Climate Confident - Practical Climate Solutions That Cut Emissions
Climate Confident is for business leaders, climate professionals and policymakers who need to understand what is actually cutting emissions—and what it takes to make those solutions work at scale.
Each Wednesday, technology and sustainability analyst, keynote speaker and former SAP Global VP Tom Raftery speaks with the executives, engineers, scientists, founders and policymakers turning climate ambition into measurable progress. Together, they examine the technologies, business models, policies and implementation strategies reshaping energy, transport, industry, supply chains, food and finance.
These are not conversations about distant targets, vague pledges or greenwash. They are candid discussions about what is working, what is failing, where the real bottlenecks lie, and how leaders can make better decisions about decarbonisation, resilience, investment and risk.
You will hear:
Proven approaches to reducing emissions
Hard-earned lessons from real-world implementation
Analysis of the markets, technologies and policies driving the transition
Honest examination of costs, trade-offs, setbacks and unintended consequences
Practical ideas for turning climate commitments into action
New episodes are published every Wednesday at 7am CET. Subscribers also receive bonus episodes featuring highlights, analysis and emerging themes from across the series.
Follow Climate Confident for practical climate solutions, informed debate and the insights you need to turn ambition into measurable progress.
Welcome to another joint Digital Supply Chain and Climate 21 podcast episode. The reason this is a joint podcast is that today's topic - the electrification of transportation is relevant to both podcasts.
Today's podcast guest is James Carter. James is a Mobility Futurist, Thought Leader and Influencer, and he is the Principal Consultant at Vision Mobility.
We talked in the podcast about the climate implications of the electrification of transportation, whether hydrogen has a place in transport, and why electrification is coming to fleet vehicles.
This was a truly fascinating episode of the podcast and I learned loads as always, and I hope you do too.
If you have any comments/suggestions or questions for the podcast - feel free to leave me a voice message over on my SpeakPipe page, head on over to the Climate 21 Podcast Forum, or just send it to me as a direct message on Twitter/LinkedIn. Audio messages will get played (unless you specifically ask me not to).
Podcast subscribers I'd like to sincerely thank this podcast's amazing subscribers:
Anita Krajnc
Cecilia Skarupa
Ben Gross
Jerry Sweeney
Andreas Werner
Stephen Carroll
Roger Arnold
And remember you too can Subscribe to the Podcast - it is really easy and hugely important as it will enable me to continue to create more excellent Climate Confident episodes like this one, as well as give you access to the entire back catalog of Climate Confident episodes.
🎤 Looking for a keynote speaker on climate, energy, AI, or sustainability?
I help executive audiences understand the technologies, trends, and decisions shaping the low-carbon transition.
Download my Speaker Pack: https://tinyurl.com/spkrpck
And a quick note before you go: I’ve started a new Reddit community for serious, evidence-led discussion on climate solutions, clean energy, decarbonisation, policy, technology, and what actually works in practice.
If you’d like to suggest future guests, challenge ideas from the show, or share climate reports and solutions worth discussing, join us at r/ClimateConfident
Introduce Yourself
Vision Mobility
Are Electric Vehicles Better For The Environment
Hydrogen?
Hydrogen for Trucks?
Battery Electric Vehicles For Fleets?
Electric Vehicle Maintenance
Fleet Managers' Biggest Challenge Moving To EVs
Any Question I Haven't Asked You?
Where To Find More
James Carter:
Firstly, I think the thing to point out is hydrogen fuel cell vehicles and battery electric vehicles are zero emission. And the really important thing about that is they don't put pollution around where we live. So we're healthier our kids are healthier our cities have less small and and that is so critically important because we know that millions of people have their life expectancy reduced every year by by smog emissions.
Tom Raftery:
Good morning, good afternoon or good evening wherever you are in the world. This is the climate 21 podcast the number one podcast showcasing best practices in climate emissions reductions. And I'm your host, global vice president for SAP Tom Raftery. Climate 21 is the name of an initiative by SAP to allow our customers calculate, report and reduce their greenhouse gas emissions. In this climate 21 podcast, I will showcase best practices and thought leadership by SAP, by our customers by our partners on by our competitors if their game in climate emissions reductions. Don't forget to subscribe to this podcast in your podcast app of choice to be sure you don't miss any episodes. Hi, everyone. Welcome to another joint episode of the climate 21 and digital supply chain podcasts. We don't do these very often. This is the second one if I if memory serves correctly, so welcome aboard. My special guest today is James James, would you like to introduce yourself? And let's see why we're doing a joint episode.
