland, Louisiana. I hadn't driven down there before, it's on the coast. And you can just see towns dying literally, and nobody's helping them. Um, you know, the the government's not there. They have no one to appeal to to help them retrain them wherever they want. They've been there for over a hundred years. They don't want to move, their homes are there. I I agree with you with the utilitarian argument. If we can get everything going in this direction, the net is actually going to work out and it's gonna be better for all of humanity. But I think we also have to just keep in mind those folks that are on the ground that are experiencing those things. And that gets to one of the bigger points here, too, which is I sort of alluded to this, but this is bigger than any corporation. It's bigger than any one business. We I think we talk about public-private partnership a lot. Um, but this is one place where it's absolutely critical. The whole reason we have government, even if you're a libert libertarian, even if you don't like government involvement, the point of having a government is so that when a problem is too big for any one person or any one company, you can go to the government and get that sort of help. And that's why I think one of the things that especially large corporates can do is use your political influence, uh, create incentive structures, work with the government in order to say these are the things you need to do in order to support these people who are on the ground. Because if you start thinking that way, start thinking systemically rather than just, okay, in my little bubble, I'm gonna do good. And because I did good on my little quota, I feel good about it. That's great. I'm not saying don't do that. You absolutely should do that. I'm just saying if you really want to get ambitious, start thinking about the role that things are happening, even in just your local community. Can you get involved? Can you help create an incentive structure that helps folks, that helps retrain those folks so that the folks who are losing the jobs can actually get where they need to go? And as to the supply chain bit, and this goes back to the macro thing, um, yeah, it's it's no different than any other supply chain. And this is happening across different supply chains all over the world. I guess I would just say two things, and I'm I'm not even disagreeing with you on this, I would just sort of add two things to that. Um, when you go back, you know, ever since the first industrial revolution, most of our really truly consequential global conflicts are about energy. Um, if you want to boil down World War I, World War II, the Cold War, I mean, yes, there was ideological froth, and yes, there was a bunch of geostrategic, all that other stuff is there. But at root, it's about energy. You know, the Germans wanted living space. They had to get to the oil fields in Romania. That the Japanese entered World War II because the US placed an oil embargo and the the Japanese didn't have any oil on the homeland, sort of thing. So energy is driving these things. And when we're talking about dealing with climate change, um, we're talking about changing the way we generate energy. And so we're going from competition over coal and over oil and over natural gas. And it seems to me we're just substituting some of these other things that are also important for creating a sustainable future. So now instead of worrying about maybe oil in Saudi Arabia, we're gonna be worrying about cobalt and the DRC. That doesn't mean we can't create a system that is good. It just means I think we need to be honest with ourselves about we're talking about these similar things. And it's not gonna be everybody's holding hands and singing kumbaya overnight. We're gonna have to drive to some sort of change. And you brought up the Biden plan. This is what's so worrying to me, because yes, Biden's talking about creating manufacturing jobs. The EU has its Green New Deal, China's pledging its thing by, I think by 2060, they want to go to zero carbon. But everybody's competing. There's no cooperation. Um, the US just rejoined Paris, and even if everybody did everything that was in Paris, we would still fall short of what we need to do to deal with climate. And when you and when I talk about, you know, cobalt and the DRC, uh, lithium in Argentina, the geopolitical competition there, you know, supporting rival political factions, building up political influence in those peripheries, that stuff is all happening. You've got mercenaries running around Africa, you've got political instability in Latin America, all those things are happening. So if you go to a future where each country is pledging to do its own thing, um, I mean, I'm I'm gonna be a little uh tongue-in-cheeker, but it's a little bit like Mad Max. Like every country is gonna have their own little castle and they'll dispense the water and dispense the resources out as they want, but there's gonna be no global buy-in. And that's a that's another place where I think corporations can actually play a huge role because governments, especially in a system that is veered away from globalization, especially in a system where there's more fear, more instability, more national security concerns, they're thinking about risk from that point of view. And corporations are the one that the ones that create those global supply chains, that create the, you know, okay, we're gonna harvest this thing from over here and manufacture over here and then send it out to create good global change. So the more that corporations can build trust, can work with their own governments, and then continue to partner with other companies and with other governments, that's the sweet spot. That's where you actually can create momentum and move the needle forward so that those supply chains don't necessarily fall into some kind of global 21st century great game. Um that that's the positive spin, I think. I think the negative is that that's not happening right now. There's a lot of good news out there, there's a lot of amazing technology, but just look at how COVID has has fallen out. We're more competitive with each other and more concerned and afraid of each other than I think we've been since 1991.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um I'm not sure I would agree. Um good.
