Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Climate Confident is for business leaders, climate professionals and policymakers who need to understand what is actually cutting emissions—and what it takes to make those solutions work at scale.
Each Wednesday, technology and sustainability analyst, keynote speaker and former SAP Global VP Tom Raftery speaks with the executives, engineers, scientists, founders and policymakers turning climate ambition into measurable progress. Together, they examine the technologies, business models, policies and implementation strategies reshaping energy, transport, industry, supply chains, food and finance.
These are not conversations about distant targets, vague pledges or greenwash. They are candid discussions about what is working, what is failing, where the real bottlenecks lie, and how leaders can make better decisions about decarbonisation, resilience, investment and risk.
You will hear:
- Proven approaches to reducing emissions
- Hard-earned lessons from real-world implementation
- Analysis of the markets, technologies and policies driving the transition
- Honest examination of costs, trade-offs, setbacks and unintended consequences
- Practical ideas for turning climate commitments into action
New episodes are published every Wednesday at 7am CET. Subscribers also receive bonus episodes featuring highlights, analysis and emerging themes from across the series.
Follow Climate Confident for practical climate solutions, informed debate and the insights you need to turn ambition into measurable progress.
Guest suggestions and feedback are welcome at Tom@tomraftery.com.
Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Carbon Budgets, Carbon Bubbles, And The Risk To The Financial Sector - A Chat With Carbon Tracker's Mark Campanale
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Get in touch - leave me a message
I first came across the Carbon Tracker Initiative about 8-9 years ago when they posted a cool short video explaining the concept of a Carbon Budget.
I follow the Carbon Tracker Initiative's Founder and Executive Chairman Mark Campanale on LinkedIn so I reached out to him to see if he'd be willing to come on the podcast to explain it.
We had a fascinating conversation about what the carbon budget is, the implications of these stranded assets for pension funds and financial markets in general, COP 26, and what we hope to see come out of that, and practical steps any of us can take to move the needle on this.
This was a truly fascinating episode of the podcast and I learned loads as always, and I hope you do too.
If you have any comments/suggestions or questions for the podcast - feel free to leave me a voice message over on my SpeakPipe page, head on over to the Climate 21 Podcast Forum, or just send it to me as a direct message on Twitter/LinkedIn. Audio messages will get played (unless you specifically ask me not to).
And if you want to know more about any of SAP's Sustainability solutions, head on over to www.sap.com/sustainability, and if you liked this show, please don't forget to rate and/or review it. It makes a big difference to help new people discover the show. Thanks.
And remember, stay healthy, stay safe, stay sane!
Music credit - Intro and Outro music for this podcast was composed, played, and produced by my daughter Luna Juniper
Sign up to Climate Confident+ for deep dive analysis of the major climate and energy stories of the day.
Podcast subscribers
I'd like to sincerely thank this podcast's amazing subscribers:
- Anita Krajnc
- Cecilia Skarupa
- Ben Gross
- Jerry Sweeney
- Andreas Werner
- Stephen Carroll
- Roger Arnold
And remember you too can Subscribe to the Podcast - it is really easy and hugely important as it will enable me to continue to create more excellent Climate Confident episodes like this one, as well as give you access to the entire back catalog of Climate Confident episodes.
🎤 Looking for a keynote speaker on climate, energy, AI, or sustainability?
I help executive audiences understand the technologies, trends, and decisions shaping the low-carbon transition.
Download my Speaker Pack: https://tinyurl.com/spkrpck
And a quick note before you go: I’ve started a new Reddit community for serious, evidence-led discussion on climate solutions, clean energy, decarbonisation, policy, technology, and what actually works in practice.
If you’d like to suggest future guests, challenge ideas from the show, or share climate reports and solutions worth discussing, join us at r/ClimateConfident
And we will still able to conclude just the listed companies alone. We're going to bake break the carbon budget to one and a half degrees and in the state owned enterprises, I mean, we've got a massive problem. And what we said on our first report called unburnable carbon, other financial markets carrying a carbon bubble from 2011 is that this represented not just a risk to pension funds, and the public actually, they represented a risk to the financial stability of the whole market system.
Tom Raftery:Good morning, good afternoon, or good evening wherever you are in the world. This is the climate 21 podcast, the number one podcast showcasing best practices in climate emissions reductions. And I'm your host, global vice president for SAP Tom Raftery. Climate 21 is the name of an initiative by SAP to allow our customers calculate, report and reduce their greenhouse gas emissions. In this climate 21 podcast, I will showcase best practices and thought leadership by SAP, by our customers, by our partners and by our competitors if their game in climate emissions reductions. Don't forget to subscribe to this podcast in your podcast app of choice to be sure you don't miss any episodes. Hi, everyone. Welcome to the Climate 21 podcast. My name is Tom Raftery with SAP and with me on the show today I have my special guest, Mark. Mark, would you like to introduce yourself?