James Carter:
Yeah, no worries. Thanks. It's really great to have to be here, Tom. And again. Thanks for having me. My name is James Carter, and I'm Principal Consultant of vision mobility. I live here in Toronto, Canada.
Tom Raftery:
And that's a strong Toronto accent. You don't have their Jamie,
James Carter:
I'm very definitely not from Toronto. I'm Australian by background, but it's I've been here for 15 years now. So it's I guess it's home. So
Tom Raftery:
okay, and tell me a little bit about vision mobility. And that might give us a clue as to why this is a joint podcast.
James Carter:
Yeah, totally. So actually, I'll give you a two second overview of my background. My background is, as I mentioned, I'm Australian. And I worked for Toyota for nearly 20 years in the Australian head office, then in TMC, Japan for a couple of years. And then more late more recently at Toyota Canada. In 2015, I left Toyota and started vision mobility. And what it is, is a consultancy that really looks ahead for the future of mobility, the future of transportation, what is the future of automotive and really starting to deeply understand how the changes particularly driven by the impacts of new technologies, the case technologies, connected, autonomous, shared and electric, really impact different industries that are out there. And it's not just automotive, there's huge change, huge changes and knock on effects. And I think what we're seeing is transportation becoming one huge big industry rather than these different siloed industries that we've previously seen. So, but right now, as we're going through this change, it's such an exciting time to be around this industry. And it's just, it's the first time in, you know, 100 or 100 plus years that we've seen such a dynamic change to an industry like this.
Tom Raftery:
Yeah. I mean, people who have listened to me on podcasts before, maybe aware because I have mentioned it a few times. I'm a big fan of electric vehicles and the electrification of transport in general. And hence the the joint podcast because this is essentially mostly what we'll be talking about on this podcast, James is the electrification of transportation. And it has, you know, huge implications for climate emissions, fossil fuel reduction, and also huge implications for fleets. So hence the supply chain, because fleets of vehicles will start electrifying, shortly. So let's, let's talk about the fossil fuel one first and the whole climate implications. So you hear lots of people criticizing electric vehicles saying yeah, but they run on coal grids, you know, are electric vehicles better for the environment? Or not? You
James Carter:
know, great question. And and I think one of the things that we really need to understand is we need to step back from, you know, our analysis of you know, little parts of why electric vehicles might be better or worse, why I see internal combustion vehicles are better or worse or you know, even hydrogen the same and look at everything in context. So take all those pluses and minuses in context and understand on balance or on total hot, what is going to be better for the environment and and a pretty clear picture emerges, what we see is, firstly, I think the thing to point out is that hydrogen fuel cell vehicles, and electric battery electric vehicles are zero emission. And the really important thing about that is they don't put pollution around where we live. So we're healthier, our kids are healthier, our cities have less smoke. And and that is so critically important because we know that millions of people have their life expectancy reduced every year by by smog emissions. And I think it's really critical to understand that no, we need to reduce that to improve our own human health. So I think that is the first point to understand. The second point that we need to understand is, is greenhouse emissions or co2 emissions. And when we step back and have a look at that to what we see, if we have a look at the absolute worst case for electric vehicles, is that they're running on 100% Coal grid, and typically, you will see emissions, perhaps around the 800 brands co2 per kilowatt hour. So at that point, typically, you're you're at a what I would call a roughly breakeven in terms of actual running costs, not not including the production emissions of the vehicle. In you know, perhaps the, the, you know, Evie might even be slightly behind. But this is this really narrow subset of places where where EVs are, sorry, coal powered fire stations, coal fired power stations, 100% of the grid, you know, mostly there's some sort of balancing there with renewables or nuclear or something else. And if you look at the best case, for electric vehicles for co2 emissions, and and I think where I live right here in Toronto, Canada is one of those best cases we write here we have 40 grams a kilowatt hour co2 emissions. So when