SPEAKER_01Tell me why. I'm I I would be happy to be wrong about this, please.
SPEAKER_00No, no, no, yeah. Uh yeah, the the I think the COVID thing um will shake out. Maybe it's just the eternal optimist in me, but um every country or region has uh ordered maybe five, maybe ten times the number of vaccines that they actually need. Every uh large countries, you know, large wealthy countries, the OECDs and and countries like that. Uh and several of them, Canada has made a commitment that it will give several hundred million to poorer countries. So there's there is they're they're gonna, you know, vaccinate their own people first, but they have heavily over uh ordered, and they're not alone, the EU has as well. And you know, you know it's we'll do our own people first, but we will also help everyone else that needs it. It's is kind of the the mentality or yeah, the mentality that has has been put forward at least by these by these countries. Uh so yeah, it is us first, and then we'll help everyone else. But I can understand that too.
SPEAKER_01Can I I I I no, I know I just want to say one thing, because I don't I don't disagree with that. Maybe I didn't articulate it well. Because so when I think about COVID, when I describe COVID, it's the first climate change crisis from my point of view. You can go back to early 2000s and read papers on on the National Institutes of Health and other places where they they are predicting an increase of diseases that jump from animals to humans, and there are heat maps of the exact locations where they're gonna be. And there's a heat map where Wuhan is at the center. It's like one of the hot spots that they predict back in like 2005 that there's going to be, because of changing climate, because of warming temperatures, these diseases are gonna start jumping. And because of, you know, population movements, all these other things. So I think of COVID as a climate crisis and that from that point of view. Um, but I think when you're when you're thinking about COVID and the response to it, um you actually have to go back to the um outbreak of African swine fever in China. Now that didn't jump to humans, but it decimated China's pork herd. And the Chinese like to eat a lot of pork. And that all happened right when the US-China trade war with Trump was just raging. Trump was looking for any point of leverage he could, he could, good, he could get going into the midterms and going into 2020 to show that he was tough on China. Um, so what the US did was it used that African swine fever epidemic in China against China and tried to get China to give trade concessions on buying US agricultural products and a lot of other things because they knew that China was quite frankly screwed with how things were going. It's going to take them years to rebuild their pork industry. Why am I talking about that? I'm talking about that because when China first started registering cases in Wuhan of some kind of strange pneumonia, I think that one of the one of the calculations behind being so secretive about it, because they hadn't been secretive about SARS, some of these other things, they had it in their interest to control all these things. But I think one of the reasons there was an initial hesitance to disclose what was going on was because they were worried the U.S. was going to use it against them. It was about fear and insecurity. They had just seen what they thought was a public health issue. And I'm not justifying it. They shouldn't have done that and they caused irreparable damage. I'm just saying that's an example of mistrust and suspicion breeding a crisis. Because if they had just been up front, and if we hadn't made them feel insecure about their thing, and if we had nipped this in the bud back in January in China, well, then we wouldn't be here. And we and you know, once we get to the point that we are now, yes, everybody needs to vaccinate their own countries first. My point is just that if you're in an environment where there is that suspicion and folks aren't working together and they're arguing about the World Health Organization rather than trying to push in the same direction, you've got a major problem. And the the way I know that this is, or the the evidence I say to know that this is a big change is that when the 2008 financial crisis set off, China and the US were working together. Central banks on both sides were calling each other, everybody was coordinating. There was this idea that the global economy needed everybody to cooperate to get on the same page. And that didn't happen with COVID. And if if we behave like that going forward as a world where nations are thinking about climate in that way and are not trusting each other or corporates aren't willing to work with corporates in other countries, you're gonna get more crises like these that could have been could have been nipped in the butt. So it's that's my point about trust and suspicion. It's not that at the point we're at at now that things are bad. I think actually the way that things have gone ever since ever everybody sort of realized what was going on, it's been a lot better. It was in that moment where we could have prevented all this if there wasn't this hostility and fear and suspicion. And I just I see all those elements still there, even even in the US-China relationship. Like look at what what Biden is pushing on, what he's saying about China. Like all that mistrust, mutual, mutual fear is is still there, I think.