Mark Campanale:Thanks. So I'm delighted to be with you and your listeners today. My name is Mark Campanale. I'm the founder and Executive Chair of the Carbon Tracker initiative. We're a nonprofit, financial Think Tank, they're set up about 10 years ago, there's about 3035 of us. What we do is we model coal oil and gas production. It's very focused, but we look at it through a financial market lens our our audiences is the financial community and financial regulators and my colleagues many of them have a similar background to me they've worked in the City of London or in Wall Street, they've been sell side analysts producing research for pension funds or or they've been like me, they've been on the buy side which are managing money for for pension funds. And what we try to do as a think tank is look at how the clean energy transition, how climate policy is going to completely disrupt the whole of the energy system and the transportation system, and then try and give some steers to pension funds concerned about risk.
Tom Raftery:Interesting. Interesting. And I think it's something you know, and we talked about this earlier, before we turned on the recorder. It's something that not a lot of people have grasped yet. But you guys, I came across you first a good few years ago, probably very early on when you released a cool video talking about something called a carbon budget. And for people who are not aware, and I've mentioned it in a couple of presentations, because it's I think it's such a an easy concept to grasp. But I'll let you explain it. And you know, for people who haven't come across it, can you explain what the idea of a carbon budget is?
Mark Campanale:Thanks, Tom, if you were to get in a car and drive at motorway speed going vertically upwards would take you less than 10 minutes before your escape the atmosphere is stats that very thin level layer of of gases that surrounding the planet and and what we're doing with pollutions we're putting 10s of giga tons of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, that very thin layer. And of course, what it's doing is the greenhouse effect, we know it's acting as an insulator, which is what's causing temperature rises. So we can actually model scientifically how much carbon dioxide and other gases like methane we're putting in the atmosphere, and how that's likely to change temperature systems and weather systems. So that's the core concept of of the carbon budget, we've had average warming global average mean temperature of around 16 degrees Celsius, pretty stable, over say the last 10,000 years, the last 50 years, we've changed the carbon dioxide concentration from around 350 parts per million a bit less actually and increase that above 400. And we're heading heading north of us and the higher the concentrations of co2, the higher the higher the warming. So the question then, that we have to ask ourselves is, is how much do we How much more are we planning to put into the atmosphere? You can look at historical trends in pollution we emit around 40 Giga tons of carbon dioxide a year. The budget we estimate the scientists estimates that to give us a 66% chance of avoiding this one and a half degrees increase above the 16 degrees we we only have a carbon budget of around 300 Giga tons some says higher Archer About 500 with different probabilities. But the point of this is, if you're releasing 40 gigatons a year, then you can only emit 300, you're down to less than 10 years before we go through before you're locking in one and a half degrees. So and if you do the numbers again and say, Well, what about two degrees and three degrees, you're talking within the next 30 years. So that so what we do today, the decisions we make today, today are profound consequences for the future of fear, essentially, the future of this species.
Tom Raftery:And I think what was really interesting to me as well, about the concept of the carbon budget is not alone, did you estimate the amount of giga tons of co2 that we can emit, to reach that kind of one and a half or two degree warming? But you then said, Okay, what is the proven reserves of the fossil fuel companies and countries? And it turns out that the proven reserves of these organizations is three times what we can actually emit, which is obviously massively problematic for them. And for us, and, you know, it speaks to I mean, if the for people who are unaware, the proven reserves are, what the lending of these organizations is based on, it's what their market capital is based on or market capitalization is based on the share price is based on if they have to write off two thirds of their value. You know, it's it. It's hugely problematic. It's massive stranded assets.