I did the math, and we're not including production efficiency, but when I did the math, to compare our previous car, which was a you know, fun Subaru Varex, you know, fun sporty car, to our newer fun sporty car being a Tesla Model three, that was a 97% drop in our, our personal our own household footprint for our transportation, and that is dramatic. In fact, if you're living in an area, like where we are here, the best single thing you can do to reduce your co2 footprint is by an electric vehicle. Now, if we go back and have a look at something like average of Europe, or average of us now, there's somewhere between 354 50 grams per kilowatt hour of electric co2 per kilowatt hour of electricity produced, you're still well ahead. So once you look at you used to roughly about half the emissions on in terms of running costs. Now I think the other thing we need to bring into this as is say, Well, what about production emissions, because you've really got these two things going on in vehicles, its production emissions of the vehicle itself, plus the running emissions. So if we have a look at the production emissions, quite typically, an Eevee will have near roughly 25 to 30% more co2 emissions in its production, because the batteries are fairly co2 intensive. However, if you are in a place like where we are in here in Toronto, those production emissions are essentially paid off, or it becomes better than the you know, becomes positive after about 18,000 kilometers of running. Now that's really low one year. And from then on for the next 15 years. typical life cycle of a vehicle, your car is getting better and better and better every year. In fact, at the end of those 15 years, you're somewhere between us somewhere between two to three bye ahead. In terms of reductions in emissions. If you take a more average grid that we're talking about, the payback is slow. It could be 40 or 50,000 kilometers that you know that happens. But once you look at the lifecycle of the vehicle, then you can see these significant reductions occurring. So what I'm saying here is it's a long winded way of saying that EVs are much better. And I think on balance, you know, we need to understand just how much better they are and because we see more and more renewables coming every year, the balance all that improvements in co2 emissions reduction, EVS actually improved that their reduction in co2 every year, and that is such a critical thing to remember.
Tom Raftery:
Yeah. And another another point I would make, just because I have done it myself is you can purchase an Eevee. And then contact your local electricity providers and find one that gives you a 100% renewable tariff and or stick solar panels on your roof. And that way, you know, you reduce that 40 Gram co2 per kilowatt hour down to zero, right, you know, that that brings your 17,000 maybe down to 10,000 or something seminar, so you've paid it off in six months or whatever, you know, totally, these are kind of things that you cannot do with an internal combustion engine vehicle, you you cannot get fossil free petrol or diesel, you cannot, you know, install a petrol pump in your own garage and have it be fossil fuel free or solar panels to create petrol. No, but you probably could, but would you want to, you know, so
James Carter:
that's exactly it like, and hydrogen, I'm not sure if I want to put some hydrogen tanks in my backyard either. Might be a bit of critical, maddening, whatever.
Tom Raftery:
It's an thank you for bringing up hydrogen, because you know that that's one that you hear people talking about a lot. And my, my impression of hydrogen is, you know, it's a bit like, I've called it on another podcast, unicorn farts all nice in theory, but it did, the people that I see, pushing hydrogen generally tend to be people who are fossil fuel company, or adjacent. So, and it has me thinking that it's got a very similar model where you've got a liquid fuel, okay, gaseous liquid fuel, that's distributed from particular fueling stations. And you have large distributors manufacturing it, destroying it, distributing it to these retail outlets, where you drive to and fuel your car. So it's got a very similar business model. So that alone makes it attractive to fossil fuel companies, you got to think that's very little they have to change in that scenario. But also, the really worrying thing is that, and I'm, I may be wrong in the numbers here, by a small bit of luck, but I'm right in the orders of magnitude. Currently, about 97% of hydrogen is manufactured by steam fracturing hydrogen, methane, so makes it a de facto fossil fuel. And I think I read that it takes about, or it's the production of a kilo of hydrogen produces 10 to 12 kilos of co2 On a typical grid. But if but a lot of the world's hydrogen today is made in China, where it's closer to 20 kilos, co2 per kilo of hydrogen, does that. Is that correct?