SPEAKER_00Okay. I I haven't been following that that closely, uh, I have to say.
SPEAKER_01Um I did see that Biden had a his first phone call with uh Xi Jinping, but if you're Rudy Giuliani, apparently it's Xi Jinming or whatever Rudy tweeted the other day. It's unbelievable.
SPEAKER_00So Biden did have his first call with him this week, I saw uh earlier this week. Um but I didn't I didn't actually click on the link and see how the phone call went. Uh but you'd have to hope that uh the US administration under Biden would at least be more open to talking than it was under the previous administration.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the the best thing about the readout from that call was how boring it was. Um I had gotten used to to White House readouts that you never quite knew what you were gonna get. Was there gonna be a tweet later? Like this time, there's just a readout. He hit all the things that he was supposed to hit. And afterwards, um he, and it was actually I I watched the footage on C-SPAN. Afterwards, he so he said he spoke to Shi for two hours, which is pretty incredible. And afterwards he said, look, if if we don't get our act together, the Chinese are gonna eat our lunch. I'm I'm quoting Biden there right now because he's thinking about what China's doing in general. But I think your point is exactly right. Um, I think that Biden, and if you listen to what Blinken and some of the others in this current US administration are doing, they're trying to phrase, they're trying to push this idea that they're in a competitive relationship with China, not necessarily an adversarial one. Now, yes, there are there are positions where there are going to be concerns, um, semiconductors, Xinjiang, um, Hong Kong, Taiwan, and not in that order. Some of those are more important than others. Africa. I mean, there are going to be areas where it's adversarial, but one, can you return to some kind of stable, reliable form of mutual communication? Can you put down interests that are the same on both sides and push toward them? And can you think in terms of a competitive relationship rather than one between enemies? I think that's what Biden will want. The rubber will meet the road when it comes to U.S. domestic politics, though, because when you, if you look at Pew surveys, if you look at any data on this, um, the electorate distrusts China. It likes having a boogeyman, especially in the context of a pandemic. Everybody's cooped up, everybody wants to blame someone for something. And in the US in particular, China's getting blamed. And Biden has a lot of priorities, especially at the domestic level. And I don't think he's going to stick his neck out to fix US-China relations first. That's why he's taking, what is it, four months, five months to organize a task force, to think through recommendations for how to change US-China relations. Um, I think he's hoping to get the pandemic under control and then to get back to that level with the US and China. Um, I think in the short term, you're right. I think there's actually a lot of basis for some cooperation. But the real challenge is going to be restoring some level of trust. Because if you're in Beijing and you're in Xi Jinping shoes or you're in the shoes of someone in the party, um, you know, you just got four years of Trump and you don't know what's going to happen in 2024, 2028. You have to be prepared for all these sorts of things. You have to be preparing, you have to be preparing for best case scenarios. And that's why they are pushing things like self-reliance and trying to establish their own supply chains and build their own Navy so that they can defend their own supply chains. All that stuff is happening behind the scenes. So, in some ways, I think when it comes to supply chains in general, when it comes to climate change, Biden will be judged by history about whether he could not repair the US China relationship, because I don't think you're going to put Humpty Dumpty back together again, but can he put it on a more constructive footing? Can we be speaking as competitors who are pushing in the same direction rather than zero sum great powers that are fighting for? Scraps in in places like Africa, Latin America, Southeast Asia.