Mark Campanale:If you've got gone straight to the heart of the question, Tom, that's exactly right. So what we didn't know 10 years ago is what percentage of exons and shells and BPS and all the others fossil fuel reserves and what they produced and Sony share what Ashley what was causing the climate problem was it 5% of the warming problem, or 10%. Now, when we analyze those companies, we also analyzed the Saudi Aramco and the state owned entities, so you need to look at the entire picture. And we were still able to conclude just the listed companies alone, we're going to be break the carbon budget to one and a half degrees and in the state owned enterprises. I mean, we've got a massive problem. And what we said on our first report called unburnable, carbon, other financial markets carrying a carbon bubble from 2011 is that this represented not just a risk to pension funds, and the public actually, they represented a risk to the financial stability of the whole market system. And the banking system, we estimate that something like a half of non bank corporate bonds are linked to the fossil fuel economy. So you're not just coal, oil and gas, you've got to add in aviation cements steel shipping, you got entire systems built around the fossil fuel economy, look at shipping, further shipping is to shipping oil and gas. Yeah, so if you decarbonize all of that, and you have to do it very rapidly, this represented quite a big systemic risk to market. So we, we think something like a quarter and carbon tracking, we've written a paper called the decline and fall of the fossil fuel system of our website, anyone can download it around a quarter of equity capital markets and link to the fossil fuel system as well. So if you are Ravel not just the oil and gas sector, but you unravel the fossil fuel economy decarbonize cement and steel and aviation, you're going to have to turn over the capital stock of, of the global economy, you're going to have to replace high carbon manufacturing systems with low carb, and we have to have us a financial market system that is able to absorb the costs, but then be strong enough actually to put the money money up to replace capital stock. With new with with new systems. Now we've actually done it quite successfully already. In the case of automobile manufacturer, we've managed to take out a lot of the internal combustion engine manufacturing systems and replace them with electric vehicle systems. And that's, you know, anyone can read about what BMW and Volkswagen, all those companies are doing already today. Yeah, but can you do it with shipping? Can you do it with the power system can you do it with with the heating system, and that really is the imponderable. That's really the challenge of the next decade.
Tom Raftery:And if you say that a third of the global shipping system is used to ship fossil fuels. If we get off if we shift off successfully off fossil fuels, that means a third of the global ships are no longer required.
Mark Campanale:Yeah, you'd have to draw that conclusion. Yeah, certainly over the next decade or two. So it changes the way we think about about shipping. So what I'm saying I think what we're both saying is, is you have to think of this issue as a systems risk issues not isolated to do switch from an internal combustion, Jakarta electric one, it's not isolated to that or do switch from a coal fired, power generating system to wind and solar, maybe a bit of nuclear, you're actually got to transform the entire basis upon which we build a modern industrial economy.
Tom Raftery:Yeah. Yeah, I saw a headline a couple of months ago now, where it talked about a coal fired power plant in Germany that had just just been shut down. And it was shut down for reasons of economics. And this was a power plant, which was commissioned in 2015. So in six years, it had gone from being commissioned to being shut down. I mean, I don't know how much it costs to build a coal fired power plant, but it's got to be in at least the 10s of millions or more.
Mark Campanale:Hundreds, hundreds runs. Yeah.
Tom Raftery:Yeah. And yeah, you're writing that off in six years? Yeah. There's no way investors who who financed that, you know, there's no way they got a return on their investment.
Mark Campanale:No, that's completely right. And you're seeing people building pipelines, particularly, you know, the Nord Stream pipeline from Russia to Europe, and the pipelines from Canada down into America that the investors are buying this thinking it's got a 3040 year life and infrastructure funds that are owned by pension funds are buying what they think is long life infrastructure, you know, with a 3040 lights, but but, but they're wrong. I mean, a lot of this will have less than 10 year life, five year life in the case of the coal fired power station, then it sort of begs the question, Why are why do we have a financial system that is building completely new fossil fuel infrastructure, the figure that the International Energy Agency uses is that there's around $1 trillion a year globally, is spent on building out even more fossil fuels. Right. Which has to be anyone's definition of insanity. Because that's somebody is paying for that? Is that a bank? Is it your pension fund is your insurance company that's coming from somewhere. So the university endowment, you know, that's paying for that? So, so a lot of this has to be rethought. I mean, people are doing the thinking now, it is changing. Let's be clear. Okay. And I'm on the advisory council for something called GE fancy Glasgow finance alliance for net zero, which now has, I think, 40 $50 trillion of banks that have joined. So they're all on this journey to try and understand what decarbonisation means. But as of today, you've got the big banks like JP Morgan, and Barclays still investing billions and billions of dollars in in more fossil fuel production, and you can't be committed to net zero and continue to fund the fossil fuel system at the same time. It's, it's just scientifically illiterate. Yeah. Yeah. And as well as financially, it's Fred.
Tom Raftery:Yeah. And it's, it's interesting that you bring that up that you you can't, you know, be investing and be committed to net zero, because, I mean, the the whole carbon budget thing, says that we have already far more fossil fuels at our beck and call than we can ever use. And in that scenario, how can fossil fuel companies justify the existence of their exploration arms? Because, yeah, yeah, you know, and, and they say they're committed to net zero, I get my head explodes. I have no idea.