James Carter:
Yeah. So from what I understand, and you can, I think there might be some listeners on the podcast, who could who could probably correct us a little bit, but I think we're pretty close here is that around 90% 97%, or 98%, somewhere in there of hydrogen production is fossil fuel production, ie, when you produce hydrogen, there's a significant amount of co2 released into the atmosphere. In other words, when you have 98%, of hydrogen produced from fossil fuels, you can essentially call it a fossil fuel. And that's the message that I want to get across to people that hydrogen is essentially a fossil fuel, because almost all of it comes from fossil fuels. And the point you made about China is really important. And it happens in Australia too. Because when we have a look at that 97%, typically we split it up into steam made me think before forming which you I think you're right around somewhere between eight and 12 kilograms co2 per kilogram, but you also have our from coal gasification. And that's the big one in China. And that's somewhere between 20 or 30% of the world's production from that, and that, as you said, is somewhere between 18 to 20 kilograms of co2 per kilogram of hydrogen produced and when you look at coal gasification and hydrogen production, that's much worse than I see vehicles running on petrol or diesel. And that's what we've got to remember is, if we go towards fossil fuel, hydrogen, were either roughly the same as I see or a hybrid I see in terms of steam methane reforming, or we're taking a huge huge step back. So in other words, it is hydrogen for transportation is not a pathway to net zero or, you know, reducing significantly reducing carbon emissions in our economy today, obviously, with if we look at Green hydrogen, which is made through electrolysis from from renewable electricity, that's going to bring those numbers down dramatically. And, but but here's the problem with green hydrogen, and we've got to be really careful with it is that its efficiency is poor. So if you put electricity into making hydrogen, and then you convert that hydrogen back to electricity, or putting, you know, led into the electric motors for the wheels in your vehicle, like if you're driving an MRI, then you lose essentially, somewhere between 60 and 70% of that energy, were an electric vehicle, you would batteries, you only lose maybe 10 to 15%. So it's, it's a huge problem, because suddenly, you, you now have to put three times as much energy into that same vehicle to run it. So if you take a model three and MRI, that model three is essentially three times plus more efficient or uses three times. It uses 1/3 of the electricity as an arrival. And it's super important to understand. So when you have a look at hydrogen options, you either have this super inefficient method or the super polluting mesh methods. It's really to me a, a serious problem that we have to understand and know. And it's why I say, hydrogen for transportation is a really bad option.
Tom Raftery:
Yeah, yeah, no, totally agree. We should really, because this is the joint podcast, we should really switch on over to talking a little bit about fleets of vehicles at least. And I think this is a good juncture to do that, because we're talking about hydrogen. And typically, the the use case that's put forward for hydrogen now is very rarely personal vehicles anymore, it was a few years ago, but that seems to have died down. And now the use case that's put forward is trucking, the kind of the 40 ton trucks, the 18 wheelers. So is it a is that a good use case for hydrogen.
James Carter:
So here's the thing about us with hydrogen, the, the problems don't go away. And you scale it up the problems just so that's, that's the real problem, suddenly, you've got this truck, that's three times more, you know, energy inefficient, if you go green hydrogen, and you know, is is as dirty as a diesel, if you use steam, methane reforming, or coal gasification, hydrogen, adding, obviously, in coal gasification, it's much worse. So these are the problems that don't go away, there are, there are things that change the picture a little bit, where you can essentially store more energy on board, a hydrogen vehicle, then you can have battery electric. So potentially, there might be some small weight reductions potential versus a battery electric vehicle, potentially, you know, you might be able to have a longer range out of this vehicle. But there's a lot of that the industry is still fairly nascent. And some of these things are still a little unknown. But there are some things that I think we can say or understand about hydrogen in terms of those, both those weight conditions, and terms of those range conditions. So firstly, it's worth looking at the Tesla semi truck, which hopefully will be launched in the next few months. And as four months, four years behind. It's, it's an issue of showing but this truck is really important. And