SPEAKER_00You did say that you think that the COVID crisis is the first real climate-related crisis. I would challenge you on that as well, though, because I mean, sure, we've had lots of weather-related disasters which are directly attributable or almost directly attributable to climate or climate would have played a big part in them. But I would say that things like the uh civil war in Syria, which is, you know, a crisis, uh, I would say that's pretty directly attributable to climate as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I I should take out the first. You're 100% right. Um, and for those who don't know, I mean, Syria, ISIS, the whole all the stuff that's happened in the Middle East goes back to really a historical level drought in Syria in 2007, 2008. That nobody at the time, myself included, who was focusing on the Middle East at the time, nobody kind of watched it. And then we had the Arab Spring, but the Arab Spring really covered up what was going on there. Remember why the Arab Spring started. It was because a Tunisian vegetable salesman couldn't get the price he wanted at the market or was getting insulted by the policeman at the market. Um, all this goes back to food and climate change and all these other sorts of things. So, yes, I shouldn't have said first, it's yeah, that too. I I yeah, I but I shouldn't have said first, but I I I think that um I shouldn't have said first. What I really meant is when I think about COVID, I think about it as a climate change story, not just as a public health issue, not just as, you know, some kind of random event that could have like, no, like this we're gonna see more diseases that jump from you know animals to human beings because climate, you know, bacteria, viruses, these are also things that are affected by climate. All that stuff is gonna happen.
SPEAKER_00So it's it's bizarre how interrelated this stuff is. Uh, I remember reading a report as well about the um the protests in Iran uh around the time of the Arab Spring and a lot of that being related to the price of chicken.
SPEAKER_01Well, no, but I mean that's that's what I mean about focusing on humans, though. Like it's nice to think about a lot of these other highfalutin things and thinking about future-proofing our supply chains, but a lot of what's going to affect your macro environment uh is how do Indian farmers feel that the Modi government is responding to their concerns because they're trying to sell their wares if you're looking at what's going on in India. Um it different Mexican states are competing with each other over water resources because the Mexico and the United States have differing agreements on water and these sorts of things. Um, the example that you gave is another one. So all those issues are really, really important. People need to be able to buy bread. People need to be able to feed, feed their families, they need to be able to do all the things that they want to do, and climate change gets wrapped up in all that, whether it's a disaster that, you know, destroys homes, or whether you're losing your job, or whether the price of your food is going up because you can't, and food prices are skyrocketing right now. They're the highest since they were in 2014, in part because of, again, more protectionism and export restrictions and things that are happening in food supply chains. So it's all part of the story. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I've been reading a lot as well about uh the price of containers uh has skyrocketed. It used to be that a container from China to the US cost something like $2,000 and now it's approaching $10,000. And a lot of that is because of I I I I think I read it because of, at least in part, because of the imbalance in trade, so that there's a huge number of uh containers that are arriving in America full and then going back empty. Because, you know, the in in China they're trying to ship stuff, but they don't have the containers. Uh all the containers are empty in ports in the US because they've just delivered a load of stuff there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I was I was looking just the other day. Um I think it was the Pacific, I forget what it's called. It's one of those Pacific maritime associations or whatever that does reports on on traffic at ports. And yes, the price of containers is skyrocketing. If you look at um the the number of ships that are experiencing greater than five-day wait times, it's up past 25%. It averaged around two to three percent sort of before. Not even in the first couple months of COVID, it was averaging sort of that. So yeah, containers, um, we could talk about the the huge spike in LNG prices earlier this year because of overly cold winters in Asia that was driving this, you know, LNG producers have been dealing with low prices and gluts of supply for a while now, and then suddenly uh that they were making hay all over the place because of lower temperatures in Japan and Taiwan and South Korea and things like that. So all those kinks in the supply chains are there. I think some of that stuff is gonna go away when it once COVID-19 resolves itself. Um, whether that's a year from now, three years, three years from now, who knows? But again, it it goes to your it goes to the point that we're talking about here in the intersection of supply chains with climate. Um, you know, nobody knew there was gonna be an overly cold uh winter in Japan and and South Korea, Taiwan. And you're right I I read this stuff for a living. Nobody was, yeah, and nobody was nobody was predicting a huge spike in LNG prices uh in January and February, literally no one, myself included. I wish I had called it. I would, you know, be it'd be my version of GameStop if I could, right? But that that's the nature of climate. Like you have to future proof yourself against risks that you weren't expecting. And you have to think as much as you can about, well, what could go wrong and try and and at least um limit your exposure to the things that are gonna most um affect your business. Or in the case of like like with these LNG things or container things, um, jump on the opportunity. If you have a container shipping company or you were shipping LNG to Asia, you you had a really, really good two months because you were able to jump on the opportunity. So it's not just about future-proofing against risk, but making sure you can jump in when the opportunity presents itself.