Mark Campanale:A lot of these companies are run by guys. And the most exciting thing they can do is to go out and dig a hole, and use a lot of a lot of engineering equipment. And if you've grown up and trained as an engineer, of course, that's what you want to go and do, preferably if you can use some explosives along the way. And so so there was a bit of a mindset, quite insular. A lot of the companies you look at the senior management, they haven't come from outside, they've actually come in inside the company. They're grown up surrounded by other people that like drilling holes. And so you create a culture of that this is the only way we can do energy. Of course, it's not to move from A to B. You don't need to burn anything. You don't need to burn to heat to burn something teacher home. Yeah. I mean, the funny thing is Tom, and I'm not the first person set to say this, but we'll be the first generation in human history that hasn't had to set fire to something to heat ourselves or to cook or to move on. If you go back to the Neanderthal man in a cave, you know, he had to use some twigs to create a fire if you wanted to eat or keep warm. And today, we're the first generation because we don't, we don't need to do that anymore because we can. We can use electrons to do all of that. And we're going to see the electrification of transportation and power. And we're going to find heating from other sources, whether it's going to be hydrogen or ground source heat plants, and we're in the middle of this extraordinary clean energy revolution. And a lot of it is the skills around electronics, I mean, all is all electric vehicles is a computer on some wheels, basically. And do do the oil and gas companies. So you know, the guys with with the big gloves and the 10 hats, do they have do they? Are they typically people that are electrical electronics, engineers, not really, it's a different skill set. And so a lot of those companies in my view will ultimately be swept away for a very simple reason, of course, which is renewables and are cheaper in 90% of the world than than fossil fuels is cheaper to to build solar and battery storage, then to continue to run a coal fired power in many parts of the world. So that's that's the good news of the of the energy transfer transition. That's that's the upside, I think, of the energy transition. So why did the banks continue to fund this? I think, probably the death there of the mindset, that change won't happen very quickly. But whenever I'm doing a lecture, I asked how many people in the lecture room have a Blackberry? Not many hands go up and a lot of people what's a Blackberry? And yeah, just a decade ago, yeah. But everyone had a Blackberry, nobody had the iPhone. But when the iPhone arrived, it didn't go 3%. Market share six 812 1722 wasn't linear, it was exponential when iPhones went from 1% 7% 20% 50%. And then of course, it was game over, but for the BlackBerry was exponential. So this is the era I think, of the fossil fuel companies and the bankers who fund now is they think the energy transition is going to be linear, or when in my view is going to be it's going to be exponential. And, and, you know, if you're a shareholder, in a company that's facing a technology threat, flight to shareholders and blackberry, I mean, another good example is, is blockbuster. You know, when Netflix arrived, what was the board of blockbuster doing? Were they saying, we're going to double down and get the public to buy more videos. We said what they were saying than that, no, people go what you mean, I don't have to go to the video store anymore. I can live stream 20,000 films and I can choose from without leaving the home. And by the way, you won't pay a late fee fight. Remember pay fees to Blockbuster, when you put your video, but I mean, that's part of their revenue model. And I think the same thing is going to happen with the fossil fuel system, is people going to be surprised just how quickly it's going to go. People won't go to the end of the road and queue down the street to fuel up their car, they will just plug it in the front in the front yard or on the street or in a lamppost.
Tom Raftery:Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I mean, I drive an Eevee. But we're a single car family, and I drive a VW ad for and it's absolutely fantastic. I went on a holiday to a studious, I live in Seville, I went on a holiday to a serious during the summer, it's 850 kilometers away, and it was painless to do so. Our energy provider is 100% renewable, we have a five kilowatt solar array on the roof, all our heating and cooling is electric, all our cooking is electric. So you know, we've made that shift, and zero downsides and huge upsides for, you know, the planet. I want to thank we're not huge, but you know, it's, you know, so it's not hard to do. How do we tell the financial system that this is happening? And you know, you need to be aware of these risks?