the reason it's important is because the efficiency claims and the range claims that Tesla's made now, obviously, because it's not yet in the marketplace. There is some it's yet to be really proven out. However, I think given Tesla's record on on their range, and their efficiency that even if it's roughly in the ballpark, which you know, I believe it will be roughly at least roughly in the ballpark. This is a complete game changer because you're getting now 500 miles or 800 kilometers of range out of that vehicle. And when you look at a hydrogen truck, right around the same number, when you look at weights now wait is really important because, you know, for trucks No, generally companies get paid by how much weight they shift. However, there's a couple things here one I'm I, my gut feel tells me and there's not more than gut feel and some other engineers who are reading it that this Tesla semi will weigh less than some fuel cell hydrogen trucks out there. And one of the reasons is, is we've already seen Tesla Model three quite a bit lighter than a Toyota Mirai, and it's two or 300 pounds lighter. So you know, the potential that it that it scales up to be lighter is there but not necessarily 100%. The other thing that's really important is having a look at use case for truss. The first thing we need to know is that when we have look at the NAC Fe data, the National Council with great efficiency, here in North America, what we found is 75% of loads aren't near the maximum weight. So even if we have some increase in weight over diesel trucks, 75% of that market is still available to take loads, you know, within the weight range of the semi truck. The next thing that's important is is understanding what the weight and when it was was there other weight and Oh, distance load this distance. So again, the same sort of things happen is that most of the freight, or most of the trips for trucks is under 400 kilometers, so well within that range of that Tesla semi, and also well within the range of the 300 mile Tesla semi that they'll also be offering. So, these are really important because what we can say is that 5060 70% of the use cases out there today for trucks can be met with a Tesla semi Now I know some of these what I would call generation one trucks, things like that the Volvo BNR the Cascadia from Mercedes and Freightliner these tend to be what's you know, shorter range, you know, maybe 100 150 200 mile type range and you know, more affected by cold weather and things like that. So to me that like the those vehicles are like the Nissan LEAF that we sell our 1011 2012 short range vehicles and a bit of a compression on what really the vehicle can be used for gen two trucks in Eb trucks like Tesla semi like whatever's behind for Mercedes and Scania. And others, I really believe we're going to be matching those top types of range requirements. The other thing that's super important to understand with a hydrogen versus BV comparison is refueling times. And we know that hydrogen typically for trap, you're going to be in around 1015 minutes, the refueling could be more because the pumps behind it might may have to recruit we we pressurize that the hydrogen in behind the pump tax. But as we talked about before was was would you put hydrogen at home would you there's typically not as many diesel available at depo either. But with electric trucks you can. And by having depo charging at electric trucks. It's a huge time saving because truck drivers don't have to stop the fuel while are out in the road. So we calculated that even if there's more stops needed for an electric truck. And with depo charging, there's actually a 50% reduction in the times that drivers have had to stop to refuel their vehicles for electric vehicles versus hydrogen or diesel. And that's really super important to remember depo charging is a real breakthrough and a time saving. The second thing that's really important to understand in this refueling scenario is this megawatt charging standard that's being put together and adopted by all the major trucking truck OEMs. So, you know, we've got Daimler Trucks there. And now one of the leaders on this we have trade time we have a Tesla we have all those big semi trucks, companies, Volvo and Alba on this working hard to produce a standard that has room past three and a half megawatts for charging typically you may not see that maybe it's in the one to two range. But what that enables is trucks to recharge to 80% within the drivers 30 minute rest break. So in other words that because they can charge within the rest break They actually don't need to that there's actually not essentially an increase in time on the road. And this is a great, this really opens up the ability for our over the road tracking. So super important to understand.
Tom Raftery:
And what about a cost comparison of, let's say, kilowatts of electricity versus kilos of hydrogen versus litres of diesel?
