Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Climate Confident is for business leaders, climate professionals and policymakers who need to understand what is actually cutting emissions—and what it takes to make those solutions work at scale.
Each Wednesday, technology and sustainability analyst, keynote speaker and former SAP Global VP Tom Raftery speaks with the executives, engineers, scientists, founders and policymakers turning climate ambition into measurable progress. Together, they examine the technologies, business models, policies and implementation strategies reshaping energy, transport, industry, supply chains, food and finance.
These are not conversations about distant targets, vague pledges or greenwash. They are candid discussions about what is working, what is failing, where the real bottlenecks lie, and how leaders can make better decisions about decarbonisation, resilience, investment and risk.
You will hear:
Proven approaches to reducing emissions
Hard-earned lessons from real-world implementation
Analysis of the markets, technologies and policies driving the transition
Honest examination of costs, trade-offs, setbacks and unintended consequences
Practical ideas for turning climate commitments into action
New episodes are published every Wednesday at 7am CET. Subscribers also receive bonus episodes featuring highlights, analysis and emerging themes from across the series.
Follow Climate Confident for practical climate solutions, informed debate and the insights you need to turn ambition into measurable progress.
Stanford doctoral candidate Benjamin (Ben) Franta (aka @BenFranta on Twitter) has a degree in Applied Physics from Harvard, a Law degree from Stanford, and is currently working on his Ph.D. from Stanford on the history of climate science, climate denial, and the fossil fuel industry.
I came across him when I heard about his most recent paper where he and two French researchers showed how French fossil fuel company Total were aware of harmful global warming impacts since at least 1971 but instead of doing anything about it, they engaged in overt denial of climate science. This was the way fossil fuel companies decided to deal with the issue.
That this was standard practice for fossil fuel companies is something I've been aware of for some time, but I decided to invite Ben to come on the podcast to talk about not just this but also the potential legal ramifications of this behaviour.
This was a truly fascinating episode of the podcast and I learned loads as always, and I hope you do too.
If you have any comments/suggestions or questions for the podcast - feel free to leave me a voice message over on my SpeakPipe page, head on over to the Climate 21 Podcast Forum, or just send it to me as a direct message on Twitter/LinkedIn. Audio messages will get played (unless you specifically ask me not to).
Podcast subscribers I'd like to sincerely thank this podcast's amazing subscribers:
Anita Krajnc
Cecilia Skarupa
Ben Gross
Jerry Sweeney
Andreas Werner
Stephen Carroll
Roger Arnold
And remember you too can Subscribe to the Podcast - it is really easy and hugely important as it will enable me to continue to create more excellent Climate Confident episodes like this one, as well as give you access to the entire back catalog of Climate Confident episodes.
🎤 Looking for a keynote speaker on climate, energy, AI, or sustainability?
I help executive audiences understand the technologies, trends, and decisions shaping the low-carbon transition.
Download my Speaker Pack: https://tinyurl.com/spkrpck
And a quick note before you go: I’ve started a new Reddit community for serious, evidence-led discussion on climate solutions, clean energy, decarbonisation, policy, technology, and what actually works in practice.
If you’d like to suggest future guests, challenge ideas from the show, or share climate reports and solutions worth discussing, join us at r/ClimateConfident
Ben Franta:
We're basically in the 1980s, Exxon, went to the other oil companies and said, Look, we've been doing research about this internally. And this is a major threat to our industry, meaning fossil fuel controls are going to be a major threat to our industry. And we need to get organized and block those fossil fuel controls.
Tom Raftery:
Good morning, good afternoon, or good evening wherever you are in the world. This is the climate 21 podcast, the number one podcast showcasing best practices in climate emissions reductions. And I'm your host, global vice president for SAP. Tom Raftery. Climate 21 is the name of an initiative by SAP to allow our customers calculate, report and reduce their greenhouse gas emissions. In this climate 21 podcast, I will showcase best practices and thought leadership by SAP, by our customers, by our partners and by our competitors if they're game in climate emissions reductions. Don't forget to subscribe to this podcast in your podcast app of choice to be sure you don't miss any episodes. Hi, everyone. Welcome to the Climate 21 podcast. My name is Tom Raftery with SAP and with me on the show today I have my special guest, Benjamin. Benjamin, would you like to introduce yourself?