Mark Campanale:Well, that's really why I set up carbon tracking is to express to explore that question. How do we communicate with the financial system? So the financial system tends to listen to three or four groups, customers, what are customers telling us? Now if you look at the size of the divestment movement, which is at the moment, around $15 trillion of pension funds have divested from fossil fuels. What we knew knew well, I knew carbon track was happening as endowments were ringing up whether it was Goldman Sachs or UBS or any of the other big fund managers going, why when fossil fuels we can't burn all this stuff is climate change? Can you please get us out? They in turn triggered the fund managers to go what's what's this about? Let's invest to gauge the science of carbon budgets and global warming, and they don't educated themselves and then so on and so forth so so the quote so accountant customers, I think that's that's clearly the case. It came from financial regulators. So Alex Sharma announced yesterday new guidance for the investment system for disclosure around climate risk for for customers. And, and but regulators is more than that. It's it's the listing rules of the stock market how, what a company's raising capital have to say, and I was struck when I read the IPO, the initial public offering document of extractor, which is now public. Glencore, it rents like 300 pages, all they do is coal. Okay, let's be clear, it's a comp company. Of the 300 pages, there are only 20 lines about climate change rates. Can you believe that 20 line, I thought 20 lines in a 300 page document. But on all you do is call? I thought, Well, that can't be right. Why why financial regulators missing the most important risk that you should be talking about? Why did it only merit virtually a side note in in the document that you were going into the market and saying, here's our credible business plan, please, can you give us billions? How come the most important risk wasn't at the heart of that IPO? So regulators need to think about those questions. And of course, they've shifted and Mark Carney, his work and the work of the Financial Stability Board and the Bank of England has has been really triumphantly game changing. And I think the highlights of my sort of career was being asked by Mark Carney in 2015, to present the Carbon Bubble stranded assets thesis to the Financial Stability Board, which is all the central bankers. And then he went on to give his famous Lloyd's of London insurance speech where he echoed our reports and talked about unburnable carbon, so regulators are really crucial. But then you've got the third group, which is the accountants and the auditors who put the books together and the numbers together and Carbon Tracker. Yes, we're playing spending a lot of time scrutinizing what the auditors and accountants do. And just to give you an example, and our recent accounting work, which you can download from carbon tracker.org, we spotted how companies were telling the market about their climate plans saying, We think oil prices will fall as demand falls, we think$50 A barrel for oil and gas is what the price should be. But then when you turn to the back end of their accounts, their disclosures to the market, they're saying, We think oil prices are going to be $70 a barrel. Now, Tom, that doesn't sound right. To me, you can't say in the public eye climate strategy is based on one thing, and then in your accounts, you say it's based on something completely different. So you've got to harmonize them. So when, if the auditors were to look at their fossil fuel company and say, We think you know, when, if you have a computer, you write it down by 1/3, in your books each year is called depreciation. Now, in the fossil fuel system, because we're going to drop, we're going to have to reduce emissions by 50%. You should be depreciating your fixed assets, your coal fired power stations or refineries, your pipelines. So when you pick up the accounts of the oil and gas companies, where's the where's that depreciation? A third of their assets or 20% of their assets each year to be inlined. With Net Zero? Of course, there isn't any. Yeah, they they're the the auditors and the accountants are treating the assets of the fossil fuel economy as if they've got this 2030 year life. So the auditors don't act for the company, the auditors act for the shareholders, and they often forget this. The auditors are there to tell the shareholders whether the management is properly managing the assets of the company. And if the auditors are saying, well, no, the board has decided that they're going to be building more fossil fuel assets, and they're not going to be writing it down. What we're probably going to see as the shareholders go, Well, look, you know, we can just remove you as auditors. We don't think you've done a good job, we're going to vote down the accounts. And we're going to, we're going to ask the company to reappoint new auditors are going to do this properly. I mean, this is the battle really, that I'm sure boards of companies can have to face up to, in the next decade against increasingly vocal and engaged shareholders. And we saw I mean, a good example of this was engine one. Yeah, the hedge fund. Exxon being the biggest bully in the playground thought that they were invincible. Along comes engine one says very simply, you don't have a strategy for the future. And with 0.02% of the shares of Exxon, they managed to remove three board directors, because they gained the support of the majority of the institutions like State Street and Vanguard and BlackRock and now once you've done that to the biggest blue in the room, Kenny and your little your little kid, and the little kid goes walking and the rest of the pipe, but playground, all the other little kids, all the other big kids in the playground are going up. Am I going to be next? Yeah. And that's the message I think engine one has sent the fossil fuel system is that is that any company, if Exxon is vulnerable, any company is vulnerable. And we're going to be institutional shareholders and activist investors are going to come along and look at all the boards of the fossil fuel companies, whether it's shell or Chevron, whoever it's going to be and say, Are you are you climate competent? Do you have a transition plan? Are you future fit, and if shareholders don't believe so, or the companies don't have an adequate Transition Plan, people going to get metaphorically bopped off by being removed from the board. And I think we're going to be at the beginning really have quite a significant change in the institutional investor activism. So if you take all those three together, because the customer focus the regulatory focus, the accounting and audit, the rise of investor activism on this issue, I think the financial system even with its flaws, even with ignoring the key changes, I think need to happen. It's It's waking up and is in some respects, is doing a job what government should be government should be interviewing getting policy, in the absence of shareholders sort of stepping up to the plate, a lot more can be done, of course, but the site signs are looking much better now than they were even three years ago.
Tom Raftery:And speaking of governments, we are just coming into cop 26. What what are you hoping emerges from that?