James Carter:
Yeah, it's a very, very good question. At today's prices, hydrogen is astronomically expensive. Typically, prices that we see in North America are 17 to $18, a kilogram Canadian around $14 us a Europe I believe, it could be, you know, 10 to 12 euros. So
Tom Raftery:
how far do you get with a kilo of hydrogen just, you know, let
James Carter:
it drop. So in a car, typically, you would use about a very best case for a marine would use about one kilogram per 100 kilometers with a truck, you essentially times that by eight or nine. So once you do the math out, you'll see that a, I believe most of them are quoting around that. Yeah, the nine ish mark of Mercedes, sorry, the Hyundai truck is right around there, too. But once you multiply that out on the cost versus electricity, it's, it's shocking. It's unbelievable. Unbelievably different. So for instance, when we did the math on electric truck versus a hydrogen truck, in today's price, well, and I assumed 10 cents a kilowatt hour. For, for trucks, essentially, using a hydrogen truck, it's 12 times the energy costs. Now, if you reduce that, down to our friends, you might remember our friends, Nikola, who Nikola trucks, Nikola trucks that had their, you know, Chairman, indicted, you know, that guy is when they they pre IPO or pre SPAC merger, what they did is they released an investor report and what they you know, using their numbers off that you can, you can make a judgment call is whether those numbers are accurate or not, they were making an assumption that they were going to make green hydrogen $2.49 A kilogram now, $2.49 a kilogram, the green hydrogen versus you know, steamy, thin reformed hydrogen at $14 A kilogram. Okay, all right, let's take them at their word. We found and, and in fact, that quote that in the, the prospectus that they can only just get to diesel, total cost operation with those numbers. However, electricity, electric trucks, so battery electric trucks that are another 30% 40%, lower again, in their energy energy usage. So you've got this dramatic difference going on in terms of the cost around so. So to repeat that, again, even if hydrogen is is $2.50 kilogram, they are only just competitive, competitive with diesel and not nearly competitive with battery electric trucks. So it's a massive difference, you know, that's going on. And we also see a massive difference in terms of the cost associated with electric trucks and hydrogen trucks, there are at least another 30% More again, so you know, I can't see how the, the hydrogen truck thing is going to pay off for anyone, even with long haul. You just can't wear that three by multiple of cost increase or you know, 12 by multiple increase with with regards to prices today, so I just can't see that happen.
Tom Raftery:
Yeah, I took a look at the, the numbers on my own car I have an ID for and I've done eight and a half 1000 kilometers on it so far. Got an April. So I don't do a lot of driving, but still eight and a half 1000 kilometers averaging 19 kilowatts per 100 kilometers. So you're saying that the hydrogen, one kilogram of hydrogen would get you 100 kilometers, so that's equal to 19 kilowatt hours and my electricity provider provides 100% renewable overnight electricity at nine cent per kilowatt hour. That's for the sake of maths let's make a 10 cent per kilowatt hour. So that's one euro 90 cent for 100 kilometers. Compared to you said, I think a kilo of hydrogen in Europe is around 10 to 12 euros. So yeah, right. The second make no sense in that scenario.
James Carter:
No. And the other really important thing is you said you use 19 kilowatts, hours per 100 kilometers. And we also said that a Mariah will use about one kilogram. Now it takes if we look at green, renewable electricity, it takes about 60 to three kilowatt hours of electricity to make one kilogram. So there's that three by a number we talked about earlier. So, you know, it's it's a real problem that, you know, essentially any hydrogen vehicle is going using green hydrogen is going to cost you three by more.
Tom Raftery:
So let's dump hydrogen, it's, we we've we've thrown it out, was trashed it completely. It's not it's not an option. So full battery electric vehicles, particularly for fleets. Why are they better? I mean, apart from the emissions, which we dealt with at the start, other than that, what's the advantage for a fleet operator of having battery electric vehicles over diesel? Yeah,
James Carter:
that's a good question. The first one that we alluded to before is cost that there is a significant cost reduction. You know, if we just look at our, you know, personal vehicles right there, you know, I don't know how many, you said 10 cents, you know, I would have said a euro 90 per 100 kilometers, maybe you would have cost you what, 1210 12 euros per 100 kilometers to fuel if you had a diesel SUV, maybe somewhere in there. So
Tom Raftery:
my my previous car was, well, my previous car was a leaf. But before that, again, my previous car was a Prius. So you're seeing a trend there. The Prius I was getting, let's call it, when I drove it hard, it would be six liters per 100 kilometers, with a liter coming in here at around six, that sorry, coming in here at around one euro 30 per liter. So that's six, that's about nine euros per 100 kilometers versus the 190. Well, 170 something actually, but anyway, we call it 192 rounded out. So nine euros versus 192 years.