Ben Franta:
Sure. Well, thanks for having me. My name is Ben Benjamin Franta. And I'm a PhD student in history at Stanford University. And a former law student there just finished law school. And I work on the history of climate politics. I study fossil fuel companies, I study what they knew about climate change, and when what their lobbying activities have been like, and what they've told the public about climate change, too.
Tom Raftery:
Okay, interesting. And obviously, they've only just recently found out about climate change, right?
Ben Franta:
That's right. I think yesterday, you know, earlier this week, yeah.
Tom Raftery:
So tell me no more more seriously. Obviously, I'm being a bit of devil's advocate there being a bit facetious, but, but more more seriously, because I came across you through a publication last week on LinkedIn, or Twitter, one of these ones anyway, where, you know, and this speaks to a lot of investigations that have come to light in the last couple of years, really, around how much oil companies knew. And when, and I think a lot of people might be surprised at what they knew. And when can you tell us a little bit about that from your research?
Ben Franta:
Absolutely. So back in around 2015, this is when the first investigations of the oil companies began, what those investigations found shocked a lot of people including me, they found this internal research from Exxon, from the late 70s, and the early 80s, where Exxon had an internal research program about climate change. That was very sophisticated. And the scientists at Exxon had predicted very accurately how much global warming would occur today that we're living through now. And of course, that juxtaposed with the history of debt of climate denial, which was very strong throughout the 90s, with which oil companies were pushing, and then since then, not necessarily over denial, but you know, blocking legislation and kind of delaying action. You know, that got people's attention. That was around 2015. And since then, a growing number of researchers, journalists, have continued the investigation. So you know, just this week, some French historian colleagues and I had a paper out in a in an academic journal, and it looked at the history of totaal, the French oil company. And, you know, to make a long story short, we found that, yeah, totaal was aware of even the catastrophic, and that's the word they used catastrophic potential of global warming. This is back in the early 1970s, when they were aware of this. And then we got into the archives at totaal. We interviewed some former executives, from totaal. And they described it as this, this bigger story where we're basically in the 1980s, Exxon, went to the other oil companies and said, Look, we've been doing research about this internally. And this is a major threat to our industry, meaning fossil fuel controls are going to be a major threat to our industry. And we need to get organized as and, and block those fossil fuel controls, this is in the mid 1980s. So they privately coordinated amongst themselves internationally even and distributed to all the different oil companies around the world. These talking points, you know, how can we work together to oppose climate treaties, climate legislation, it was, you know, say the science is uncertain, emphasize the costs of, of action. And in most diabolical, in my view, is promote solutions that look like they're solving the problem, but in reality are just distractions and deflections away from fossil fuels. So things like promote reforestation. Right, reforestation is, you know, good, yeah. But they were using it, they weaponize that they used it as a distraction technique, or, you know, focus on efficiency, which, again, efficiency alone is good, of course. And then even, you know, focus on natural gas, they developed all those ideas back in the late 1980s. And then they implemented them in a coordinated fashion. And, and they've a lot of those techniques they've been using ever since. So, yeah, we found a lot of really interesting stuff in this in this latest article.
Tom Raftery:
So they knew in the 70s. I mean, I saw, I've listened to Amy vestre, felts drilled podcast series, and you know it. So for me, this stuff that you're saying now is not shocking, per se, because, you know, it's similar findings. But it's still shocking to me that knowing they were destroying the planet, rather than stop, they decided, no, let's let's double down on this and make as much money as we can, while we still can.
Ben Franta:
Yeah, yeah. And, and what makes all of this more sort of compelling or important is, you know, scientists were studying global warming in the 70s. To some degree. Yeah. And so in that sense, it's not surprising that the fossil fuel companies would have been aware of that research and even discussing it internally, even. But what makes this really significant, of course, is that these companies knew it was their own products, that were going to cause this problem. And so that puts the fossil fuel industry in a special position. You know, legally, yeah. And morally, of course, but, but legally, because if it's your own product that's causing a problem, you know, then you have special duties to deal with that. And those include warning the public about the problem, you know, not staying silent about it. And then doing what you can what is reasonable, what's feasible, to avoid the problem to minimize the damage. And they did not do that either. And, in fact, they, of course, went in the opposite direction, they told the public that this was not a big deal, that this wasn't a problem. And they continue to expand fossil fuel production through their, you know, capital investments, they could have shifted those they did not. And they knew that this would make the problem worse. So
Tom Raftery:
and they spend, you know, that's they spent, they spend millions 10s of millions on lobbying politicians to stall any climate legislation as well. Right.