Mark Campanale:Well, gosh, Tom, I mean, that, you know, the problem of climate change, and global warming is primarily one of burning fossil fuels. So the Paris Agreement, it's it's an Emissions Reduction Agreement that gets government's to write these things called NDCs, nationally determined contributions, which are the government's plans to reduce emissions. The one thing most people will be surprised by this, and I don't know if your listeners know this, that the words coal, oil and gas and fossil fuels don't appear anywhere in the Paris Climate Agreement. You know, you're probably not Yeah, most people don't know. It's, it's it's not a it's not a fossil fuel climate change treaty, it is an Emissions Reduction Treaty, as if the two are not related. And so as a consequence, when we go into Glasgow, will there be any discussion by governments? Or even the scientists about constraining the production of fossil fuels? And the answer to that is no, there won't be. And so we're going to come out of of the Glasgow cop, the most we go expect is higher ambition, statements and commitments, we're going to probably have people try and talk about things like cross border adjustment, taxes, possibly carbon pricing, but I don't think they're going to make it anywhere close to the, to the to the announcement, official cop announcement, what you what you might get is government's firming up the so called 100 billion to go to the global south to assist them with the energy transition, but you won't get any discussion of fossil fuels. And so that I think, is his floor. So I, I'm on the steering group of, of an initiative that says, look, we got to stop this acceleration in the production of fossil fuels. We've got to stop this race from the bottom. If Canada doesn't produce the fossil fuels Russia, well, if the Russians weren't the Saudis, well, and each country wanting to, to produce some more to get more market share. And so there's a civil society global south led initiative called the fossil fuel Non Proliferation Treaty, you can you can see the website, fossil fuel treaty.org, that tries to say to governments, look, we've got to get off this race to produce more fossil fuels. We have to everyone has to sit around the table, the Canadians, the Americans, the Russians, and Norwegians. The Middle East, of course, all the major producers of fossil fuels. And and like with nuclear nonproliferation, who said, Let's hand back the missiles, which, of course, what the Russians and the French and the Americans and the Brits decided to do. We've got to do the same with fossil fuels. We have to start counseling licenses. We have to we have to stop this collective insanity that says we need more fossil fuels, which is what the companies are saying is what the companies are telling governments and have an honest conversation. If we were to get in. If we were to get into the next century in any kind of stable weather system. We have to have this conversation and I'm afraid Glasgow will not have that conversation. But the youth is demanding it. The global south is demanding it. Scientists is demanding it we need to have this conversation.
Tom Raftery:How far away are we from having a Do you think I mean it it is some if you look at the trends, they are, I think all going in the right direction. Some faster than others.
Mark Campanale:Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, there is an initiative called Bogu, which stands for the beyond oil and gas Alliance, which is led by the Danish and the Danes have announced that they will ban all new oil and gas production licenses and exploration and Europe's biggest one of Europe's biggest producers of oil and gas. And do I have a slight Irish twin? You do. And you'll know that Ireland was the other country that has banned oil and gas exploration and they've also the state fund. The Irish reserve fund has banned investments in fossil fuels. I think he knew that. That's what we need to do around the world. But the UK the United Kingdom Government has no such ban.
Tom Raftery:And not to Norway, announced a couple of weeks ago that they're not going to stop.
Mark Campanale:That's right. And and in the UK right now you've got the Cambo proposed development, which is a shell invested project up in the North Sea in Scottish waters, which is which is waiting for this government, Boris's government, whether it gets permission to go ahead or not. So you've got the discussions in Canberra to build yet another coal mine. So so we need to move beyond on a guest. But where we do have some international support is, is something called the powering past coal initiative, which the UK Government does support and Carbon Tracker is involved in which tries to get international agreement. So there are signs, there are signs of people willing to discuss it. But I've been amazed because I've been on a number of phone calls, I've been amazed by the resistance to by countries to even a discussion about about their licensing rounds, because they see it as a source of revenue i There is no single place you can go to anywhere in the world. That gives you a complete picture of what fossil fuels have been produced and where and by who mean the International Energy Agency has data BP with this energy outlook. And so so does shell have some data. And the scientists have a rough idea as well. But there's no publicly available library of information about what oil and gas projects are called projects have been developed close to where you live. So I chair, a sister project to the fossil fuel and Operations Research Chair project called the Global registry of fossil fuels, which is funded philanthropically, and we're working on at the moment, and we're trying to build an open source library that tells people how much carbon dioxide is in the projects which have been developed in their country. And from that, what is the forecast potential co2 emissions from all these new licenses that are being handed out whether it's coal or oil or gas. And with that, we hope that policymakers and scientists and citizens can all kind of have this sort of see the collective picture this, this, this is equal to four degrees or more of warming, and they'll be able to see it with great clarity. And then they'll be able to Depop could be able to put pressure on the politic politicians or policymakers to sort of say, Look, this really has to, has to stop. So when are there anywhere close to it today? No, no, we're not in. And last week, I spoke to the chief executive of a major oil and gas trade body and said, Look, you know, you call for greater transparency? Would you support the call for a global registry of fossil fuel production? And basically, after half an hour of chatting essentially sort of said, No. And the reason why is that is that it this goes to the heart of the fossil fuel industry, his business model, which is go and find more, go and sell more, and go and make more money, or they think they will go and make more money. And so of course, I don't want the public scrutinizing that. Even with all the cause for say, Yeah, we support transparency and openness. But of course, they use any kind of reasons not actually to not actually reality to be open and transparent.