James Carter:
I reckon if you had a diesel SUV, you would be another 50% off on that. bracket. Like Prius is a nice aerodynamic car. Id four is a bit higher art, more wind resistance, all that. I reckon if you had I don't know what a Ford Kuga or, you know, whatever the Volkswagen, maybe take one. Yeah, yeah, you would be, you'd got to be another 50%. above that. And I think that's the real difference here is that, you know, electric, that cost to run, what we also hear from please to especially fleets more and more these days, they have an ESG mandate that the companies are looking at, you know, how can we improve our environmental, social and government governance policies to make sure that, you know, we're the best company we can be. And the reason that companies have got such a strong focus on it, is that investors have such a strong focus on it today. And this has been a game game changer over the last year. And so there's that starting to really look at every part of their business on how they can reduce emissions. And, and a really obvious one in terms of fleets is his vehicle emissions themselves. And, you know, you know, we went back to go back to talking about, you know, this huge reduction that that of co2 emissions that we said at the start, it's, it's such a, it's such an easy way for fleets to really improve their ESG mandate by switching to electric. So you've got this cost saving, or at least operational cost saving plus this this ESG mandate, you know, co2 component as well. What I think fleets need to understand and just any buyer needs to understand is that these vehicles do cost quite a bit more to run, but often on balance over the time that you're going to own his vehicle, say 567 years, whatever it turns out to be more often than not, you're going to be ahead. And I think that's the real key message that we need to get across from fleets. The other really cool thing that I see happening with fleets is no going back to you your statement, you know, buying green electricity off the grid and making sure that you can do that. The ability of some of the new fleet management tools to really tap into these these, you know, energy type management and situation things is really important. So that fleets can buy green electricity when they can fleets can, you know, get the charging when they need, you know, so these things are really starting to come together and be really important.
Tom Raftery:
And what about maintenance, because that's another big cost for fleet managers as well.
James Carter:
Totally. There's a huge reduction that we're seeing, you know, we've had our tests Model three for two and a half years now and we had his first service the other day. So essentially, our maintenance costs for the first two years were was zero apart from the washer fluid that I put in. And so, and me paying my girls to clean the car, so labor by my actual spend on on maintenance, car maintenance has been close to zero. And unfortunately, my goals is still young, so they work fairly cheap. So
Tom Raftery:
I remember when I collected the leaf, I got a 40 kilowatt hour leaf was my first full electric car, I got it and 2018. And I remember when I collected it from the Nissan dealership, and the guy handed me the maintenance book and I opened it up. And the first scheduled maintenance was at 30,000 kilometers. So it, it's I saw a Consumer Reports report come out about electric vehicles saying that they cost something just under 50% of the cost is the cost for maintenance of electric vehicles versus internal combustion engines. And it stands to reason because they have very few moving parts, you know, compared to internal combustion engines these days are becoming increasingly complex because of the significantly greater regulations around vehicle emissions that they have to meet. And so they're actually becoming more expensive to manufacture quite at the same time, the cost of manufacturing EVs is dropping, the cost of their maintenance are staying flat.
James Carter:
Exactly right. And I think you know, we all need to realize that, you know, an internal combustion engine vehicle, particularly today is an incredibly complex beast. And there is a lot to go wrong. And at the same time, totally recognize that vehicles are much, much more reliable than they used to be. But I know when things break, they break big, and you have to open out your wallet. But you know, I think that simple fact, and I'm sure you found it when you went from your Prius, which was still, you know, a very good icy hybrid vehicle to your, you know, Id for annual leave was simply that no oil changes. And you don't have to regularly go to your dealer every six months to get this oil change done. It's it's just non existent. And so, you know, the first time I went back to the Tesla dealer was after two years. And here's something really interesting when
Tom Raftery:
you got the timing belt change, was it. What's that, that was to get the timing belt changed was it there's no timing belt in electric vehicles people.
James Carter:
The reason why we went back after two years was because in cold climates, like here in Canada, they'll often put salt on the roads to melt the snow and ice. And salt is not good for cars at all and cause rust out here. And they tend to, you know, you get lots of rust on even things like brake components. And because of the lack of use of brakes and electric vehicles, because it's all you're using the the regenerative braking all the time, you actually have to have the brakes serviced to be lubricated to make sure that they don't seize up now, and not a big job. But it's one I guess it's a new job that, you know, is needed for maintenance. But I guess it astounded me that you have to get the brake service because of lack of probably, actually, because there's too much use, I remember, we had a BMW three series and the year before we got rid of it, you know, I had to do the RE of brakes, and it was 1000 bots, and I'm going What the heck, you know, like, Ah, so, you know, I'm very happy that I don't have to do brakes probably ever again.