Ben Franta:
Yeah, that's right. And they continue to do that. And that's like, another area of study is just trying to quantify how much money they spent on lobbying, on advertisements. Big area now is, of course, green advertising. And you've probably seen, you know, advertisements from Exxon or from Shell, on your Twitter or, or other places that are promoting Danny as absolutely, as a green company. They talk about, you know, algae or carbon capture, things like that. And, and so, you know, big area is looking at how much money are they actually spending on those things? And does that stack up with, you know, the impression that you get by looking at these advertisements, and as also potentially, legally actionable, because, you know, you're not supposed to mislead people in your advertisements. So, you know, all of this is extremely important, it kind of just to kind of wrap this thought up, it, it speaks to a higher level of scrutiny that's being placed on the fossil fuel industry now. I think probably a higher level of scrutiny than has ever been placed on them before with regard to the climate issue, at least. And, you know, that's all for the better. I think, you know, to kind of keep Try to keep them honest, as much as possible.
Tom Raftery:
So we saw something like this in the past. I mean, the the other example that we could point to have something similar happening is with the tobacco industry. And the outcome of dad was a big court case, which the tobacco industry lost? Are we going to see something similar with the fossil fuel industry?
Ben Franta:
Well, we've already seen a series of lawsuits filed against the fossil fuel industry, in the United States, and all around the world. And a lot of those lawsuits are based on tobacco litigation, they're very similar. So by that, I mean, you have an industry who has a damaging product, causes some harm. And then the industry becomes aware of that harm. And then deceives, the public about it in some form, doesn't tell the public doesn't warn them, and then denies, you know, the effects. And, and then profits off of the continued use of that product. And so those who are harmed, yeah, they're bringing Sue, you know, they're saying, you owe us some money, you, you need to help us deal with these impacts that you knowingly caused, and made worse. So throughout the United States, I think there's now over a couple of dozen lawsuits throughout the United States being filed by cities, mostly cities and states, the states themselves counties, so these are governmental entities, right. And they're pursuing what's called a cost recovery, sued, you know, let's say you're a coastal city, you have to build a new seawall to deal with sea level rise. And those can be of course, extremely expensive, you know, hundreds of millions of dollars. And, you know, you want the oil companies to pay for part of that. Not all of it, but part of it, based on their contribution to the problem. So that's one kind of lawsuit. And then, elsewhere in the world, there are other lawsuits based on human rights, where, you know, the courts might just simply order the fossil fuel company to change its business to align with some sort of human rights principle, or with the Paris agreement, we saw a huge court case like that in the Netherlands, recently, with Royal Dutch Shell, the oil company there. So these lawsuits are proliferating all around the world, taking different forms in different countries based on their own legal systems. But I think this is going to continue, I actually, actually, my side job is I consult for some of these lawsuits with my historical knowledge, you know, you know, because it's very important information for for them. And I think that these lawsuits are going to continue for the rest of the existence of the fossil fuel industry, I mean, for decades, because climate change is just going to keep getting worse, the damages are going to keep getting worse, you know, our knowledge of what those companies knew, is only becoming clearer over time, as well. And so I think this is gonna, this is a major trend, and it's significant for the business world, as well, you know, relevant to this podcast for sure.
Tom Raftery:
Is there a possibility that some of these fossil fuel companies will be sued out of existence? Or do they have war chests that are just way too big?
Ben Franta:
Well, that's a really good question. That's a, you know, I don't want to speculate it is speculation. I think it's instructive to look at other litigation areas like like tobacco, like opioids, more recently, in the United States. You know, it is possible for some companies to go bankrupt, of course, you know, if they can't, they can't pay a judgment or settlement. Or they enter bankruptcy, though, that all is part of the negotiation. So it's not clear, you know, what the end game will be for these lawsuits, what the outcome will be, you know, we'll see. I think it's going to be interesting, as the suits proceed, the sort of effects on the investment community, you know, as that litigation risk becomes more material for those companies, how are investors going to react to that, you know, I think there will be knock on effects likely. Yeah. You know, for these companies.