Tom Raftery:Yeah, yeah. I remember I wrote a blog post in 2015. And that was a time when global oil prices had tanked. And I actually referenced the carbon budget in the blog post, because it was it was when there was furious talks with OPEC. And the talks broke down, and Saudi just opened the taps, suddenly, the price fell even more. And of course, they've got the cheapest oil to develop. So they don't care how low the price goes. And what I was saying, as you know, because we're in a world of constrained carbon. The Saudis are saying we we know that we can't, you know, get all our carbon into the atmosphere, but we want to make sure that as many gigatons as possible in the atmosphere, or Saudi gigatons so probably a very cynical way of looking at it, but that was that was my interpretation of their attitude at the time.
Mark Campanale:Yeah, yeah. I mean, you put a we put a carbon price at the point of production, for example, so at the wellhead, or at the mine head, the Saudis would then have to say, Okay, well, if there was an international agreement, to sell the oil, they have to pay a carbon price or the point to which the barrel of oil is dispatched with that payment, actually, I mean, the Saudis are still be making money. But at that, with that payment, the world could transfer those funds to the global south for the energy transition to leapfrog don't need to move to a fossil fuel system that can leapfrog to a clean energy system. And the funds for that could come from, you know, payments from people with the who are paying for the, for the right to be the last producer. And that's why this kind of discussion about carbon pricing is helpful, because we can talk about social justice and equity for countries less wealthy, less prosperous than ourselves. And we could be funding that clean energy transition. I mean, it's insane at the moment, countries like Ecuador, are, are mining for oil in their rain forests to produce the cash to fund the debt that they owe to the Global North. I was tweeting recently about Garner, that's trying to develop a multibillion dollar, oil and gas sector and the reason why they've got $30 billion debt to the north to countries like the UK, wouldn't it be much easier to say to the people in Ghana look, cancel your oil and gas production, and we'll cancel your debt. If what's the benefit to the world to to fire it up and have you know, the world on fire, just just a pay tip just to pay interest on the debt that we could have, we could forgive that debt. So we need to think about this in a very different way about how we, how we transition and how we compensate the global south for not producing fossil fuels and how we get to just a fairer world that I do think is possible from from from decarbonizing, I mean, I said, making the remarks earlier that renewables cheaper in most parts of the world and fossil fuels, and there will be a fantastic and enormous democratic dividend to be Think about it like this, that in poorer countries, if they don't have to import their oil and gas or their coal, because they're generating energy locally, you actually will get a financial dividend from that, but a democratic debit again, because the export is like Venezuela, in the Middle East and Russia, there are set up tend to be oligarchs, very powerful state systems and state security. And you remove the you remove the financial base for that political system. Putin has his oligarchs around him, you know, from the guys gas proms and the rolls neffs, you remove the source of that wealth, and then you remove the source of their power. So there could be a democratic dividend, whether as I say, whether it's Venezuela or Russia or Saudi. That's my hope. And you know, we may see that in the next, you know, next two decades, if the clean energy system, as we expect it will, will rise and dominate. And people will be talking about, you know, energy as a percentage of your expenditure, the household will actually fall because renewables will be so to
Tom Raftery:speak. Speaking of hope, given all that we've discussed so far, are you optimistic for the future?
Mark Campanale:Anyone that knows me will know that I'm a happy go lucky, happy guy, and always optimistic that I was born with the glass half full, not half empty. So I am optimistic but but my pessimism will only come into being if we still use see, we still use the same old formulas. And we actually haven't recognized the need to change the way we think. And what I'm really talking to that is we need a we need an agreement that says we need to put fossil fuels back in the box, we need to stop funding fossil fuels. And if we get the same old mantras coming from politicians, that then there will be a little bit of, of pessimism, we still have time left, we can still take to some extent co2 out of the atmosphere, even though it would be costly to do so. The time is against us, but I think we can do it for sure.