SPEAKER_00That kind of brings us back nicely, I think, because if we if we think about the energy space, uh one of the things that we have seen over the last number of decades is the volatility in the price of hydrocarbons uh has a massive impact on global trade. However, with renewables, when you're building out a large wind farm or solar farm, you're typically doing so on the basis of 20, 25, 30-year power purchase agreements, which sets the price of the energy coming from those solar or wind parks for the next 25 to 30 years. It's a guaranteed price. Uh how will that affect the global energy market when A, the energy coming out of these is cheaper than it coming from gas or coal or any other traditional form of fossil fuel, and B, it's not volatile.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think in the short term, it's going to be about changing um sort of the direction of trade. And this is already happening. It started when the US started producing shale. Um, so you know, US and European countries that have been importing a lot of these hydrocarbons are moving towards sustainability or have access to their own resources because of shale, natural gas, and those sorts of things. And so the Asian countries are really importing and African countries as well. And countries like China, like India, where we're having, I think Delhi has it's a second straight week of record fuel prices in Delhi right now, like in history, record fuel prices, um, even with depressed demand, even with the Saudis cutting everything. Um, and then there's also um, you know, coal is still a major factor in a lot of different countries in the world. I was, I mean, South Africa still gets something like 70, 80% of its electricity generation from coal. It's cheap, it's right there. They're they're saying they're not gonna flip for at least two decades. They're gonna they're gonna start trying to and start doing other things, but it's gonna take time. Uh, I think 55% of Indian electricity comes from coal right now. And you're gonna need major um investment in infrastructure in India to move that needle. And based on India's success in building infrastructure in the past 50 years, it's not the greatest track record. They're gonna need help, sort of thing. Um, so I think in the short term, it's a shift in who's gonna be buying, not necessarily a shift in how things work generally. Whether we get the real shift at the systemic level, um, you know, I think you're talking 10, 20 years from now at minimum, and yeah, that's gonna have to change the way energy companies do business. Um, and again, that's gonna be about governments working together with energy companies and trying to figure out the right ways to maximize, because in some cases it's actually makes more sense to use natural gas or to use hydrocarbons than it would be to say, I don't know, um I'm just saying you can imagine a world in which uh you eliminated hydrocarbons, but you didn't necessarily change the trajectory of climate change because you were mining rare earths in a particularly destructive way to the environment or wiping out whole communities or creating emissions because of the way you are mining the things to create the solar farms and the wind farms. So there has to be that kind of partnership in general. But look, this is why this is why the oil companies are so afraid. Um, this is why climate change is about um dealing with entrenched interests. And I'm not, I don't, I'm not blaming anyone here. I don't, I don't think blame game is a is a good thing. The system is built the way it is for a reason. And we're talking about systemic change right now. Um so if you just leave leave it up to the oil companies themselves, they're gonna fight tooth and nail to try and survive. And what you really need there is public-private partnership incentives to make it so that they can come in and use the expertise that they do have to be part of a whole unified solution rather than demonizing any one company or country or industry, everybody working together to try and move forward. Um, it's why, even though I share your eternal optimism, I'm an optimist myself, but it really doing the kind of systemic change necessary to really make a difference here, it's gonna require a lot of different people working together and cooperating together and not necessarily thinking of the bottom line as the most important thing. Like we're we're literally talking about not like since the Industrial Revolution, it's always been about more, create more, harvest more, sell more, find new markets. We need growth, GDP growth rates. When you look at the way economists talk, it's all about growth, growth, growth, growth, growth. Um what we're really talking about, we're talking about conserve, recycle, circular economy, make things, you know, and and that's a different, that's a fundamentally different economic system. And to make that happen, it's gotta be across borders. It's gotta be governments have to get involved and provide support for those who, by no fault of their own, are profiting from the current system. All those things have to work together in tandem. So I rambled a little bit there. And before we got on the podcast, I told you my it's hard sometimes to sum all this up in easy, easy boxes. One of the reasons I founded Perch was because I worked at consulting companies before that just sort of said, eh, climate change, like we have no idea what's really going to happen. So we can't actually give you any advice. So we'll we'll focus on the other stuff. I feel I think this is the stuff you really need to lean into and and have hard conversations about. But it's hard. I mean, the the data that we have, the solutions that we're talking about, the scale of the problems that we're talking about here, they're massive. And I can't pretend to to kind of to make them any less than they actually are.