Tom Raftery:
And for for fleet managers who are thinking of making the move, what do you think is their biggest challenge? I mean, is it is it sourcing, suitable electric vehicles? Is that putting charging infrastructure in place? Is just learning about EVs in general, what's their what's their biggest challenge? Yeah,
James Carter:
there's three big challenges that I see. One is understanding what the use case is. So I'm not going to lie for some use cases it's going to be tougher to adopt an electric vehicle than it is an IC right now. So firstly, understanding how easy is it is to switch over to an electric vehicle so there is a bit of a still a lack of product, especially in the commercial market vehicle market, especially in North America, that things like pickups bands aren't yet readily available. So I think that's that's one big problem to start with. Is there a vehicle out there, that's electric that fits your use case, the second is charging. Firstly, understanding that use case is super important, but putting the infrastructure in behind it, and then monitoring your vehicles, you know, electricity usage, it can be a little bit of a challenge to set up. For bigger vehicles, you may actually have to get utility involved and say, you know, I need a megawatt of power coming into this thing now, and there could be some, you know, fairly significant additional costs behind that. But in terms of light vehicles, unless there's a huge lot of light vehicles at one location, it's not necessarily going to be that challenging, particularly, because you'll typically use level two, overnight charging. And the third thing is, is really starting to get your head around the cost component, because you have this much higher upfront capital cost and a much lower operating costs. Typically, budgets are set up for fleets to reflect today's ice vehicles, you know, lower cap costs, higher OPEX costs. So how do you kind of merge these things together and make that work in a in a new budget tree framework, it's really just an accounting problem. However, what we do here is quite a bit of pushback that it doesn't match up and being able to have that, you know, conversation with the EU finance department about what this new new thing will look like, really is something that's important.
Tom Raftery:
Interesting. Okay. James, we're coming towards the end of the podcast. Now, is there any questions that I have not asked that you wish I had, or any aspect of this that we've not touched on that you think it's important for people to think about?
James Carter:
Yeah, you know, I think there's a couple of things, you know, one of the, well, I'm gonna start with one, and then this is just going over really what we've talked about before, but you know, in terms of some things that really drive me, and that's how can we do the best thing for our environment. And I think people really, they hear stuff and take snippets of stuff, but I really encourage people to understand in detail and make their own judgments about what they see is important from that for hydrogen versus electric vehicles versus other things like that. Do your own research, don't just look at, you know, the stuff that you know, one company or another is putting out have a look at from a scientific point of view and have a look at the overall landscape and make up your own mind. That is so super important. And so super critical to how I see the way that we need to think about our environmental future, not just the transportation, but for energy for everything.
Tom Raftery:
Okay, super. James, if people want to know more about yourself, or about vision, mobility, or any of the topics we discussed today, where would you have me direct them?
James Carter:
Yeah, so they can go to our website, which is vision mobility.ca. ca for Canada, so please go and take a look there. Even though we are based in Canada, we do do a lot of work globally. In fact, most of our work is either in us or your please take a look at that you can get in contact with me through the website on there. And you know, please also follow me on LinkedIn. It's LinkedIn slash James Carter Toronto, I believe there's 38,000 or something followers right now I do publish quite regularly on that. So on my thoughts about you know, transportation about you know, electric vehicles, and and our environment. So really encourage people to follow me on LinkedIn and see what I'm talking about.
Tom Raftery:
Super, super app. James. That's been fantastic. Thanks. A million for coming on the podcasts today.
James Carter:
Wonderful. Thanks so much for having me, Tom.
Tom Raftery:
Okay, we've come to the end of the show. Thanks, everyone for listening. If you'd like to know more about climate 21 Feel free to drop me an email to Tom raftery@sap.com or connect with me on LinkedIn or Twitter. If you like the show, please don't forget to subscribe to it and your podcast application of choice to get new episodes as soon as they're published. Also, please don't forget to rate and review the podcast it really does help new people to find the show. Thanks. Catch you all next time.