Tom Raftery:So, what can Joe Public do? Mark what you know, because we all feel kind of powerless in this. You know, I have done as I said, Evie, photovoltaic panels, everything electric, but is that aid or is there more that can be done?
Mark Campanale:So Tom, are you a member of a pension fund? Yep. Have you written to the pension fund trustees about climate risk and ask them? Are they still investing in fossil fuels and how big they said decarbonisation goals can be done that
Tom Raftery:I haven't, there's a good reason for that. One of the previous guests on the podcast brought up this very topic. And it was Rob Gardner from St. James wealth management. And his his advice to everyone listening, which is I suspect where you were going was to contact your, your HR department and have asked them is the pension fund invested using un PRI standards? And I did. And I hope everyone else listening to the podcast did as well. And if you haven't, you should. Luckily, here in SAP Spain, we are our pension fund is with a company called Vita Keisha, who were they say the first to sign up are the first in Spain maybe to sign up to the UN PRI. Principles for responsible investment as a PRA stands for if I remember correctly, is that is that where you're going back?
Mark Campanale:It could do that, I think you can go further and actually ask for a pension fund that's not just a signatory to the UN PRI. But of course, that's important. But it's actually said we will decarbonize in line with the science we will divest from fossil fuels. And not only that, but we'll have a bias towards investing in a sustainable future. There are a lot of funds out there now with the with the word sustainable future. And if you're part of what's called a money purchase scheme, where you're buying an insured pension plan, as opposed to what's called a final salary scheme, then you could buy a fund yourself, which is invested in a sustainable world, you could do that. Or you could also join campaigns, there's a very good one called Making my money matter, which Richard Curtis, you know, the guy from for weddings in a funeral. Yeah, him and his mates have launched make money matter, which is a public campaign to make the financial system and pension funds more accountable. And then there's another one called share action.org, which is which which is a UK based one which mobilizes shareholders around shareholder resolutions on climate but not just climate, but other issues that are interesting as well. So you can do all of those things. But even if you've done those, if you're if you have house insurance or motor car insurance, they may often come from a household brand name group Amar, or AXA, or, or, or exactly you could write even as you could say, as a as a policyholder, I'm a policyholder of whichever company it is, I want to know that my policy funds are being used responsibly and sustainably. And you can actually decide between insurers not just on how cheap they are, but which ones are taking the most active approach on climate and voting their shares and some much, much better than, than others, actually. And x has taken the diversity from coal, but has Elliott's you know, these are some questions. And there's another good website reclaimed finance.org, which has a lot of this analysis on his website for the public to see. And so so you can vote with your with your with your wallet. As a consumer, you can buy green things. You could vote politically, of course, but you can also vote with your financial products, your bank, your insurer, your pension plan.
Tom Raftery:Nice. Nice. Excellent. That's great advice. Mark. That's been fantastic. If people want to know more about yourself, Mark Campanale. About About the Carbon Tracker initiative. Yeah. Where would you have me direct them?
Mark Campanale:Yeah. So I tweet pretty much every day about things that are topical, as my Twitter handles at Campanale. Mark, Carbon Tracker, we have about 40 50,000 followers on Twitter, and that's at carbon bubble. But if you sign up to our research on our website, carbon tracker.org, it's all free. You'll just get a newsletter will pop up with links to the latest reports on what's going on in the clean energy transition, decarbonisation the fossil fuel system. What's happening to big companies like Shell, you can just let me just get that from our free newsletter, I we regularly present to pension funds trustees around the world, and to the boards of insurance companies as well, and fund managers. And we hope to do more of that. And so if you are a trustee of a pension plan, you can always email us get in touch. And we of course be delighted to talk through what we how we see risk issues and what a good fund manager would be doing today. Know what those risks are.
Tom Raftery:Fantastic, really interesting, Mark, that's been great. Thanks a million for coming on the show today.
Mark Campanale:Thanks Tom
Tom Raftery:okay, we've come to the end of the show. Thanks everyone for listening. If you'd like to know more about climate 21 Feel free to drop me an email to Tom raftery@sap.com or connect with me on LinkedIn or Twitter. If you liked the show, please don't forget to subscribe to it and your podcast application of choice to get new episodes as soon as they're published. Also, please don't forget to rate and review the podcast it really Those help new people to find the show. Thanks. catch you all next time
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Buzzcast
Buzzsprout
Wicked Problems - Climate Tech Conversations
Richard DelevanClimate Connections
Yale Center for Environmental Communication
The Climate Pod
The Climate Pod
Climate Action Show
Climate Action Collective
The Climate Question
BBC World Service
Energy Gang
Wood Mackenzie
Climate Positive
HASI
Climate One
Climate One from The Commonwealth Club