Tom Raftery:
reputational risk will impact share price will impact investors. Mm hmm. Yeah. What about the possibility I Can I know you said you don't like to speculate, but what about the possibility that this might cause a change in behavior? Oh, I
Ben Franta:
think it already is, I think it already is, with the oil companies trying to portray themselves as having changed. You know, so you see this, it's sort of like, yeah, I you know, we did that, but we're different now. You know, we've changed. That's, that's something you see from them. Now. It's kind of reflected in their advertising campaigns. And even that Exxon lobbyists, Keith McCoy it, you know, kind of interesting story, there were this exon lobbyist was caught on camera. It was actually a sting operation by some activist, but he he thought he was talking to, you know, potential client or something. It was I think he thought it was a job interview was, yeah, I believe so. And, you know, so he was sort of bragging a little bit about, you know, how Exxon has blocked climate legislation? And, and, you know, he said, Well, yeah, we used to work with Shadow groups, as he called them, to, you know, deny climate science and stuff. But we don't do that anymore. You know, sort of like his like, that was back in the past. So, you know, that's a big question. Is it in the past? Yeah. You know, are these advertisements misleading? For example, if Exxon spends 0.2% of its capital investments in non fossil fuel energy sources? And then spends half of its screen time advertising? Those very minimum de minimis investments? You know, that's that arguably gives a misleading impression to the public, arguably, the activities of the company, right. Yeah. So you know, this is all very live issue. And, you know, I expect, you know, probably there will be litigation about all that, too, because we are seeing the political process has been just jammed up and corrupted by, you know, these companies themselves. So it makes sense that people are turning to the courts to help remedy this problem.
Tom Raftery:
Of the many cases that are out there at the moment, you said, around two dozen, is there anyone that sticks out that you're aware of that, you know, is particularly interesting, or has a particularly good chance of going over the line or anything like that?
Ben Franta:
That's a it's a good question. You know, there are a bunch of suits in the United States. And they're all They're very similar to each other, because their basic, you know, their basic argument is the same. It's like you know, about this, you lied about this. Now, the damage is, you know, materialized and, you know, you need, you need to pay for part of this. And, you know, they're a bunch brought by the different attorneys general of the US, of course, they're quite powerful. They're in powerful positions. They have powerful investigative abilities, you know, so abundant, you know, I think many of them are important. And I don't know, you know, if there's a leading one, the Attorney General Massachusetts file a case, the Attorney General of Minnesota, file a case and there are a bunch of others, too. So these will be very important to watch. You know, they're there. They're moving forward, it seems. And then internationally, there's, there's another interesting strategy, which is to try to align governments and businesses activities with the Paris Agreement. Right. Okay. So, you know, the Paris agreement itself is not legally binding in the most important parts. But it provides this standard. You know, litigants can point to that and say, look, the world has agreed this is the, you know, this is the standard to use, if we're thinking about human rights, or if we're thinking about just a duty of care, sure, that that a government or a company should pursue. So in the Netherlands, I think, you know, we've seen the biggest successes with that strategy, first with a lawsuit against the government, saying the government is violating the rights of the Dutch people by, you know, not taking greater efforts to avoid climate change. And the court agreed, and then they ordered the government to, you know, act more, take more bold action. And then a very same logic, but applied to Royal Dutch Shell in a subsequent lawsuit. And then, so far, the same outcome, you know, at least the lower court so far said, you know, Royal Dutch Shell, you need to align your business model with the Paris Agreement, which of course, implies major changes to their business model, you know, it means to put numbers on and I think the emissions from their products have to declined by about 50%. By this by the end of this decade. Yeah, that implies a major shift away from fossil fuels. So, you know, I think we're seeing that legal strategy as well, and it has promise. So it's it's going to be an area to watch for sure.
Tom Raftery:
And it's interesting talking about that Dutch ruling that you mentioned that their emissions have to drop by the end of the century, because in that ruling, and the judge made very clear that it was absolute emissions that had to fall. And it had to be able to to scope three. And it couldn't be the the terminology that fossil fuel companies today like to use, which is carbon intensity, which is quite different from absolute emissions, it's, you know, you can actually increase your absolute emissions while reducing your carbon intensity by investing in low carbon energy sources, for example.