SPEAKER_00What about the uh new interest there is globally? Uh, you know, witness, for example, the new letter that went out from uh Larry Fink in his annual CEO letter, the new uh focus there is internationally on ESG uh on in the investment community. That should, you would hope, uh, increase. I don't think that's a fad by any means. And uh because it seems to be risk-based, I'm sure it's something that you're keeping an eye on, uh, it seems that the investment community are saying, yeah, no, we don't want to go near anything carbon-intensive anymore because there's a risk there. So, you know, report your ESG, we'll take a look at it. If you do report your ESG, excellent, we'll be more inclined to talk to you. If you're not reporting it, not so much. Uh, and if it's particularly poor, yeah, your chances of you getting any investment or any capital are lower and the capital you get will be more expensive.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a great question. And it's it's a hopeful thing that ESG is becoming more important in conversations. I think you're right that there is a there's a cultural change happening there where folks, not only are folks believing that it's important to focus on sustainability and governance and good governance, it's also that um, and maybe this is the more important part, uh, companies and executives want to be seen supporting it. It's important to their reputations to be, to be, um, to be seen supporting it, even if they do or not behind closed doors or at the dinner table. And arguably that's the the greater tipping point once it becomes um a broader cultural phenomenon. I again, though, I would say don't throw the baby out with bathwater. It's good to have all these ESG indicators. The more data we have, the better. Um, but again, positivism and the the gathering of data that all comes from the industrial revolution, being able to quantify things and think about things in boxes and look at them. And I would just caution us not to go too far, not to go too far down that road. Just because somebody doesn't meet the ESG score that maybe your particular metric um says is it's supposed to be doing, that's not a reason then to cut them off. Um, if we're going to build a more sustainable future and we're going to actually build a circular economy and think about climate change and work together, um, you stand a lot better chance of doing so if you welcome in the companies that focus on hydrocarbons right now or focus on building bridges with those companies that maybe don't have the good ESG scores. So I say that just to say that I feel like sometimes you check off boxes and say, oh, I can invest in that particular thing because it checks off the ESG box I want. Sure, great. Like if you're a retail investor and that's what you want to do, it's great that you have access to that information. But let's not use those ESG indicators to create a prison for ourselves or to stop ourselves from actually cooperating with folks throughout the entire ecosystem in order to make broader systemic change. Like use the ESG indicators to create better outcomes for humans, not just to make yourself feel good that your however much money or your operations are doing the thing that society will think is good. Um it's it's hard advice. Like, this is not like in some ways, climate change is not a business issue. Um, supply chains are a business issue. Climate change is a moral issue. It's an ethical issue. Um, it's it it is it is also a business issue in and of its own right. But there is that moral ethical element to it as well. And I think the way to you you sort of have to confront that head on, and you have to think about marrying the business and the moral and thinking about that really honestly and really openly and understanding that you're gonna have to work with everyone, even the folks that are doing things right now that you don't like, because the only way to get where we want to go is if everybody again is pushing in that same direction. It's um so I guess the short answer to your question is it's great. I like the focus on ESG, but let's make sure we use it to actually create better outcomes for humans and actually um creating tangible change in climate, even if that means partnering with folks who they don't meet your indicators right this moment, but you want them to in the future. Sure.
SPEAKER_00We are coming towards the the close of the podcast now, uh Jacob. I mean, you keep telling me you're optimistic, and then you keep sounding less optimistic than you claim you are. Are are you are you in fact optimistic that we will reach our Paris climate goals, for example?