Ben Franta:
That's right, you know, and of course, if you're just looking at carbon intensity, you can just, you know, you can dial it down just a little bit, of course, while absolute emissions, you know, go up quite a lot. And so you can play that game. And I'm glad that the courts are seeing through that, because that has been a that's been a major smokescreen. Yeah, you know, that and focusing on scope one and scope two and ignoring scope three, when it that's a little bit like a tobacco company saying, Oh, we'll get our employees to smoke less. It's like, well, that's not really the problem here. It's what you're making, you know, it's what you're manufacturing. That's the problem. So, you know, I'm glad the courts have seen through that, I think in an emerging area, might be the net zero paradigm and the net zero pledges. Yeah. And, you know, the potential problem there is that, you know, the phrase net zero implies that there are viable, available, negative emissions tools at our disposal when, when, perhaps there are not. And so those sorts of pledges could also constitute a, you know, a misleading communication, essentially, to the public. And we should have scrutiny on that, you know, if that, if that works out, that's great. If that strategy works out, that's, that's great. But if it is a smokescreen, then it behooves us to catch it as early as possible. And, you know, said things, right. So that's, that could be another area to watch as well.
Tom Raftery:
So somebody isn't going to invent a magic carbon sucking box between now and 2050.
Ben Franta:
We'll see. I mean, of course, carbon capture is an old technology. And so technically, it's, you know, it's there. In fact, there's an old internal document from 1981, from Exxon, one of my favorite internal documents. And it talks about what do we do about the climate problem? What are possible solutions, and it considers carbon capture, it says, well, one, one option is we can just use carbon capture, which already existed at that time. And their assessment was that it's not economically competitive compared to renewables, even at that time. Right. And, of course, you know, think about how renewables have, you know, priced in price. And how carbon capture is, you know, it's a cost adding activity purely, right. So it cannot make fossil fuels more competitive, they can only add to their costs and make them less competitive. And there, there may not be many more cost reductions, because a lot of the parts of that process are mature. And, you know, it's things like, you know, compressing gas, pumping it, you know, these are limited by the laws of thermodynamics in terms of how cheap you can make them. So, you know, we'll see what happens with carbon capture, but I'm not holding my breath, for it to be deployed in massive scale, unless that we're talking about, you know, after fossil fuels are already off the market, maybe some decades from now, and societies still wants to, you know, reduce the co2 in the air so that they may, they might pursue carbon capture, not as a business activity, but as a sort of socialized waste cleanup activity or something like that. I mean, that's a little bit of a different scenario, though, right? Because then we have today
Tom Raftery:
I think as well, it's difficult to grasp the scale of the carbon capture problem because, you know, I say to people, you know, try and visualize a tonne of carbon, or a tonne of co2. You know, let's let's take a small town car like a mini, roughly one ton in weight. Now No, you could compress it down to a smaller size, let's say it's one, one meter one yard cubed. Now, that's one ton. We have to capture 10s of billions of those tons every year. Because, you know, we are emitting 40 billion tonnes a year, nature is taking out 10 to 20. So we have an excess of 20 or more billion tonnes. And like I say, if one time is a meter cubed, picture 100 tonnes picture without, you know, scale up from there, and where do you put it? You know, it's, that's a lot of tonnes.
Ben Franta:
Totally, it is a lot of tons and every year, absolutely, it's a massive scale. And of course, all everything about this is basically at a massive scale, of course, and that is hard to comprehend, and really wrap our minds around. And, you know, if we did have major carbon capture, as part of the energy economy, then we would have to have a huge transport infrastructure to transport all of that, that co2, you know, and pump it. And, you know, as a sidebar, another thing I think about is, most of the cost estimates for carbon capture have been technical cost estimates, you know, how much does it cost in terms of energy, to actually, you know, separate out the gas, compress it transported, pump it, you know, injected underground to an reservoir. And, you know, in reality, this would also include things like monitoring costs, to make sure didn't, you know, leak leak or something insurance, you know, all of these regulatory sort of permitting costs. And, you know, I think a lot of that has so far just been ignored. Mostly, I mean, I might be wrong about that. If I am, of course, you know, I'm happy to be to learn about that more, but, um, from what I've seen, the cost might be even greater than have been estimated. In reality, and so I, this is sort of, you know, I said, I didn't want to speculate earlier, but I'm going to speculate now, which is that you have seen the fossil fuel companies, the major oil companies, pushing this carbon capture narrative, saying, it's, it's a necessity, it's inevitable, we have to have it, and then pushing for major pipeline infrastructure to be built now, in preparation for that, and asking for the cost to be socialized, you know, for the government to subsidize, building out massive pipeline infrastructure, which they will then use right now for natural gas, right, with the promise that they're eventually going to use it for carbon capture. So there is an interesting sort of strategic action here. I think of the oil companies trying to lock that in sort of infrastructurally like, well, we built this and now we sort of have to do it, you know, and, and maybe that's how they see themselves staying in business, you know, for the long term is being the sort of service provider, because, you know, frankly, that does fall within their core expertise, you know, compressing fluids and pumping them and injecting them and things like that. So it that falls into their expertise in a way that renewable energy often really doesn't, you know, because it's just a, it's a very different business involving very different technologies and training and things like that. That's a little bit of speculation as to perhaps what their strategic direction we won't
Tom Raftery:
go into the record with spills and things like that. No, no. Yeah. We're coming towards the the end of the podcast now, Ben, are you optimistic for the future? Given everything we've talked about?
Ben Franta:
You know, it's, I mean, the short answer is, I feel like we have a lot of agency. What happens with climate change is going to be up to us. And it's going to be up to what we do in the next, you know, few years. In the way I think about it is the next decade is going to be absolutely crucial. For the next 1000s of years, hundreds to 1000s of years, right? If we think about it, realistically, next decade is crucial and a decade is not that long a decade is you know, three, you know, through three and a third long periods, or it's so, you know, it's really incumbent upon us to, to act boldly To do what needs to be done, and here's why I feel, you know, energized is the solution to climate change dallisa sufficient and necessary and sufficient one is to replace fossil fuels as our as our, you know, energy source. Of course, there are other sources of greenhouse gases. But if we replace fossil fuels, you know, then we'll have avoided that kind of crisis, in a sense, right. And so the NSA, in a way, the solution is simple. It's not necessarily easy, but it's clear. And so to me, anything that accelerates that process, that replacement, you know, is something that should be pursued. And that kind of gives clarity to the issue. And that's why I think, you know, uncovering this information, communicating it, we talked about legal action, all of this is very empowering, because, you know, we can, we can actually do this. So, I don't really ever say I'm optimistic or pessimistic, because they're more of like feelings, then, you know, ideas in a way. But I think that it's up to us now, you know, it's up to us now to, to do everything we can to to, to avoid this problem, and to set the course of the future in a good way.
Tom Raftery:
Cool. As I said, we're coming towards the end of the podcast. Is there any question I have not asked that you wish I had, or any aspect of this, that we've not touched on that you think it's important for people to think about?
Ben Franta:
I don't think so. You know, I think the only thing is that this podcast is part of the solution. And by that, I mean, over the last decade, we've seen a massive broadening of, of the tent of climate action. You know, I mean, it wasn't that long ago that it was mostly scientists and economists and sort of technical discussion occurring around climate change. And, you know, that was woefully inadequate, because climate is largely a political issue, as well, as we found through all this research and looking at the political obstruction by vested interests and incumbents and things like that. So I think it's very important that more and more people are brought into this, this issue brought into this struggle. It's one reason I think social movements are so important. And, you know, just, we need everyone. Yeah, you know, we need everyone we need everyone's talents brought to bear on this issue. So I think the public the communication part, and just the conversation, the discussion that this podcast exemplifies is it's part of that. Right? So I'm so I'm, you know, I'm very happy to see this and, and I think it should give it give us a cost to smile, you know, cause for for some some help here.
Tom Raftery:
Super, super. Thanks, Ben. Ben, that's been really great. Thanks, a million for coming on the podcast today.
Ben Franta:
Absolutely. Thank you very much for having me. Okay, we've
Tom Raftery:
come to the end of the show. Thanks, everyone for listening. If you'd like to know more about climate 21, feel free to drop me an email to Tom raftery@sap.com or connect with me on LinkedIn or Twitter. If you'd like the show, please don't forget to subscribe to it and your podcast application of choice to get new episodes as soon as they're published. Also, please don't forget to rate and review the podcast it really does help new people to find the show. Thanks. Catch you all next