SPEAKER_01Uh look, I I am optimistic, but I'm also I'm a I guess I'm a little bit of a sadomasochist because I'm an optimist who's in geopolitical risk consulting, and geopolitics is not a space where a lot of optimism is good, but I think that's how I balance myself. I I kind of stay sane that way. Uh look, no, I I am, I actually am very optimistic. And um, one of the things that Perch does that is different than a lot of different geopolitical consulting companies out there, is that it's not just about risk management. I really do think it's about identifying opportunities and then using information to have power to make change. So I believe that none of the challenges that we've talked about today, as big as they are, I don't think they're beyond us. I think we can absolutely tackle them. Um, I just think that that it's my job to give a really clear and sober description of the scale of the challenge, because I think it's that deep. I think it's that big of a challenge. So the optimist in me is like, yes, we can absolutely do these things. And the risk analyst in me is let's not let's not dumb this down at all. Let's not pretend like if we just have a couple ESG indicators or if we start um, you know, managing carbon emissions, that everything's gonna be okay. That the scope of the challenge is extremely, is extremely real. But yeah, I think in some ways, um, climate change could be the biggest force for globalization and for global cooperation and peace that we've ever seen. Because we finally have an issue that it doesn't matter what your borders are, it doesn't matter what your geography is. This stuff is going to affect all of us. And we have a choice in front of us. We can either choose to lapse into things that we've done previously, where we compete and the countries that are going to benefit from climate change do well and hold it over the countries that are not going to uh that are not gonna do well because of climate change, because there's gonna be winners and losers there. Um, or we can say, look, this affects humans as a species. And this is really a fight about um more integration, more globalization, more data for everyone, learning how to cooperate with each other because that's the only way we're gonna move forward. So um, yes, I the optimist in me would tell you the hour is late, but it's not too late. Um and I can imagine a universe in which um we start using these challenges that we're facing together to move forward rather than to compete with each other. That's one of the reasons I frame COVID as a climate challenge, because um, it needs to be a wake-up call. Like we we failed with COVID. We didn't deal with COVID the right way. If we deal with climate change the way we dealt with COVID, we're screwed. It's already over. Um so I don't think it's too late. And I think there are a lot of ways that companies, governments, even individuals, the the things that they do, the language they use, the behaviors they they model, all that stuff is important and all of us can can make a difference in that sense. Um, but you know, it's it's time. Like we don't have a lot of time to waste anymore. If you and I are still having this conversation here in 10 years, I'll probably be a lot less optimistic. So hopefully, hopefully that urgency, hopefully um the scope of the challenge um gets us moving in that direction. Maybe what's happening between Biden and Xi Jinping in the US and China will be the first step. Wouldn't that be great if the US and China could say, you know what, we disagree on all these different things, but we agree that we're not even going to be around to fight each other if the climate sucks. So let's focus on fixing the climate together and then we'll fight around the edges. That would be great. That would be a that would be the sort of geopolitical step forward that would validate that thesis that we can use this to unify rather than to divide and compete. Nice. Nice.
SPEAKER_00Jacob, uh we're coming towards the end, as I said. Is there anything I haven't asked you that you kind of wish I had, any topics that we've not discussed that you think it's important to talk about?
SPEAKER_01Um no, I think I think we I think we actually covered it all, Tom. I can't think of anything that we that we missed out on. Nice.
SPEAKER_00I'm awesome.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's true.
SPEAKER_00That's that's why I keep coming back. Super. Jacob, if people want to know more about yourself or perch or any of the topics we discussed today, apart from things like the Financial Times, Wall Street Journal, where where should they go? Where would you have me direct them?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so check us out at perchperspectives.com uh or email us at info at perchperspectives.com. We put out a twice-a-week geopolitics newsletter. Um, we have our own podcast. Tom has been a guest on that podcast as well. If you want to check that out, and then you know, drop us a line. I read everything that comes into that that info at perchperspectives.com email address. So if you want to talk um about what you had for breakfast this morning or maybe what perch can do to help you future proof things for your for your own line of business, we're always around.
SPEAKER_00Super, super. Okay, we've come to the end of the show. Thanks everyone for listening. If you'd like to know more about Climate 21, feel free to drop me an email to Tom.raftere at sap.com or connect with me on LinkedIn or Twitter. If you liked the show, please don't forget to subscribe to it in your podcast application of choice to get new episodes as soon as they're published. Also, please don't forget to rate and review the podcast. It really does help new people to find the show. Thanks. Catch you all next time.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Buzzcast
Buzzsprout
Wicked Problems - Climate Tech Conversations
Richard DelevanClimate Connections
Yale Center for Environmental Communication
The Climate Pod
The Climate Pod
Climate Action Show
Climate Action Collective
The Climate Question
BBC World Service
Energy Gang
Wood Mackenzie
Climate Positive
HASI
Climate One
Climate One from The Commonwealth Club